1aa Top Three is better than 2a Top Three?

The Fact Jack

Redshirt
Dec 10, 2008
121
39
0
? How would you rank East Surry,Tarboro, Holmes, Reidsville, Northeastern and Mountain Heritage.

1. East Surry
2. Tarboro
3. Reidsville
4. Holmes
5. Northeastern
6. Mountain Heritage
 

mbdfan_rivals121259

All-Conference
Mar 17, 2007
25,690
4,313
0
Not sure Mountain Heritage is a top 3 small 2A team this year, lack of offense. I'd have Wallace Rose Hill in there instead, just my opinion.

1. Tarboro (until proven different imo)
2. East Surry
3. Reidsville
4. Wallace Rose Hill
5. Edenton Holmes
6. Northeastern
 
Last edited:

HowerinJr

All-Conference
Jan 9, 2010
1,662
1,246
52
Not sure Mountain Heritage is a top 3 small 2A team this year, lack of offense. I'd have Wallace Rose Hill in there instead, just my opinion.

1. Tarboro (until proven different imo)
2. East Surry
3. Reidsville
4. Wallace Rose Hill
5. Edenton Holmes
6. Northeastern
You can dispute the order, but these are the 6. I'm honestly not sure the Holmes win over Northeastern wasn't more impressive than the East Surry win over Reidsville. I don't think anyone saw that one coming.
 

ESODcards

Junior
Nov 13, 2016
615
288
0
I think Edenton Holmes has put themselves in the convo with East Surry and Tarboro this season with that win. All year it was said to be The Vikings the Cardinals then everyone else maybe the aces have been overlooked a bit.
 

jsc1973

Sophomore
Sep 17, 2001
2,136
124
0
I think the 1AA top three is probably better than the 2A, although Wallace might have something to say about that. Their performance against Wake Forest is certainly no reason to downrate them; I actually moved them up a spot on my 2A AP poll ballot.

No reason to rank East Surry ahead of Tarboro, though. It's not like Tarboro hasn't beaten any good teams this year themselves. They should stay No. 1 until someone shows they aren't.
 

bud33345

Senior
Jul 5, 2019
766
658
0
You can dispute the order, but these are the 6. I'm honestly not sure the Holmes win over Northeastern wasn't more impressive than the East Surry win over Reidsville. I don't think anyone saw that one coming.
Those that pay attention wouldnt be surprised. The aces played Northeastern tough last year. Score was 30-14 but was close throughout with Edenton jumping out to a 14-0 lead when NE was blowing teams out by 6 and 7 touchdowns. It is considered a rival game mainly to the fact that Edenton like Tarboro was 2A and had some success in the playoffs. In Edentons case they knocked off Northeastern 35-21 in the 2016 2A playoffs to secure a spot in the 2A East final. Thats still fresh in mind with the coaches.I'm not giving Northeastern a pass here, but let's not undermine the Edenton program either when it comes to 2A. All in all I think the narrative that 1A contenders couldn't hang with 2A contenders is a horse that is dead and buried.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: AcesWild2323

Kingbluedevil

All-American
Apr 2, 2014
5,896
6,278
113
I agree! I said this on another post. I’m more impressed with the aces win
To me I'm more impressed with the cardinals win. Most teams in this area are intimidated playing Reidsville because of their success year after year and they don't schedule 1a teams. If Reidsville was having a down year it would be different but they are one of the favorites to repeat. I'm not sure when they've lost a regular season game at home and never to a 1a school.
 

bud33345

Senior
Jul 5, 2019
766
658
0
Way to show your IQ.
Hey, lol, cool your jets! I respect the hell out of you SMC guys. But is robbinsonville 1AA? I didn’t think so. But you got to admit it’s pretty funny with how much SMC topics are posted here.
 

bud33345

Senior
Jul 5, 2019
766
658
0
Not sure Mountain Heritage is a top 3 small 2A team this year, lack of offense. I'd have Wallace Rose Hill in there instead, just my opinion.

1. Tarboro (until proven different imo)
2. East Surry
3. Reidsville
4. Wallace Rose Hill
5. Edenton Holmes
6. Northeastern

I agree with mbdfan here. It's pretty simple..... top 3 1AA and top 2A teams and these are it.
 

dogs79

All-Conference
Nov 7, 2009
3,997
4,985
72
Not sure Mountain Heritage is a top 3 small 2A team this year, lack of offense. I'd have Wallace Rose Hill in there instead, just my opinion.

1. Tarboro (until proven different imo)
2. East Surry
3. Reidsville
4. Wallace Rose Hill
5. Edenton Holmes
6. Northeastern
Tarboro -until proven different
WRH - because Reidsville lost to 1a
East Surry - cause they beat Reidsville
Reidsville
Edenton Holmes
Northeastern
 

ESODcards

Junior
Nov 13, 2016
615
288
0
Tarboro -until proven different
WRH - because Reidsville lost to 1a
East Surry - cause they beat Reidsville
Reidsville
Edenton Holmes
Northeastern
Reidsville should not be docked for losing to a 1A because the caliber of that 1A team is on par with anyone in the state 2A and period! Reidsville won the 2A title last year and are supposedly better this season, the cards are just playing at another level this season.
 

bud33345

Senior
Jul 5, 2019
766
658
0
Tarboro -until proven different
WRH - because Reidsville lost to 1A AND WRH HUNG IN WITH THE 3 STRAIGHT YEAR UNDISPUTED 4 AA CHAMP FOR 3 AND A HALF QUARTERS.
East Surry - cause they beat Reidsville
Reidsville
Edenton Holmes
Northeastern
There fixed it for you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dogs79

dogs79

All-Conference
Nov 7, 2009
3,997
4,985
72
Reidsville should not be docked for losing to a 1A because the caliber of that 1A team is on par with anyone in the state 2A and period! Reidsville won the 2A title last year and are supposedly better this season, the cards are just playing at another level this season.
But they lost to 1a team that didn't win Championship last year.
 

TD-FridayNight

All-American
Oct 28, 2015
7,213
5,811
0
With all the buzz about Holmes, East Surry, and Tarboro, 1aa seems to be overlooking the fact that Swain is undefeated also. I'm not saying that Swain is in the upper echelon, but to overlook the Maroon Machine late in November usually ends up with an early basketball season.
No one knows anything about the records of those Georga & Tennessee teams that The SMC plays in nonconference and then when conference play starts then we know more. I am sure Murphy, Swain, and Robbinsville will be right in the thick of things as they always are.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Swaindad40

swe98

All-Conference
Aug 17, 2010
4,741
2,278
113
Lost all credibility with the very first post. Switch that East Surry over Tarboro thing and then I'll read the rest of this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bud33345 and dogs79

ESODcards

Junior
Nov 13, 2016
615
288
0
Lost all credibility with the very first post. Switch that East Surry over Tarboro thing and then I'll read the rest of this.
Watch the Cardinals this year and you’ll see very fast that this is not completely unwarranted. While I do believe they still have to beat Tarboro on that final Saturday in December to be number 1 they did just beat the number 1 reigning 2A champions and have looked damn near flawless!
 

WHChoops

Senior
Oct 11, 2018
530
437
0
No one knows anything about the records of those Georga & Tennessee teams that The SMC plays in nonconference and then when conference play starts then we know more. I am sure Murphy, Swain, and Robbinsville will be right in the thick of things as they always are.
You know they will, they always are. 1 of the top 1a/ 1aa teams will come from the smc. And those smc teams would beat most 2a( not 2aa, and not Shelby) teams.
 

TD-FridayNight

All-American
Oct 28, 2015
7,213
5,811
0
You know they will, they always are. 1 of the top 1a/ 1aa teams will come from the smc. And those smc teams would beat most 2a( not 2aa, and not Shelby) teams.
Reidsville bounces back and wins 2A State Championship. They have a lot ti prove now !
 
  • Like
Reactions: dogs79

Finish Strong2

Sophomore
Oct 23, 2017
220
135
0
What’s not being talked about in regards to the East Surry/Reidsville game is where was the defense on either side of the ball? If ES thinks that Boaz is going to have all that time to throw the ball and think that someone is going to be open every time might as well stay at East Surry. I can assure you this Tarboro team has a defense ES hasn’t come close to seeing all year. Sure they can air it out to a wide open Gosnell or his brother but it’s not going to be pitch and catch with Boaz and his WRs playing against Tarboro by any means.
 

rambbq

All-Conference
Nov 13, 2002
13,992
3,119
0
and I can assure you that T'boro hasn't seen a 6'8" QB that can drop a dime to a quality receiver as quick as ES does....should be interesting...…….
 

swe98

All-Conference
Aug 17, 2010
4,741
2,278
113
and I can assure you that T'boro hasn't seen a 6'8" QB that can drop a dime to a quality receiver as quick as ES does....should be interesting...…….
That's nice and all, but can this kid find that dime while on his back, or while running for his hisl life? Because that's what'll happen vs Tarboro.
 

ESODcards

Junior
Nov 13, 2016
615
288
0
Like last year?
Last season East Surry wasted too many downs trying to run the ball against Tarboro. Running the ball is wasting a down against that team. However the defense plays man coverage the entire time and seemed to get lost and confused on more complex route combos. If Reidsville didn’t get this unstoppable pressure I’m not sure why your so convinced Tarboro will. The defenses for both Reidsville and East Surry I’ve been very good all season long but it’s almost impossible to stop that many athletes making plays.
 

TarVikes

All-Conference
Nov 23, 2017
2,137
4,301
0
Last season East Surry wasted too many downs trying to run the ball against Tarboro. Running the ball is wasting a down against that team. However the defense plays man coverage the entire time and seemed to get lost and confused on more complex route combos. If Reidsville didn’t get this unstoppable pressure I’m not sure why your so convinced Tarboro will. The defenses for both Reidsville and East Surry I’ve been very good all season long but it’s almost impossible to stop that many athletes making plays.
What makes you think East Surry is so much better on offense that they can actually score an offensive touchdown on Tarboro this year?