I'd like to see him stay. I'd like to see Mullen grab the top athletes from MS year in an year out. It's clear that Ole Miss is using the out-of-state approach and Nutt may likely be a lazy recruiter with respect to local talent. Having that strategy in Oxford lets Mullen work his plan better. Whether that's an effective plan or not remains to be seen, but I think going head to head against Nutt gives Mullen an advantage in achieving his goals. I don't want somebody else sharing a similar plan as Mullen forcing us to share already thin resources.
Plus, as noted by the other posts, there's a significant drop-off in experience/talent at Ole Miss. I think we'll see a couple of mediocre seasons from Nutt over the next 2/3 years should he stay. Combine that with Mullen pushing his buttons and Nutt's past history of embarrassing himself personally at Arkansas, it could make for some entertaining moments.