After The Bahamas, Are You Rethinking Expectations For The Season??

Hall-O-Daze

Sophomore
Jan 8, 2020
122
185
43
I mean, granted, we've been heartbroken and burned more than a few times based on some promising early season results - seems to come with the territory. That said, it seemed like expectations were fairly low pretty much across the board after the first few contests.

Then, we lost last Friday, but we put up one helluva fight under very tough circumstances. Now these two big time(for now), clutch non-conference wins.

Has anything changed for you?
 

Pirates94

Freshman
Dec 21, 2021
73
64
18
Honestly, no idea. I no longer have expectations going into the season with the new NIL league. I get a feel for the team about 1/4 way into conference schedule. When you turn over 90% of your team year after year us really hard to have expectations. Not their fault, it’s what they’ve done to all college sports. Between paying players million and letting guys play against women, the NCAA has become a joke.
 

hallmatt

Sophomore
Dec 1, 2018
171
144
43
I didn’t have high expectations, so I have to say yes.

The Wisconsin win doesn’t hold a lot of weight, imo.

The Nc State win holds a good amount. That was a great win! Very resilient team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PirateBlue08

HALL85

Heisman
Jul 5, 2001
30,664
12,211
113
Still sticking with 9-11 BE prediction but with upside . Playing with a lot of energy especially on defense and that tempo is having an effect other teams

Brown comes out of nowhere tonight with instant offense. Copeland took over in OT. Parker making big plays.

Interesting that three players averaging 11 ppg and another five averaging over 7 ppg. And that doesn’t include Petro and Wilcher at 5 ppg. Maybe the balance and depth is this teams image.

Need to take care of business in next six.
 
Last edited:

Halldan

All-American
Staff member
Jan 1, 2003
187,115
9,969
113
I had us 10-10 in conference. But I would be lying after 3 games to say I had any confidence in that prediction. Now watching (for the most part) how poorly some of the teams are playing it once again looks like SJU and UConn are far ahead of the rest of the league. Meaning 10-10 is back in play.
 

SHUSource

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
42,249
4,694
48
This is kind of what I was quietly confident in. I liked the pieces on the roster; my biggest concern was the lack of a real quality point guard after Budd took the money and ran.

Still, you never know how it’s going to come together or how long it will take when it does. So I was hoping these guys would jell by the Bahamas, and it seems like they did. Maybe the experience in Tuscaloosa was good for them: adverse conditions, hostile environment, and even a tough road home. They lost, but I think they learned something about themselves and each other.

I think we can produce a Big East record something like last year‘s, and hopefully it isn’t so light on top.
 

shurup86

Sophomore
May 19, 2026
115
181
43
My honest prediction is 12-8 BE Conference record, based on teams different offense. Offensive attacking instead pushing the pace and the same defense in key parts of the game. Different player is stepping his game. R. Brown played to his potential last night. (quiet before in games).T. Copeland was awesome last night, played aggressively inside and got rebounds. (Highly efficient from the floor, he’s been efficient from the floor all year). Difference last night took more shots. (Looking like the best Juco Player in the U.S.). (MVP of the Juco Tournamen- highly clutch performance). E. Fischer is rock solid all year. Team is rooting for each other bottom line to win games.

I. Whitehead was spot on, when he posted he really liked this team. (On side note- I. Whitehead would become a awesome future Assistant Seton Hall Coach- he really bleeds Pirate Blue).

Shaheen Holloway is the PERFECT HEAD COACH FOR SETON HALL.
GO SHA!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Hall84 and Halldan

Mrpiratee

Redshirt
Jan 17, 2018
20
4
3
I mean, being a long time Hall fan trains you to take it one day at a time and not get your hopes up too high. The BE season will be a grinder. But, yeah, if they can keep shooting and making free throws (big difference!), it could be a competitive year…..
 
  • Like
Reactions: catholicman

hallmatt

Sophomore
Dec 1, 2018
171
144
43
Also, we scored our 2 highest outputs of the season on Baha Mar. This is why I’m so focused on our offense rather than our defense.

Our offense (especially our 1st half) vs Wisconsin is what won us that game.

Our offense also won the game yesterday. We had an answer every time Nc St got it within 2 in OT.

Copeleand, Fisher, and Brown were our 3 best players last night? Do you think it was their defense or the fact that they scored 18, 22, & 24 respectively?
 
  • Like
Reactions: pirate AI

SHallguy2

Sophomore
Nov 11, 2009
67
149
32
I’m thinking I cannot wait to see Copeland vs Hines. My expectations are always high with our coach. He’s exposing lazy coaches with money. Holloway has a plan to play fast with lots of guys playing team ball. Some may not like his plan but this is the way to beat teams who spend lots of money on several great players. Going to be rough spots this year, they are always going to happen, but we are going to be a tough team to beat most nights. Lots of tools in the tool box.
 

SPK145

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
1,614
3,690
113
Great week for the Pirates!

I had a split in the Bahamas so I’m one game behind. The rest of the OOC isn’t hard. At Rutgers should be tough but Kansas State is bad.

The Big East is better than last year but still not back. I had Seton Hall at 9-11 for this season, not sure there is a lot of upside to that.
 

Seton75

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
37,344
3,954
113
Also, we scored our 2 highest outputs of the season on Baha Mar. This is why I’m so focused on our offense rather than our defense.

Our offense (especially our 1st half) vs Wisconsin is what won us that game.

Our offense also won the game yesterday. We had an answer every time Nc St got it within 2 in OT.

Copeleand, Fisher, and Brown were our 3 best players last night? Do you think it was their defense or the fact that they scored 18, 22, & 24 respectively?
If Mcneil was hitting 13 3s, our guys' points are kinda mitigated. Both side of the court are critical, even the side Sha concentrates on.
 

dehere23

All-Conference
Feb 28, 2015
2,134
2,453
113
I mean, granted, we've been heartbroken and burned more than a few times based on some promising early season results - seems to come with the territory. That said, it seemed like expectations were fairly low pretty much across the board after the first few contests.

Then, we lost last Friday, but we put up one helluva fight under very tough circumstances. Now these two big time(for now), clutch non-conference wins.

Has anything changed for you?
Big time?

These are games we absolutely had to win if we want to avoid what happened last year. Now hope the rest of the OOC is “clean” and hope that either NC St or Wisconsin ends up being a team in consideration for the dance. NC State looks like it will be right now. Wisconsin most certainly doesn’t. But it’s early.

I had us winning both games because I think we are a borderline NCAA team, give or take. So I’m obviously happy but ky expectations haven’t been aligned.

Can we make a pact here for the rest of the OOC to avoid the post-Maui world from last year?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Seton75 and batts

PQR

Sophomore
Jan 31, 2020
121
128
43
Depends on how the rest of the league is. If it’s like last year we’re in great shape. I suspect the rest of the league is better and we’re looking at a similar record but probably getting in with an 8 or 10 seed.
 

dehere23

All-Conference
Feb 28, 2015
2,134
2,453
113
Depends on how the rest of the league is. If it’s like last year we’re in great shape. I suspect the rest of the league is better and we’re looking at a similar record but probably getting in with an 8 or 10 seed.
If it’s like last year, we need to do far better than 10-10 and 0-6 against the other tourney teams in the league to avoid sweating out Selection Sunday. And that assumes no more losses in the OOC. If the league is better though - which is our hope- we have more margin.

Right now we all need to collectively pull for the BE to do as well as possible for the rest of the OOC. Especially those teams besides UConn and SJU.

The reality is that for UCONN and St Johns, the OOC is about the teams getting experience and better against top competition and how it impacts their ultimate seeding for the NCAA. Last year UCONN got a great seed even though SJU outperformed them in the league again because of the OOC. SJU didn’t get as good of a seed as it could have had if it won another OOC game or two against ranked opponents.

For the rest of the league, including Nova now with their 2 losses already, the OOC is about positioning to make the dance.
 

Anon1776442946

Freshman
Apr 17, 2026
101
98
28
Also, we scored our 2 highest outputs of the season on Baha Mar. This is why I’m so focused on our offense rather than our defense.

Our offense (especially our 1st half) vs Wisconsin is what won us that game.

Our offense also won the game yesterday. We had an answer every time Nc St got it within 2 in OT.

Copeleand, Fisher, and Brown were our 3 best players last night? Do you think it was their defense or the fact that they scored 18, 22, & 24 respectively?
Thank u. Start the best offense, which means wilcher off bench. Maybe u explode more in the 1st half and work on holding the lead w subs 2nd half. Would anybody not want to see rodney or trey start over wilcher? Why wait to see their offense when they can start now. The pg position is still up for debate. We know del needs to sit. Way too many min. Petro has something but still need to refine his game. Id rather go w pg by committee over del anyday. Give del confidence min against new hampshire and njit, bot these important games.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hallmatt

dehere23

All-Conference
Feb 28, 2015
2,134
2,453
113
Thank u. Start the best offense, which means wilcher off bench. Maybe u explode more in the 1st half and work on holding the lead w subs 2nd half. Would anybody not want to see rodney or trey start over wilcher? Why wait to see their offense when they can start now. The pg position is still up for debate. We know del needs to sit. Way too many min. Petro has something but still need to refine his game. Id rather go w pg by committee over del anyday. Give del confidence min against new hampshire and njit, bot these important games.
I’m head of the Wilcher fan club, but you certainly can make the case that starting Parker is as good of an option right now. We will see.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PROF Ed

PirateBlue08

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2025
1,470
1,353
113
I’m head of the Wilcher fan club, but you certainly can make the case that starting Parker is as good of an option right now. We will see.
I like Parker as 6th man getting a lot of time in end of game situations, but that would keep us extremely undersized if you just replace Parker with Wilcher in the starting lineup. Having Wilcher as a 6'4 SF is bad enough, then you'd have 6'3, 6'3, 6'1 in your starting backcourt. With currently a 6'6 PF and a barely 6'9 center. Way too small and its showing.

I'd like to try Fisher at the 3 splitting time with Brown and start Williams and Copeland. Dolinski can backup Copeland and Wol backs up Williams. That way you have a rugged scoring/rebounder and a defensive stopper/shotblocker/pick and roll lob threat on the court at the same time. We lose too much having only one on the court.

We definitely need rebounding and size help on the frontline.
 

Seton75

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
37,344
3,954
113
I like Parker as 6th man getting a lot of time in end of game situations, but that would keep us extremely undersized if you just replace Parker with Wilcher in the starting lineup. Having Wilcher as a 6'4 SF is bad enough, then you'd have 6'3, 6'3, 6'1 in your starting backcourt. With currently a 6'6 PF and a barely 6'9 center. Way too small and its showing.

I'd like to try Fisher at the 3 splitting time with Brown and start Williams and Copeland. Dolinski can backup Copeland and Wol backs up Williams. That way you have a rugged scoring/rebounder and a defensive stopper/shotblocker/pick and roll lob threat on the court at the same time. We lose too much having only one on the court.

We definitely need rebounding and size help on the frontline.
Not sure I want to start both centers, but I want to see them together when needed.

Brown earned minutes if I was in charge. Might start him over Wilcher. And a fluctuating starting lineup based on recent play, or matchups is OK with me. I see the 5 who started last night, Cope, Parker and Brown as guys who can start. And I keep Wol and Jones (just cant believe he earned a starting spot and isnt far better than we have seen so far) in the rotation.. And hope Dolinsky gets time too. Hope the OOC games give some of the guys some time. Thomas looked good to me when we got him...
 
  • Like
Reactions: dehere23

PirateBlue08

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2025
1,470
1,353
113
Not sure I want to start both centers, but I want to see them together when needed.

Brown earned minutes if I was in charge. Might start him over Wilcher. And a fluctuating starting lineup based on recent play, or matchups is OK with me. I see the 5 who started last night, Cope, Parker and Brown as guys who can start. And I keep Wol and Jones (just cant believe he earned a starting spot and isnt far better than we have seen so far) in the rotation.. And hope Dolinsky gets time too. Hope the OOC games give some of the guys some time. Thomas looked good to me when we got him...
You're calling them centers but Williams came here as a PF and the overall expectation prior to the season at least from the fans on this board seemed to expect them to both be in the starting lineup.

The necessity of playing them as a platoon seems to have come by necessity after Kabba was injured, and then not being able to make this trip.

With the emergence of Dolinski I think you can now entertain the idea of starting them. Again, we lose too much having the platoon. Without Copeland on the floor we have no rebounding or inside scoring threat. Without Williams on the floor, we have no lob/defensive shot blocking threat. It was very palpably obvious in this tournament against bigger teams.
 

Fishjam

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2016
1,267
4,078
113
I'm very happy with the effort and results in the Bahamas. I think the games exposed our strengths and our weaknesses. It definitely helped that we were the first high major team that Wisconsin and NC State saw. We were able to punch them in the mouth early with our physicality and pressure. Both teams adjusted and began to expose us inside in the 2nd half. We won both games in the final 5-6 minutes because we were the fresher team thanks to our depth. We caught a break when Edmead fouled out also.

Has this changed expectations? Yes, I can't lie that the first 3 games were not encouraging. Sha made the wise decision to replace Jones in the starting lineup and that has made a big difference for our team offense. It's put some organization, flow and passing to our offense which has allowed various players to get better quality shots. Its produced opportunities for different players to step up and get hot.

But we also need to be realistic. I thought Wisconsin was a decent B10 opponent who would be a bubble team, but getting crushed by Boise State threw some cold water on that. I think NC State is a solid team. Each would be in the 4-9 range of the Big East so they are indicative of what we will face in many of our BE games.

We need to keep getting better and improve our weaknesses. Rebounding is a weakness. Interior defense is a weakness. And now everybody knows it. I'd like to see Sha incorporate Dolinski or maybe Kabba into the rotation and play some 2 big lineups. I think Dolinski or Williams would be better options at the 4 in certain situations than Wol. It would help with both of those weaknesses. Copeland and Williams together in some situations would be nice to see. I'd also like to see Sha add some wrinkles to our defense. Throw a Zone into the mix, double the post, etc.

I think we are a Bubble team. With the expanded NCAA field we can compete for a bid. Winning these 2 games sets us up well. We need to win the rest of the OOC games and get 10-11 BE wins and we can get in. The BahaMar wins give me hope that we will have a competitive season similar to last year and 2024. We need to keep improving and add different things throughout the season so that the second half of the BE schedule we are stronger than we are today and not limping towards the end. That's been a problem for us under Sha.
 
Seton Hall Pirates

Latest

  1. 01 Rivals 4-star PG Javion Tyndale commits to Seton Hall
  2. 02 Rivals Basketball Recruiting 4-star PG Javion Tyndale down to 6 schools
  3. 03 Women's Sports Highly-recruited 2027 prospect Ava Womack breaks down recruitment
  4. 04 Women's Sports Highly-recruited 2027 prospect Eni Oyedeji breaks down recruitment
  5. 05 On3 Basketball LMU transfer guard Rodney Brown Jr. commits to Seton Hall