College Football Playoffs- IHSA version

[SilverHelmet]

FYI I LOVE this topic well done Bruce

Thanks Edgy.
I think it offers two things.
1. A spirited debate with no correct answer.
2. Shows that even though a lot of people complain about the 8 class system and who gets in the playoffs that it could be worse. You could have a system that favors 5 conferences that only has 4 slots in the playoffs meaning 5 teams could be undefeated conference champions with no common opponents and a group of people need to decide which one is not worthy.

 

[No Bias---Just Reality]

They're the Boise State of the IHSA.

Boise state pulls upsets against be boys when they get a chance RM not so much.

 

[NazDad]

What would the NCAA do if South Carolina had to forfeit the Georgia game. Is a now "undefeated" Georgia team in the playoffs?

 

[caravan8]

Probably not, just because people will say that they have seen Georgia lose. But it brings us back to an old question with the playoff, is it the 4 best teams or is it the 4 most deserving teams? I think Naz is one of the top 4 teams, but with the opening weekend “loss” would that dissuade the voters?

 

[Kevin JCHS 81]

At what point do we quit calling a loss to a team that used illegal players a loss for Naz?

- one ineligible very good running back played and gained 100+ yards?
- 3 ineligible players that already graduated or were just too old?
- 4 ineligible players that are currently on the Clemson roster?

The IHSA has already posted their answer as Naz's record of 10-0.