2026 Recruiting Thread
- Thread starter Tom McAndrew
- Start date
Bummer
CMC has been @ PSU 5 days. I would think his priorities are:
1) Meeting with and trying to retain as many current PSU players he can.
2) Get his staff in place
3) Determine who is staying or portalling
4) Based on #3 and the needs, contacting players in the portal whom him & his staff are allowed to contact. Not sure of the rules with teams like ISU & Michigan.
5) Determine interest level of 2026 players still uncommitted.
6) Find a home & schools for his family which he's probably involved with.
I understand PSU is a big time program but give him some space.
Last edited:
I saw enough of Penn State's highly paid Coordinators to welcome changes there, and support Coach Campbell's choices.
CMC has a lifelong players perspective, then a nice coaching pedigree. Division 3 or not, he played, earned , and learned his way to the top. His personality and commitment to "faith, family, and football" indicates he is the right field general, at the right time, that PSU needs. We're lucky to have him.
In case you had not noticed coaches were not exactly beating the door down to take the PSU job. Instead they and their agents leveraged it to make miliions at their current post. After the BYU disaster PSU was very fortunate to sign someone like Campbell. They were very likely looking at someone like Brian Diaboll until Campbell literally dropped into their lap at the 11th hour.
Co-defensive coordinator, but rumors of him leaving, DC Jeremy Hawkins from GA.St. defensive line, which
was ER strong point.
This would have been the same description of Chesney if PSU had hired him and we all would have been pretty happy with him as well. Trust the coaches to know what has worked for them to get them to this point. They have adapted, as needed, along the way and probably will going forward, as well.
Michigan wanted him. USC had interest in him. The Lions had interest in him. The Jets had interest in him. He can coach and those who are in the know recognize that.
Again, barely had time to unpack and it's not like they're going to bring over the entire ISU roster, but just their best players.
Those coaches W-L record/beating top 10 teams exceeded the talent pool and resources at their disposal.
Franklin and his staff repeatedly underperformed with what they had access to.
Btw, a certain HC just won the B1G (beating dOSU) with a bunch of former JMU coaches and players.
According to 247Sports talent composite (based on the recruiting rankings) for this season, the Hoosiers are dead last in the conference.
Illinois are 2nd to last and Northwestern 3rd to last - all 3 over-performed their recruiting rankings with Indiana vastly overperforming.
Recruiting rankings don't matter if you get the right (undervalued) 3* recruits and have superior coaching, but PSU being PSU will continue to get its share of 4* recruits and more importantly, talented QBs and WRs who fit MC's system.
And let's not forget, ISU also had to share the state with Iowa, which has vastly more resources.
Iowa fans are gloating about MC being gone, but he's not really gone, is he...
In addition, having a HC who has his system on one side of the ball (preferably on O, so there is some continuity for QBs), is better than having a CEO-type HC, who repeatedly needs to make the right call on hiring coordinators (if they're any good, they're going to leave for HC gigs).
Based on his track record, are there still people who have faith in Franklin making the right hires?
Wouldn't be surprised if Franklin hired Knowles at an exorbitant cost simply because he was the "hot name" and not really considering if Knowles' system was the right fit, etc.
Knowles left dOSU in part because Day (after seeing things he didn't like), wouldn't let him have total control - which is why they weren't exactly sad to see him go.
In fact, a good no. of Bucknut fans were laughing at Franklin/PSU for way overpaying for Knowles.
Also, maybe someone will look it up, but imagine Franklin's recruiting at Vandy wasn't so hot, and he managed to lose twice to another overrated coach in Pat Fitzgerald with similar level of talent, whereby Vandy ended up canceling the match-up (too tough for Franklin! Lol).
Based on his track record, are there still people who have faith in Franklin making the right hires?
Wouldn't be surprised if Franklin hired Knowles at an exorbitant cost simply because he was the "hot name" and not really considering if Knowles' system was the right fit, etc.
Knowles left dOSU in part because Day (after seeing things he didn't like), wouldn't let him have total control - which is why they weren't exactly sad to see him go.
In fact, a good no. of Bucknut fans were laughing at Franklin/PSU for way overpaying for Knowles.
Also, maybe someone will look it up, but imagine Franklin's recruiting at Vandy wasn't so hot, and he managed to lose twice to another overrated coach in Pat Fitzgerald with similar level of talent, whereby Vandy ended up canceling the match-up (too tough for Franklin! Lol).
Last edited:
It’s possible you didn’t notice that Koltenicki and Knowles both sucked at their jobs. Hard to believe but possible.