Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="The Bell Tolls for Thee" data-source="post: 131815412" data-attributes="member: 1812660">Stomped Oklahoma with a team RR assembled.&nbsp; You diminish Holgorsen's Orange Bowl as coming from &quot;Stewart's&quot; players but credit Stewart as the primary reason WVU beat Oklahoma.&nbsp; Stewart had less to do with beating Oklahoma with RR's players than Holgorsen did beating Clemson with Stewart's players.&nbsp; You are being intellectually dishonest by this inconsistency.He beat a 5-7 Auburn team at home.&nbsp; That is less of an accomplishment than Brown's win against VT this year.&nbsp; Certainly nothing Stewart did during his 3 years has HC were as big as Holgorsen's win against #7 11-2 Baylor in 2014.Lastly you just keep saying 28-12 when the only win there against a team better than middle of the pack is 10-3 Pitt.&nbsp; 9 of the losses were to teams equivalent to the average Big 12 team or worse.Only a 5th grader would reductively keep saying numbers over and over again without analyzing those numbers.&nbsp; Between 2008 and 2010, Appalachian state was 32-9.&nbsp; Even a fifth grader can see it 32-9 is better than 28-12 so App State must've been better right?&nbsp; This is EXACTLY the argument you are making by just saying 28-12 and ignoring the quality of those games and the lack of production from the players that were obviously capable of more based upon their level of play under other coaches.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="The Bell Tolls for Thee, post: 131815412, member: 1812660"] Stomped Oklahoma with a team RR assembled. You diminish Holgorsen's Orange Bowl as coming from "Stewart's" players but credit Stewart as the primary reason WVU beat Oklahoma. Stewart had less to do with beating Oklahoma with RR's players than Holgorsen did beating Clemson with Stewart's players. You are being intellectually dishonest by this inconsistency. He beat a 5-7 Auburn team at home. That is less of an accomplishment than Brown's win against VT this year. Certainly nothing Stewart did during his 3 years has HC were as big as Holgorsen's win against #7 11-2 Baylor in 2014. Lastly you just keep saying 28-12 when the only win there against a team better than middle of the pack is 10-3 Pitt. 9 of the losses were to teams equivalent to the average Big 12 team or worse. Only a 5th grader would reductively keep saying numbers over and over again without analyzing those numbers. Between 2008 and 2010, Appalachian state was 32-9. Even a fifth grader can see it 32-9 is better than 28-12 so App State must've been better right? This is EXACTLY the argument you are making by just saying 28-12 and ignoring the quality of those games and the lack of production from the players that were obviously capable of more based upon their level of play under other coaches. [/QUOTE]

Name