Andy Beshear - Not a fan of Science

Mime-Is-Money

All-Conference
May 29, 2002
8,539
2,128
113
Our rolling 7 day avg is 1300 right now. Take a break, bud.

Today was 2,002 dead, yesterday was 1,971 dead. The rolling 7 day average was 700 three weeks ago. The WH already stated to brace for increased death numbers in the coming weeks.

I think taking a break was the problem.
 
Last edited:

anthonys735

Heisman
Jan 29, 2004
62,610
51,190
113
No I only read CNN I'm a CNN bot CNN is life

Our mask compliance is on par with some European countries and below others, including Italy and Spain. But lockdown measures are more strict than what was implemented here.



All European countries had school closures, except for Sweden, and most didn't fully reopen until August.
Yeah. That's what I said. Our compliance is the same as Europes. They've been back in school since August. Other than hypotheticals, do you have anything? Assuming no, as you desperately search for data that's not there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kyeric and 80 Proof

Mime-Is-Money

All-Conference
May 29, 2002
8,539
2,128
113
Yeah. That's what I said. Our compliance is the same as Europes. They've been back in school since August. Other than hypotheticals, do you have anything? Assuming no, as you desperately search for data that's not there.

I've already said the data collected so far shows that schools are at a much lower risk of causing an outbreak, and in most places K-8 should be open but that school districts should take precautions in places of widespread outbreaks, including shutting down in-person instruction due to lack of adequate staff. These are the same suggestions as WHO, Euro countries, medical associations, etc communicated. I haven't posted data to the contrary.

What hypotheticals have I given?
 

hmt5000

Heisman
Aug 29, 2009
26,976
82,650
0
not sure what 'around the world and likewise' means

Closing schools in communities with outbreaks and lack of adequate quarantine measures will reduce the spread. See Israel. The data that we're all talking about points to schools not being the cause of outbreaks compared to other superspreader events.

But sometimes schools have to shut down when it's difficult to impossible for in-person instruction due to inadequate staff from outbreaks.
Super spreader events... Like blm protest and riots? Why aren't those events knocked by experts but church, school, family events and regular medical procedures are? Look at Swedens #s. If we lock down again this economy is going to tank and it'll take a decade to recover... or more. The single mindedness that people look at covid is just amazing. I wonder what some of you guys do for a living where you think you will just keep getting paid if everyone stays home and doesn't do anything. A whole lot of businesses sucked it up and fought to stay in business through the first shutdown. Most won't try or be able to go through another.
 

Ukbrassowtipin

Heisman
Aug 12, 2011
82,109
89,931
0
Is there any evidence from contract tracers that restaurants are the main culprit? Or are we just picking things?

Anyway, the science is out there on schools. Of course we know unions want no part of working. My favorite is ive seen some teachers complain that Devos gave them no instruction on how to open. Lol. I dont care if its her or a D person in that position. Educators are admitting they as a large group, on the ground, are incapable of functioning unless one beaurocrat gives them precise orders.

I'm just glad the gym is still open, or I would riot. Which of course is safe as we've seen or been told all year.
 
Nov 24, 2007
23,247
23,780
0
not sure what 'around the world and likewise' means

Closing schools in communities with outbreaks and lack of adequate quarantine measures will reduce the spread. See Israel. The data that we're all talking about points to schools not being the cause of outbreaks compared to other superspreader events.

But sometimes schools have to shut down when it's difficult to impossible for in-person instruction due to inadequate staff from outbreaks.
Keep reading past likewise. Formatting error on my phone.

The governor did not close because there are inadequate staff. The local districts know when this is happening and can and have adjusted when needed. He closed them claiming it would
Slow the spread. The extensive Data does not it support this move. It’s the most researched setting since the start of the pandemic. You are wrong
 
Nov 24, 2007
23,247
23,780
0
Is there any evidence from contract tracers that restaurants are the main culprit? Or are we just picking things?

Anyway, the science is out there on schools. Of course we know unions want no part of working

I'm just glad the gym is still open, or I would riot. Which of course is safe as we've seen or been told all year.

there are a few studies showing that restaurants, events, etc... are the main culprits for non household spread. But they aren’t nearly as well funded or broad as the countless studies that show schools are not accelerating the spread
 
  • Like
Reactions: kyeric
Nov 24, 2007
23,247
23,780
0
No I only read CNN I'm a CNN bot CNN is life

Our mask compliance is on par with some European countries and below others, including Italy and Spain. But lockdown measures are more strict than what was implemented here.



All European countries had school closures, except for Sweden, and most didn't fully reopen until August.

good lord. He’s obviously discussing current closures.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kyeric

anthonys735

Heisman
Jan 29, 2004
62,610
51,190
113
I've already said the data collected so far shows that schools are at a much lower risk of causing an outbreak, and in most places K-8 should be open but that school districts should take precautions in places of widespread outbreaks, including shutting down in-person instruction due to lack of adequate staff. These are the same suggestions as WHO, Euro countries, medical associations, etc communicated. I haven't posted data to the contrary.

What hypotheticals have I given?
Your entire original post.

We may reach 2k rolling for a short period in a few weeks. Hopefully we're rolling over the to now, like Europe started about 10 days ago.
 

Mime-Is-Money

All-Conference
May 29, 2002
8,539
2,128
113
Super spreader events... Like blm protest and riots? Why aren't those events knocked by experts but church, school, family events and regular medical procedures are? Look at Swedens #s. If we lock down again this economy is going to tank and it'll take a decade to recover... or more. The single mindedness that people look at covid is just amazing. I wonder what some of you guys do for a living where you think you will just keep getting paid if everyone stays home and doesn't do anything. A whole lot of businesses sucked it up and fought to stay in business through the first shutdown. Most won't try or be able to go through another.

A lot of things going on here.

- Masks and social distancing were prevalent and strongly encouraged with most BLM gatherings. I don't believe a protest or a gathering supporting BLM has caused an outbreak, but could be wrong. The superspreader events have been gatherings in which attendees let their guard down, and remove their masks, specifically indoors.

- Sweden's #'s are awful right now and are implementing lockdown measures

- A pandemic will cause an economic retraction with or without lockdowns. Suffering an additional 1-2 million deaths, which is the estimate without restrictions given transmission and fatality rates, would take billions out of the economy.

- My family has suffered financially because of this. I want it over.
 

CatsFanGG24

Heisman
Dec 22, 2003
22,267
27,134
0
A lot of things going on here.

- Masks and social distancing were prevalent and strongly encouraged with most BLM gatherings. I don't believe a protest or a gathering supporting BLM has caused an outbreak, but could be wrong. The superspreader events have been gatherings in which attendees let their guard down, and remove their masks, specifically indoors.

- Sweden's #'s are awful right now and are implementing lockdown measures

- A pandemic will cause an economic retraction with or without lockdowns. Suffering an additional 1-2 million deaths, which is the estimate without restrictions given transmission and fatality rates, would take billions out of the economy.

- My family has suffered financially because of this. I want it over.
Sweden’s 7 day avg reported deaths is 12. They look to be over the case hump already. Their restrictions are purely political, as they booted their health expert to the sideline...he was still in favor of the same strategy and first go around just 5 days ago.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kyeric

Mime-Is-Money

All-Conference
May 29, 2002
8,539
2,128
113
Your entire original post.

We may reach 2k rolling for a short period in a few weeks. Hopefully we're rolling over the to now, like Europe started about 10 days ago.

What are the hypotheticals in my original post? I am relaying what studies have reported and recommended.

The predictive models used by the CDC show us averaging ~ 2,000 deaths per day in the first two weeks of December. I hope that's not the case. And like I mentioned we had 2,002 today, 1,971 yesterday, with new cases increasing dramatically over the last two weeks. I hope that's a peak, as do many states that are enacting additional lockdown measures and new mask mandates.
 

Mime-Is-Money

All-Conference
May 29, 2002
8,539
2,128
113
Sweden’s 7 day avg reported deaths is 12. They look to be over the case hump already. Their restrictions are purely political, as they booted their health expert to the sideline...he was still in favor of the same strategy and first go around just 5 days ago.

Per the article below their death rate per capita is now 10x Norway, 5x Denmark, and cases are jumping 50 % per week.

They've implemented strict lockdown measures starting this and next week.

https://nationalpost.com/news/world...-19-cases-soar-and-herd-immunity-hopes-falter
 

CatsFanGG24

Heisman
Dec 22, 2003
22,267
27,134
0

Mime-Is-Money

All-Conference
May 29, 2002
8,539
2,128
113
So you’re telling me the numbers are potentially already dropping prior to the stricter measurements due to go into effect on November 24 and those stricter measurements don’t apply to school, business or private gatherings????

Nope, I'm saying that Sweden is putting in strict measures because of an alarming increase in cases and deaths, Someone else said 'LOOK AT SWEDEN'. I have.

And no, the numbers are not dropping prior to stricter measures. Not sure where you're getting that. There first restrictions rolled out a month ago.

“Over recent weeks, the recommendations have been sharpened and strong measures have been taken. Despite this, behaviour has not yet changed enough to turn the direction of the development,” she said.

Once again, not arguing for school closures, at least K-8, in places of low or steady rates.


Any disputing of the 7 day average death number being extremely low?

Compared to the US, yep, extremely low. But compared to neighboring countries with measures in place well before Sweden the numbers are frighteningly high, which is why the government decided to act.

“Do not go to the gym, do not go to the library, do not have dinner parties, do not have parties. Just cancel it.”
 

CatsFanGG24

Heisman
Dec 22, 2003
22,267
27,134
0
Nope, I'm saying that Sweden is putting in strict measures because of an alarming increase in cases and deaths, Someone else said 'LOOK AT SWEDEN'. I have.

And no, the numbers are not dropping prior to stricter measures. Not sure where you're getting that. There first restrictions rolled out a month ago.

“Over recent weeks, the recommendations have been sharpened and strong measures have been taken. Despite this, behaviour has not yet changed enough to turn the direction of the development,” she said.

Once again, not arguing for school closures, at least K-8, in places of low or steady rates.




Compared to the US, yep, extremely low. But compared to neighboring countries with measures in place well before Sweden the numbers are frighteningly high, which is why the government decided to act.

“Do not go to the gym, do not go to the library, do not have dinner parties, do not have parties. Just cancel it.”
What were the first restrictions? They’ve always preached distancing when possible - but I’d like to know what those first restrictions were....

It seems to me the cases are falling - Worldometers is where you can get that. Nov 13, 7 day avg cases 4,685 - Nov 19, 3,258....7 day avg deaths - 24 on Nov 11, 11 on Nov 19...only time will tell but....guess we can check back in on the 24th, final case number before new restrictions.

8 more daily deaths than Denmark, 9 more than Norway, 10 more than Finland. About double the population of all.
 

hmt5000

Heisman
Aug 29, 2009
26,976
82,650
0
Nope, I'm saying that Sweden is putting in strict measures because of an alarming increase in cases and deaths, Someone else said 'LOOK AT SWEDEN'. I have.

And no, the numbers are not dropping prior to stricter measures. Not sure where you're getting that. There first restrictions rolled out a month ago.

“Over recent weeks, the recommendations have been sharpened and strong measures have been taken. Despite this, behaviour has not yet changed enough to turn the direction of the development,” she said.

Once again, not arguing for school closures, at least K-8, in places of low or steady rates.




Compared to the US, yep, extremely low. But compared to neighboring countries with measures in place well before Sweden the numbers are frighteningly high, which is why the government decided to act.

“Do not go to the gym, do not go to the library, do not have dinner parties, do not have parties. Just cancel it.”
Im just curious how far you go to stop covid? Would you burn the entire world economy and let suicide, drug overdose, cancer, heart disease... etc etc keep increasing to try to keep a disease with 99.6% survival rate from continuing to kill people who are largely in their last year of life anyway?

Are you also taking into acct how different countries count covid deaths? You do realize that the US counts everyone who test positive as a covid death and some only list it if its the primary cause.
 
Apr 13, 2002
44,001
97,143
0
That's nice. We don't have more time. We're talking over a year of school for some of these kids and if they don't go back in January it'll basically be 2 grades that are throw outs.

There's no science out there to even lead a discussion on waiting. Everything through 9 months, the cdc, the who, pediatrics, brown u, Europe, literally everything short of unions and liberal politicians, say that kids are safer in school. The CDC literally said that verbatim, today.
No evidence that this surge is related to k-12 education. In fact, Fayette and Jefferson
Are worse off than most and they’re the two that haven’t had in person instruction for public schools.

Exactly. 9 months of evidence from various nations and states. This closure is nothing to do with safety.

Is there any evidence from contract tracers that restaurants are the main culprit? Or are we just picking things?

Andy admitted yesterday he had no evidence. Today he admitted they don't even contact trace for any school or business related transmissions. My link to the story is a few pages back. So no clue what 900+ contact tracers were doing all this time. I guess tracking every case in churches.
 
Apr 13, 2002
44,001
97,143
0
Any disputing of the 7 day average death number being extremely low?

Imo icu shows we already peaked or near it.

As you know you can't trust cases because they aren't positive patients and the lag is too great. Deaths are tough too because we never know dates. Now hospitalization won't work because they changed the definition and now require at least 3 days in for remdesivir.

It's sad and funny to see people already claim restrictions working when they haven't even started. So many are just completely unable to exhibit critical thinking. Others choose their team/outcome then choose the facts they like. Watching and listening to people discuss this virus tells me we're doomed as a nation.
 

Punkin Puss

Senior
Nov 6, 2019
685
923
0
Sweden’s 7 day avg reported deaths is 12. They look to be over the case hump already. Their restrictions are purely political, as they booted their health expert to the sideline...he was still in favor of the same strategy and first go around just 5 days ago.

Our World in Data, which comes directly from the European CDC, deaths in Sweden are shown by date of death, while deaths in other countries are shown by date of report.

So they backlog their reporting.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: RunninRichie

anthonys735

Heisman
Jan 29, 2004
62,610
51,190
113
Our World in Data, which comes directly from the European CDC, deaths in Sweden are shown by date of death, while deaths in other countries are shown by date of report.

So they backlog their reporting.
Sounds like some place closer to home.
 

warrior-cat

Hall of Famer
Oct 22, 2004
190,296
149,077
113
Super spreader events... Like blm protest and riots? Why aren't those events knocked by experts but church, school, family events and regular medical procedures are? Look at Swedens #s. If we lock down again this economy is going to tank and it'll take a decade to recover... or more. The single mindedness that people look at covid is just amazing. I wonder what some of you guys do for a living where you think you will just keep getting paid if everyone stays home and doesn't do anything. A whole lot of businesses sucked it up and fought to stay in business through the first shutdown. Most won't try or be able to go through another.
The dims used Covid politically and did not care about the repercussions. The nation be damned.
 

warrior-cat

Hall of Famer
Oct 22, 2004
190,296
149,077
113
A lot of things going on here.

- Masks and social distancing were prevalent and strongly encouraged with most BLM gatherings. I don't believe a protest or a gathering supporting BLM has caused an outbreak, but could be wrong. The superspreader events have been gatherings in which attendees let their guard down, and remove their masks, specifically indoors.

- Sweden's #'s are awful right now and are implementing lockdown measures

- A pandemic will cause an economic retraction with or without lockdowns. Suffering an additional 1-2 million deaths, which is the estimate without restrictions given transmission and fatality rates, would take billions out of the economy.

- My family has suffered financially because of this. I want it over.
Wow, just wow. In bold is why people can't take your post seriously. It is a liberal talking point that has just been ridiculous the whole way.
 

80 Proof

Heisman
Jan 3, 2003
64,602
51,229
113
They don’t make em like you anymore do they Jim Bob? You didn’t need no good teachin did ya buddy? You live off the land and watch Alaska’s last frontier. You get like a real man should. Schoolin is a waste of time init brother?
Bet I have more education than you. I definitely have more intelligence.
 

CatsFanGG24

Heisman
Dec 22, 2003
22,267
27,134
0
Our World in Data, which comes directly from the European CDC, deaths in Sweden are shown by date of death, while deaths in other countries are shown by date of report.

So they backlog their reporting.
The data from World in Data matches the data from Worldometers. Date of death reporting is more beneficial when looking at your outbreak curve.
 

chroix

Heisman
Jul 22, 2013
10,018
25,203
0
Forbes has an article stating that 1 in every 1000 people in South Dakota that have tested positive have died. It’s also the place that CNN has continued to call the per capita epicenter of the world. If both are true the restrictions are as absurd as the furthest right winger on here says. There is no way to justify the economic damage at this point. We got a handle on it. Proceed in a smart manner until the vaccines are available to everyone and cut out the fear porn. And this comes from someone that according to most of the folks on here consider a libtard. They can all still bite me but facts is facts.
 

John Henry

Hall of Famer
Aug 18, 2007
35,521
172,485
113
I read a few of the posts and all I can say is I feel sorry for folks living in Kentucky. It must be a miserable life. You can do better.

We are trying to find a turkey big enough to feed everybody coming over and you can only have so many in your house. Let that sink in. What country are you living in.
 

John Henry

Hall of Famer
Aug 18, 2007
35,521
172,485
113
Kentuckians be like