I'm thinking it could be Lampley, Kevin Norwood, or possibly one of the linemen (Jackson or McCray). Garrett just hasn't put up the big HS numbers that you would expect to see from a Dandy Dozen. He could end up being the best college player out of any of MS prospects, but not be a Dandy Dozen.
My dark-horse pick: Freelon from Bruce. Rushed for 2,500 yards and 33 TDs last year. Would not be surprised to see him get the final slot.