I'm going to assume that Stratton is gone and for this to be a "worst case scenario" I'm going to assume Routt is gone. (Hold your comments on Routt- I know)
Anyway:
I think Evan Mitchell will get a spot- he will be a junior, and there is a good chance he will be in our rotation very soon- as in possibly this week. He has started against SEC teams before, and has already started some big game and will be going to the Cape Cod League this summer.
Kendall Graveman- he will be a senior. Has plenty of experience. I look for him to be a leader of the pitching staff.
The Sunday spot is up for grabs- I would say Fitts, Lindgren, Woodruff, and Cox will all be competing for that spot. And I don't think you can rule out Ben Bracewell and Ross Mitchell- although I think both are unlikely.
Those first four guys are going to go play summer ball and are getting their feet wet in the SEC. I think they will take a big step forward next year. It wouldn't shock me at all if our rotation next year ends up being Fitts, Lindgren, and Woodruff to be honest- but I think it's somewhat unlikely. Way too soon to know.
As far as replacing Reed- I think it will be tough because he is so good, but I think Ben Bracewell and Taylor Stark could handle it. I think you may even see Holder take the job, but I think he is more of a set-up guy, and I really like John Marc Shelly one of our recruits out of Memphis. He tops out at 95, and I think he is our closer of the future.
To me, if Stratton comes back, that would be awesome. I'm not holding my breath on that right now- it all depends on where he is drafted, and that's something that no one knows right now. I agree with the posters saying that he is in the 5-10 range type of pick right now. If he continues to do well, he could go even higher. Now, if June rolls around and he slips through and goes in the 20th round- well, then I may feel a little bit better.
Routt- I think he is a mid-20's round guy at best, and certainly may not be drafted. Someone may take a flyer on him because he is left handed, but he has had injury issues, and he had an arguement with Cohen in the dugout during a game over being taken out and he has struggled. I think he will probably be back, but it's going to come down to whether he wants to keep playing or not and I think if he gets drafted, odds are he will go ahead and go.