Toggle sidebar

College football playoff seedings.........

theoriginalSALTYdog

theoriginalSALTYdog

All-Conference
Jul 10, 2021
1,486
1,921
113
Here's my guess:

1) Indiana
2) UGA
3) Ohio State
4) Texas Tech
5) Oregon
6) Whiny Bitches (get Ohio State in the second round)
7)aTm
8) Oklahoma
9) Notre Dame
10) Bama
11) Tulane
12) James Madison one and done

What do I have wrong?


Hot takes;
The 5/12 and 6/11 match ups are a joke IMO.
Acc gets left out
Dark horses: Notre Dame (they're playing as well as anyone and have gotten better) and Texas Tech (have SEC physicality on both sides of the ball).
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: RebChuck
F

FlotownDawg

All-American
Aug 30, 2012
6,845
7,169
113
theoriginalSALTYdog said:
Here's my guess:

1) Indiana
2) UGA
3) Ohio State
4) Texas Tech
5) Oregon
6) Whiny Bitches (get Ohio State in the second round in Columbus)
7)aTm
8) Oklahoma
9) Notre Dame
10) Bama
11) Tulane
12) James Madison one and done

What do I have wrong?


Hot takes;
The 5/12 and 6/11 match ups are a joke IMO.
Acc gets left out
Dark horses: Notre Dame (they're playing as well as anyone and have gotten better) and Texas Tech (have SEC physicality on both sides of the ball).
Click to expand...
I agree. I don’t see the committee punishing Alabama for playing in a conference championship game by dropping them out. That would set the wheels in motion for conference title games to be disbanded and the powers that be can’t have that because they are cash cows.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dogpatrol
theoriginalSALTYdog

theoriginalSALTYdog

All-Conference
Jul 10, 2021
1,486
1,921
113
Anon1727378473 said:
No way a three lose team should be in the playoffs 🤷‍♂️
Click to expand...

I kinda struggled with that one but their legacy gets them in IMO. Miami, Texas, Vandy all at home bitching. Miami is the only one of those that has a valid argument IMO because of their ND win. Ohio State losing hurts Texas. Vandy's best win is Tennessee.
 
Last edited:
Ranchdawg

Ranchdawg

All-Conference
Dec 13, 2012
4,472
3,725
113
Number 10 on your list is not like the others. Get them out. They were beaten unmercifully in their game. They suck!
 
DAWGSANDSAINTS

DAWGSANDSAINTS

All-Conference
Oct 10, 2022
2,886
2,643
113
FlotownDawg said:
I agree. I don’t see the committee punishing Alabama for playing in a conference championship game by dropping them out. That would set the wheels in motion for conference title games to be disbanded and the powers that be can’t have that because they are cash cows.
Click to expand...
Could an 8-5 ACC Champion Duke beat JMU or Tulane ?
If you think they can, and I do, then why leave them out just bc they are 8-5 ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: theoriginalSALTYdog and patdog
Maroon13

Maroon13

All-Conference
Sep 29, 2022
3,584
3,680
113
I think the OPs ranking is what the committee will do. They tried telling us last weak by bumping Bama up and JMU up, both would get in.

With that said, I'd like to see Bama in. However they don't look like a playoff team right now. Their offense is terrible. I would put Miami in at 10.
 
615dawg

615dawg

All-Conference
Jun 4, 2007
6,631
3,588
113
theoriginalSALTYdog said:
Here's my guess:

1) Indiana
2) UGA
3) Ohio State
4) Texas Tech
5) Oregon
6) Whiny Bitches (get Ohio State in the second round)
7)aTm
8) Oklahoma
9) Notre Dame
10) Bama
11) Tulane
12) James Madison one and done

What do I have wrong?


Hot takes;
The 5/12 and 6/11 match ups are a joke IMO.
Acc gets left out
Dark horses: Notre Dame (they're playing as well as anyone and have gotten better) and Texas Tech (have SEC physicality on both sides of the ball).
Click to expand...
Just to throw a different take in.

1. Indiana
2. Georgia
3. Texas Tech
4. Ohio State
5. Oregon
6. Ole Miss
7. Texas A&M
8. Oklahoma
9. Miami
10. Notre Dame
11. Tulane
12. Duke

Ole Miss route goes through Oxford > Dallas > Atlanta > Miami (but they don't get past Dallas. Texas Tech is going to win the national championship.
 
The Peeper

The Peeper

Heisman
Feb 26, 2008
15,400
10,545
113
theoriginalSALTYdog said:
I kinda struggled with that one but their legacy gets them in IMO. Miami, Texas, Vandy all at home bitching. Miami is the only one of those that has a valid argument IMO because of their ND win. Ohio State losing hurts Texas. Vandy's best win is Tennessee.
Click to expand...
"Legacy" as in previous years teams, and not this one THIS YEAR? Is that you Gary Danielson?
 
Dawg1976

Dawg1976

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
8,124
2,633
113
patdog said:
OSU stays #2, UGA stays #3, Miami replaces Bama at #10.
Click to expand...
I hope you’re right but some projections has bama in. They have 3 losses and simply don’t pass the eye test imo. I’m not an ACC fan or but think they should have one in.
 
P

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
56,645
25,978
113
Dawg1976 said:
I hope you’re right but some projections has bama in. They have 3 losses and simply don’t pass the eye test imo. I’m not an ACC fan or but think they should have one in.
Click to expand...
It will be interesting. I know the chairman has said they do t punish teams for losing a championship game but of course they do. Are they going to leave Ohio State #1? No. They’re going to punish them for losing. Last year, I believe every conference championship game loser dropped in the final rankings. I just don’t know how you leave bama in after that loss when they also got blown out by Florida st. But who knows?
 
Maroon13

Maroon13

All-Conference
Sep 29, 2022
3,584
3,680
113
Damn the committee will absolutely get torched for this.

You drop OhSt a spot for losing a championship game.
You don't move bama at all for losing badly.
you drop out a team you had ranked and in the playoffs the whole time.

Just wow. There will be repercussions for this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr. Cook
R

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
18,960
2,079
113
The Bears almost certainly advance one spot. They probably should have traded places with A&M tho.

I was only halfway listening, but I think he said that Tulane and JMU didn't really deserve to be in because better teams were left out. I agree if that's what he said.
 
R

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
18,960
2,079
113
patdog said:
It will be interesting. I know the chairman has said they do t punish teams for losing a championship game but of course they do. Are they going to leave Ohio State #1? No. They’re going to punish them for losing. Last year, I believe every conference championship game loser dropped in the final rankings. I just don’t know how you leave bama in after that loss when they also got blown out by Florida st. But who knows?
Click to expand...
Legacy. And they got left out last year. Largely makeup for last year. And maybe to save DeBoer's job.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog
DAWGSANDSAINTS

DAWGSANDSAINTS

All-Conference
Oct 10, 2022
2,886
2,643
113
Maroon13 said:
Damn the committee will absolutely get torched for this.

You drop OhSt a spot for losing a championship game.
You don't move bama at all for losing badly.
you drop out a team you had ranked and in the playoffs the whole time.

Just wow. There will be repercussions for this.
Click to expand...
You have to go to 16 teams.
Notre Dame, Vandy, maybe BYU, or TX or Duke need to be in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maroon13
P

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
56,645
25,978
113
DAWGSANDSAINTS said:
You have to go to 16 teams.
Notre Dame, Vandy, maybe BYU, or TX or Duke need to be in.
Click to expand...
I think where we’re heading is 16 teams. 4 bids for SEC & Big 10, 2 for ACC & Big 12, 1 for top G6 champion & 3 at large. SEC & probably Big 10 will have playoffs between #3-#6 teams for the 3rd & 4th auto bid.
 
Mr. Cook

Mr. Cook

All-Conference
Nov 4, 2021
3,229
2,362
113
Maroon13 said:
Damn the committee will absolutely get torched for this.

You drop OhSt a spot for losing a championship game.
You don't move bama at all for losing badly.
you drop out a team you had ranked and in the playoffs the whole time.

Just wow. There will be repercussions for this.
Click to expand...
The Committee was gonna get torched regardless. The disease still has not been cured - we can argue about the symptoms all we want
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maroon13
The Peeper

The Peeper

Heisman
Feb 26, 2008
15,400
10,545
113
theoriginalSALTYdog said:
Come again...........I effing hate Bama but figured they'd get in just because they are well, Bama...........
Click to expand...
Bear Bryant and Saban have nothing to do with this team and shouldn't matter any at all. If the committee thinks so they are kicking a deserving team out to keep a "legacy" team in and that sucks
 
kired

kired

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2008
7,005
2,322
113
Maroon13 said:
And screw the G5 qualifier and conference championships. Expand to 16 and make the seeding based on rankings.
Click to expand...
I’m fine with the way it worked this year. Every team in the nation had their chance to make the playoffs and play for the national championship. First time we could ever say that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maroon13
L

leeinator

All-Conference
Feb 24, 2014
2,130
1,575
113
theoriginalSALTYdog said:
Here's my guess:

1) Indiana
2) UGA
3) Ohio State
4) Texas Tech
5) Oregon
6) Whiny Bitches (get Ohio State in the second round)
7)aTm
8) Oklahoma
9) Notre Dame
10) Bama
11) Tulane
12) James Madison one and done

What do I have wrong?


Hot takes;
The 5/12 and 6/11 match ups are a joke IMO.
Acc gets left out
Dark horses: Notre Dame (they're playing as well as anyone and have gotten better) and Texas Tech (have SEC physicality on both sides of the ball).
Click to expand...
If James Madison had quality trench players, they'd be formidable. However, I just don't seem them matching up with 3/4's of the teams in the playoffs at all. They might give Ole Miss a game, but would likely wear down by the 4th quarter like we did most of this year,
 
L

leeinator

All-Conference
Feb 24, 2014
2,130
1,575
113
theoriginalSALTYdog said:
I kinda struggled with that one but their legacy gets them in IMO. Miami, Texas, Vandy all at home bitching. Miami is the only one of those that has a valid argument IMO because of their ND win. Ohio State losing hurts Texas. Vandy's best win is Tennessee.
Click to expand...
I've said this til I'm blue in the face. There will always be bitchin' about being left out until the selections are taken OUT of the Committee's hands. Even if we had 64 teams in the playoffs, we'd still have that problem. Gotta go with a computer formula with defined-accepted-weighted INPUTS that will rank every team, however many you want. Then the Committee can just sit back and smoke some reefer while the playoff spots are spitted out by the formula. Would be so easy and everybody could then see why they didn't get in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MoronDawg
J

johnson86-1

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
14,287
4,803
113
patdog said:
Yeah. Oregon & Mississippi may win by 60 combined. Not good for ratings.
Click to expand...
Good draw for Ole Miss to get to play another team losing their coach and one whose best win is either NOrth Texas or Duke. How in the hell are they in there? Even with the head ot head loss, I'm not sure Duke shouldn't be ahead of them based on splitting with UVA.
 
P

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
56,645
25,978
113
leeinator said:
I've said this til I'm blue in the face. There will always be bitchin' about being left out until the selections are taken OUT of the Committee's hands. Even if we had 64 teams in the playoffs, we'd still have that problem. Gotta go with a computer formula with defined-accepted-weighted INPUTS that will rank every team, however many you want. Then the Committee can just sit back and smoke some reefer while the playoff spots are spitted out by the formula. Would be so easy and everybody could then see why they didn't get in.
Click to expand...
There will still be b1tch1ing then. Committee easily got 11of 12 teams right, arguably all 12, and got them seeded in pretty much the right order.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr. Cook
You must log in or register to reply here.