CL top ten...

maroonmania

Senior
Feb 23, 2008
11,062
711
113
surprised that Shon Coleman would be listed no. 1 and that Steve McNair, Jr. would be listed in the top ten.
 

8dog

All-American
Feb 23, 2008
13,894
5,733
113
His stock has skyrocketed since the dandy dozen came out. I think one site now has him at #23 in the country and a five star.

Its hard to tell with guys like McNair and Carr b/c they closed their recruitments so early and stayed in state.
 

AlCoDog

All-Conference
Feb 27, 2008
5,865
1,420
113
and include A USM committ. McNair is at best the 3rd best player on his own team.
 
C

Curly Bill

Guest
McNair is probably a stretch. Who really knows about the order, but Coleman, Thompson, Robinson, Wells, Sanders, Eulls and Dickson are unanimous and interchangeable on anybody's list. They could go just about anywhere except the elite of the elite.

Carr could also, but because of his short recruitment, you can't put him up there as a top guy, we'll never know. Bennett has some good offers, so he's in there too. I'd probably replace McNair with Robert Johnson, strictly because Johnson has a ton of offers and McNair doesn't.

Where is Carlton Martin on that list? You'd probably have to go with him over Carr I'd think.
 

goldeneye

Redshirt
Dec 12, 2009
241
0
0
Coleman won the starting tackle job over a 5 star tackle in the Army game and was voted one of the standouts on the East team for the entire week. I didnt see the South Panola game but sounds like he had a bad game and everyone is saying he's overrated but its obvious he held his own against the best of the best in San Antonio so I think he def should be #1. Carlton Martin should be in over Bennet and John son over Mcnair though.