Diego Pavia is smart...

DerHntr

All-Conference
Sep 18, 2007
15,814
2,727
113

Bulldog45

All-Conference
Oct 2, 2018
1,199
1,747
113
Why would the players agree to a union or collective bargaining? They’ve literally already got everything they could want. And if they want something else they can get it in court. Why would they bargain any of that away?
When the gap between the income of the lower 2/3 and the upper 1/3 gets big enough.
 

Xenomorph

All-American
Feb 15, 2007
15,346
9,046
113
One step closer to the Xeno Model... why are we investing in talent development just to kick them out after 4 years?
 

QuaoarsKing

All-Conference
Mar 11, 2008
5,897
2,539
113
Why would the players agree to a union or collective bargaining? They’ve literally already got everything they could want. And if they want something else they can get it in court. Why would they bargain any of that away?
It won't be the stars who push it, but a union could negotiate higher and more stable benefits for most players.

It will depend on who exactly is included in the union - just football or all sports? D1 only? FBS only? Just the p4? Each conference separately?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bulldog from Birth

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
12,258
11,328
113
A lot of people are saying that there was a ruling that ALL JUCO going forward does not count against NCAA eligibility. I have not yet seen that ruling. I think they all just THINK it will happen again next year.

Either way, this really sucks. We need to clip this off now. This is why we didn't need to do rev share, because people will claim they can't get their piece of the pie. With just NIL, you are what your value is, in the eyes of the collective or whatever business.
 

johnson86-1

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
14,316
4,822
113
I said a year ago get ready for 30 year old college players playing in their 5th team. It’s coming.
That may be coming, but without really knowing the ins and outs of antitrust, his particular argument seems pretty good to me. If you don't enroll in college, your clock doesn't start at all, but if you enroll in community college, your clock starts and if you play sports, it burns a full year of your eligibility. If the NCAA just started your clock at a certain age and didn't reduce your rights based on participating in what is in theory a competing product, it would seem reasonable enough. But since it only negatively impacts your eligibility if you participate in a competing project, that looks iffy on its face to me. Certainly not a legal analysis and I don't think antitrust is really set up to handle college sports at all, but there doesn't seem to be a great argument for why a 30 year old that never went to college can play four years but a 30 year old that went to one semester of community college out of high school has zero eligibility. Looks like punishing people for "competing" even if community colleges aren't in reality in competition with NCAA sports.
 

leeinator

All-Conference
Feb 24, 2014
2,144
1,582
113
I said a year ago get ready for 30 year old college players playing in their 5th team. It’s coming.
Well, college ball is slowly turning into a NFL farm league anyway. I think you'll see career minor league college players before long having 10-15 year careers. The money's just too good vs working a smuck job.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

olblue

All-Conference
Aug 17, 2011
3,574
1,809
113
Well, college ball is slowly turning into a NFL farm league anyway. I think you'll see career minor league college players before long having 10-15 year careers. The money's just too good vs working a smuck job.
College football has always been the NFL’s feeder system.
 
Dec 2, 2021
184
224
43
Well, college ball is slowly turning into a NFL farm league anyway. I think you'll see career minor league college players before long having 10-15 year careers. The money's just too good vs working a smuck job.
I can’t wait to see 32 year-old Dr. Smith, with degrees from UAB, UNC Charlotte, and Arkansas State starting at left tackle for LSU.****

Is there any motivation for schools to keep players from having unlimited eligibility? As long as they are a student in good-standing then they’d be happy to let them continue to light up the gridiron.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: patdog

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
56,743
26,088
113
College football has always been the NFL’s feeder system.
Yeah. I think what it’s becoming is a legitimate sustainable “2nd division or AAA” type league. For players not quite good enough for the NFL whi can have a career in college football, not just 4 years & you’re gone.
 

OG Goat Holder

Heisman
Sep 30, 2022
12,258
11,328
113
Yeah. I think what it’s becoming is a legitimate sustainable “2nd division or AAA” type league. For players not quite good enough for the NFL whi can have a career in college football, not just 4 years & you’re gone.
The good news is, there will be more decent football players across the board. Guess it depends on whether or not all the smaller schools can afford to continue to play football, as to whether it amounts to much across the game as a whole. But if a school could afford the scholarships necessary for whatever division they are in, it's a chance to really have some good talent at the lower levels.