Naturally, the college football story of the year is the rise of Indiana football to the brink of the National Championship. Win or lose, Cignetti has done an unbelievable job of turning the Hoosier program around in just 2 years. So let's examine how he did it simply from a roster perspective in contrast to what Coach Campbell is doing, broken down by transfers from previous school, transfer from other schools, high school recruits and players retained from the current roster. The following numbers are a little rough.
Cignetti retained 36 scholarship athletes from the previous year........As of today, including those who have not announced, Campbell has retained, scholarship and non scholarship, roughly 70. The large difference is probably due to mostly walk ons.
Cignetti brought 13 JMU players with him through the portal. Campbell has brought, so far, 19 players from ISU.
Cignetti brought another 17 transfers from other schools.....Campbell, so far, just 1.
Cignetti had 16 high school recruits sign in 2024, Campbell has 12 commitments.
Indiana ended up with roughly 82 scholarship athletes for the 2024 season.
Outside of the retained roster, the numbers are trending in the same direction. Campbell's work now is to transfer in elite portal athletes and retain as much of the current roster as possible based on need.
So let's rate the components. I believe we would all agree that the core Penn State retained roster is higher quality than Indiana's. I believe we would also all agree that the best of the ISU roster is higher quality than the best of the JMU roster. Now, I'm not advocating that Campbell will pull off the 'miracle' that Cignetti has done at Indiana. However, I do believe Campbell has much more to work with than Cignetti did. With that being said, it remains to be seen how well Campbell does with bringing in transfers from other schools. As always, the results on the field will determine the success of this transition.