else think that PI on Redmond was BS? I watched the replay 5 different times and each time thought the same thing.
Did anyone
- Thread starter KurtRambis4
- Start date
I think he called Redmond for holding the WRs arm. I wasn't ever able to get a real clear view of it.
I didn't think it was PI either. But it also wasn't a chop block that got called on them. Both tough calls at full speed. Refs did a pretty good job I thought.
Just from my memory of last night I didn't think he held his arm or anything. The bear td had more contact than Redmond imo
I was about to start a thread on that for I just finished watching the replay of the game. I didn't need to watch it 5 times though. There was a little hand jivin' between the two off the line. However, Redmond was in perfect position and covered Dural perfectly. If you watch it again, he tries to catch it with one hand keeping his inside arm down, to get the call. I'm not saying he did so intentionally to get the call, but if he did I guess it was a pretty savvy move. Yet, given the eventual result; two things:
1) IF, and that's a big if, he was trying to get the call, how is that better than reaching up with two hands to catch a TD?
2) Why didn't they try it again?
1) IF, and that's a big if, he was trying to get the call, how is that better than reaching up with two hands to catch a TD?
2) Why didn't they try it again?
There was minimal
hand contact, between both parties, but nothing that doesn't go on every play. It was most definitely not something that could be called for PI.
hand contact, between both parties, but nothing that doesn't go on every play. It was most definitely not something that could be called for PI.
How about the no call on the running/roughing the punter? I don't think they tipped it.
ETA - apparently - at least according to an Ole Miss fan responding on the Hail State Football facebook page - Rule 9-1-4-a-5-b: The kicker’s protection under this rule ends when he carries the ball outside the tackle box before kicking.
Never knew that. I guess QB's should be fair game outside the tackle box as well.
ETA - apparently - at least according to an Ole Miss fan responding on the Hail State Football facebook page - Rule 9-1-4-a-5-b: The kicker’s protection under this rule ends when he carries the ball outside the tackle box before kicking.
Never knew that. I guess QB's should be fair game outside the tackle box as well.
Last edited:
Only thing I could think of on why that was a no call is that Devon ran about three steps to his right before punting it. That little run may void the normal protection the punter gets because he is now considered a potential runner. No idea if that is the rule but that's the only reason I could think of as to why they didn't call it, because he was clearly run into.
I'm glad they missed one call...after the HUGE 3rd and 10 pickup in the third quarter (right before Dak's long run for TD).
After Bear made a nice catch and run, he tucked the ball under the arm of an LSU DB...who had just gotten his balls stomped by Dillon Day...could have been a big 15-yard penalty. Glad they missed it, but I LOVE the cockiness.
After Bear made a nice catch and run, he tucked the ball under the arm of an LSU DB...who had just gotten his balls stomped by Dillon Day...could have been a big 15-yard penalty. Glad they missed it, but I LOVE the cockiness.
There was more PI on the 3rd down pass we threw to Malcolm later in the game than there was on that play. And no call then...