I'm going with Newton. Even without Sidney (and if Riek gets in shape) we should have a pretty good team. With Newton, we are a much, much better football team.
One stud (Sidney) can make us a final four team. There is not one player is not going to significantly change the football team this year. Too many holes and too much youth.
don't get me wrong as Newton is a very good quarterback but Sidney is a program changer for basketball. When his head is on straight he can carry this team against any other team out there.