Could you survive life in the minor leagues?

kired

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2008
6,969
2,261
113
With the MLB draft recently wrapping up, I was doing a little reading on minor league players. Ran across this article on life in the minor leagues. I knew these guys didn't make much money, but I had no idea that some basically make the equivalentof working a minimum wage job (or less).

http://www.cbssports.com/mcc/messages/thread/20713402
 

Todd4State

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
17,411
1
0
that about 10% of minor league players make it to the Big Leagues, much less are able to make a viable career doing it. Also, because of the stupid NCAA rules, the ones that go to college may have some debt to pay. And those that don't go to college are often left basically bankrupt once their signing bonus is spent- and it won't take long to do that if it's a 100,000 dollars or so- and their career is over. Often times, those players have a family and they are forced to go back to school even though they have no money to speak of. Yes, MLB will often pay for their tuition and etc, and that helps, but MLB won't pay for groceries.

There really does need to be some reform, but MLB won't do it because it would cost them money.

In a perfect world, I would change the MLB draft rules to where in order for a player to be eligible, they must attend a JUCO or a 4 year school for at least 2 years- players could be drafted after their sophomore, junior or senior seasons. In turn, there would be a cap on what a player could make as a bonus based on the round that the player is drafted. Any player that is drafted that wishes to return to school may do so provided they have eligibility left- as it is now. I would also cut the draft down to 35 rounds- down from 50. Also, I would have MLB fund seven scholarships to each school in the country in D-I so that the total for each team goes up to 20 full scholarships. On top of that, I would also have MLB provide each school with wood bats, which would help MLB scout and evaluate players better and more efficiently.

As far as D-II, D-III, and NAIA, I would continue to let them use metal, as well as the JUCO's. The reason for that is because of the expected skill level of those players in general vs the expected number of legit prospects that are at those levels. I would want the JUCO's to keep using metal to try to encourage players to go to four year institutions for the simple fact that D-I would be a wood bat league and therefore increase your stock in the eyes of scouts.
 

jackstefano

Redshirt
Dec 28, 2007
2,368
0
0
they have to go back to living in the real world? How sad. Oh wait, you said MLB will often pay for their tuition if they go back to school, so it's not really the real world.
 

Todd4State

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
17,411
1
0
than it is for rock stars and other "celebrities" to be honest with you.

I agree with you- but I always find it funny that baseball players seemed to always get called out for living in a fantasy world more than others in the entertainment industry.
 

jackstefano

Redshirt
Dec 28, 2007
2,368
0
0
Todd4State said:
I agree with you- but I always find it funny that baseball players seemed to always get called out for living in a fantasy world more than others in the entertainment industry.

Not sure I follow you on this one. What examples are there of this? I would think NBA players would be the worst, followed by NFL players, then MLB players.
 

Todd4State

Redshirt
Mar 3, 2008
17,411
1
0
people like these rock starts that have a couple of albums, and then once their genre fades, they just hang out on the reality TV circuit or they do tribute tours. The rest of the time, they don't really do anything productive in society.

But yet, people never complain about them not having a real job.

And then you have these baseball players playing for peanuts and getting a what sounds like a huge bonus of 100K, and then it's all gone and people chastise them for not having a real job. I think people don't really realize what the situation is, and think that you are a professional baseball player, you must have at least a million dollars in the bank.

At any rate, MLB really needs to do a much better job of helping these players get real jobs after baseball.
 

kired

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2008
6,969
2,261
113
I always assumed they made pretty good money. At least the few guys I know that have been in the minors for the last 6-7 years, maybe been called up for 1/2 a season or so over the last few years - I always figured they made more money than I have since I graduated (04). But that's probably not true unless they got asizablesigning bonus.<div>
</div><div>They are actually gambling away a good chunk of their life trying to make it in the majors, and when their careers are over in a few years they have no degree to fall back on. I guess then it's either straight into the job market with no education, or back to school. I remember sharing a history class with Kirk Presley at ICC & thinking how it probably sucked to be starting college at about 26 years old - hardly anyone there even knew who he was. Of course he got a nice signing bonus so that would make life a little easier, but consider guys who are mid-to-late round picks... signing bonuses under $100k. You spend a few years playing in the minors after high school or JUCO and really have no money to show for it - they'd almost make as much money flipping burgers at mcdonalds.</div>