'25 (in-season) - '26 CFB Portal Thread

WVilleLion23

All-Conference
Oct 27, 2022
1,503
2,263
82
Sooo…how I’m looking at this is that the Iowa State transfers are taking a bite out of the losses from the recruiting commitments who jumped ship, while also picking up some added commitments plus probably more coming. I also wonder how many portal losses would have left if there were no coaching changes? Admittedly a big unknown. Personally I will wait until the dust settles before assessing how the roster looks and my expectations for next year’s record. It’s a jungle out there!
Agree with what you said there. However, I am not having any expectations for next year. I think we will be a better coached, more disciplined team, that does the basics much better. I have no idea how this monster mash is going to come together though and as such, I am not setting expectations. I HOPE that our floor is 8-4/9-3, but who knows.
 

Bvillebaron

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
2,743
2,749
113
This is probably more right correct than anything. While Grunk could be exceptional, if you keep him, Campbell is stuck with him for 3 years. This way he starts over with a one year Senior and essentially three freshmen in the wings learning the system.

Part of me still thinks though that Grunk was exceptionally accurate and we should have rolled with him. But for all we know Grunk made up his mind a long time ago. Maybe it was his decision. Campbell wasn't handing him $3 million to stay based on 5 games or whatever it was.
Why would Campbell be stuck with Grunk for 3 years? Please.
 

Bvillebaron

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
2,743
2,749
113
Maybe it's the players that he isn't bringing with him that led to the 4 losses and the players that he is bringing are the ones who got the 8 wins!

Maybe we should just sit back and see what happens instead of criticizing a guy who is trying to make the team better and knows way more about what he is doing than any of us.
Or maybe we should sit back and see what happens before crowning anyone.
 

LMTLION

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2008
1,267
2,698
112
I am not sure this was reported here but our ISU Linebacker Caleb Bacon is currently ranked #3 on 247 and #6 on On3 nationally for portal linebackers. I am not sure why so many here have issues with ISU transfers. We are experiencing a huge injection of talent at PSU after losing 6 games last season, and now we are seeing non-ISU transfers as well.
 

Bvillebaron

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
2,743
2,749
113
Well, first of all I was responding to Ludd, not to you.
Second, you did in fact juxtapose two unrelated topics, as they pertain to my prior post, as well as make a material misstatement.
The misstatement: How in the world was Campbell’s depleted roster “self-inflicted” (i.e., inflicted by Campbell)? Did he fire Franklin early in the season (leading in large part to the mass exodus of 2025 PSU roster players) and fail to hire himself until the LOI day had passed (leading to the departure of all but two members of the 2026 high school recruiting class)? The answers, of course, are no and no.
The juxtaposition: What in the world does what Franklin inherited upon his arrival at PSU have to do with what Campbell is doing, which is attempting to backfill the aforementioned depleted roster? Answer: Nothing. Campbell is doing exactly what he should be doing, in starting with bringing in those ISU players he knows very well, while seeking out the players he wants from other schools to fill remaining needs within the confines of the NIL budget allotted to him.
Bonus juxtaposition: In addition to wrongfully blaming Campbell for the roster depletion, you’ve doubled down by also (wrongfully) blaming him for Kraft‘s statements during the coaching search process and whatever “minimum expectation” that created in your own mind.
Other than the above (which is to say, other than the entirety of your post), you were spot on there, “Big Guy.”
Speaking of juxtapositions, if you think I was blaming Campbell for the depleted roster you really are a special kind of stupid.
 
Dec 14, 2021
427
651
93
Similar to Campbell’s decision to go with Becht.
Agree to a point. He's familiar with Becht and Manske and they with him and the "system." Cignetti has brought in older quarterbacks from other schools for 3 years in a row (counting Hoover next year).
 

WIP2001

Freshman
Apr 13, 2022
18
52
13
It's quite doubtful that Cuban is bankrolling Indiana's football payroll (which would require this type of outlay in perpetuity) because there is no return on these massive outlays - and again, they would have to be made in perpetuity. Silly imo that anybody would do this - to what end precisely. These athletes do not represent his "alma mater" - they're professional athletes competing in a silly Minor-League NFL with Universities names written on their uniforms.
Pretty fast to google Cuban’s comments on this. No specific amount but he said his investment is significant and ongoing. Motivation? He sold most of his stake in the Mavs. They froze him out of decisions including trading Luka. He said F* them and re-oriented towards building Indiana football into a championship program.

same as Texas Tech or Oregon/Ok St before… it just takes one rich guy
 
  • Like
Reactions: SkiSkiSki and NOYDB

Omar81

Senior
Nov 12, 2014
296
668
93
Speaking of juxtapositions, if you think I was blaming Campbell for the depleted roster you really are a special kind of stupid.
My prior post to which you responded: “Campbell was left a depleted roster.” Your unsolicited response: “In all fairness, Campbell’s depleted roster was self-inflicted.” Given the original statement and the precise wording of your response, exactly who is the “self” you’re referring to, if not Campbell?
That statement of yours was the topic sentence of your entire post, which ended with “What did I juxtapose there, Big Guy?” If not for the general jackassery and stupidity of your entire post (along with most of your other posts in this 44 page thread), I might have given you the benefit of the doubt. I could have thought to myself, “Nobody could possibly be this dumb as to blame Campbell, so he must mean something other than exactly what he said.”
In the end, though, you’ve provided great but unintended humor by calling me “a special kind of stupid.”
The good news: I’m making good use of the Ignore function today, as you’re the second moron who made the list today. You will not be missed.
 
Last edited:

Catch1lion

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
3,835
6,463
113
Fingernail bio on the 4 incoming DT's...
nodim is a 6-foot-2, 290-pound defensive tackle who redshirted in 2024 with the Cowboys but played in all 12 games in 2025. He has excellent strength for the position and should come in and help the Nittany Lions who are losing several defensive tackles, including Zane Durant (out of eligibility) and Xavier Gilliam (in the transfer portal).

McPherson joins the Nittany Lions after one season at Colorado, when he played in 10 games and missed two due to injury. He had 202 snaps on defense and a blocked punt on special teams and was a contributor in both phases of the game, earning 16 tackles, half a sack and six quarterback hurries.

Those two join UCLA defensive tackle Keanu Williams and Iowa State defensive lineman Alijah Carnell as defensive linemen to commit to Campbell and his new staff from the transfer portal. Williams will only have one year of eligibility remaining, while Carnell, Nnondum and McPherson will all have three years of eligibility remaining.
Might have to throw a couple more steaks on the grill.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Bison13

WDLion

Senior
Dec 18, 2006
390
598
93
My prior post to which you responded: “Campbell was left a deplete roster.” Your unsolicited response: “In all fairness, Campbell’s depleted roster was self-inflicted.” Given the original statement and the precise wording of your response, exactly who is the “self” you’re referring to, if not Campbell?
That statement of yours was the topic sentence of your entire post, which ended with “What did I juxtapose there, Big Guy?” If not for the general jackassery and stupidity of your entire post (along with most of your other posts in this 44 page thread), I might have given you the benefit of the doubt. I could have thought to myself, “Nobody could possibly be this dumb as to blame Campbell, so he must mean something other than exactly what he said.”
In the end, though, you’ve provided great but unintended humor by calling me “a special kind of stupid.”
The good news: I’m making good use of the Ignore function today, as you’re the second moron who made the list today. You will not be missed.
To me self-inflicted would mean Penn State.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim

Big_O

All-Conference
Jun 28, 2001
1,508
2,447
113
How many of these guys are playing the game: "I have no interest in going elsewhere, but I'm going to enter myself in the portal to see how much Penn State will pay me to stay".
I was thinking the same thing. I just read that Penn State had their 43rd player enter the transfer portal.
 
Jun 26, 2025
816
677
93
Pretty fast to google Cuban’s comments on this. No specific amount but he said his investment is significant and ongoing. Motivation? He sold most of his stake in the Mavs. They froze him out of decisions including trading Luka. He said F* them and re-oriented towards building Indiana football into a championship program.

same as Texas Tech or Oregon/Ok St before… it just takes one rich guy

It's not an "investment" and to characterize it is as such is laughable (an ownership position in the Dallas Mavericks otoh is absolutely "an investment" that someone would make with a belief that they could make a return on that Investment). Cuban cannot take an ownership "investment" of a Prollegiate Minor-League NFL team.
 

Bison13

All-American
May 26, 2013
3,209
5,297
113
How many of these guys are playing the game: "I have no interest in going elsewhere, but I'm going to enter myself in the portal to see how much Penn State will pay me to stay".
That could be the case for some of them, but I think it’s more of the idea that they see Coach Campbell’s actually recruiting over them and making them compete to get time.
 
Jun 26, 2025
816
677
93
That could be the case for some of them, but I think it’s more of the idea that they see Coach Campbell’s actually recruiting over them and making them compete to get time.

Or Coach Campbell is offering them less than they believe they can get elsewhere in the Free Agent Market.... Either way, it suggests that Coach Campbell is not going to lose any sleep if they leave.
 

WIP2001

Freshman
Apr 13, 2022
18
52
13
It's not an "investment" and to characterize it is as such is laughable (an ownership position in the Dallas Mavericks otoh is absolutely "an investment" that someone would make with a belief that they could make a return on that Investment). Cuban cannot take an ownership "investment" of a Prollegiate Minor-League NFL team.
Behavioral Economics is a major field because people aren’t robots and don’t use their money strictly according to risk adjusted discounted cash flows. There are endless examples of people investing Millions on organizations (university, clubs, religious institutions) with a return of “joy”.