Do we want to see an SEC team win the national title?

Hanmudog

Redshirt
Apr 30, 2006
5,853
0
0
Got to thinking about this, on one hand you want to see your conference known as the best in America but on the other hand it is just one more thing that we have to recruit against with our fellow SEC members.

I am thinking this may be the year I want to see an Oregon/Boise State national title game.
 

fishwater99

Freshman
Jun 4, 2007
14,072
54
48
I always thought you were a little nuts for blindly following Stans like the pied piper, but now I know you are just and idiot...

Why on earth would you not want the SEC to win the national Championship every year?
 

dawgstudent

Heisman
Apr 15, 2003
39,349
18,703
113
anytime they do well, it hurts us as far as recruiting. But them doing well also puts money in our pockets.
 

Hanmudog

Redshirt
Apr 30, 2006
5,853
0
0
fishwater99 said:
I always thought you were a little nuts for blindly following Stans like the pied piper, but now I know you are just and idiot...

Why on earth would you not want the SEC to win the national Championship every year?

Most years I do want the SEC to win the title but this year look at our options:

LSU- Les Miles is the only coach in the universe who could luck into the national title plus I freaking hate LSU.

Auburn- Lead by a guy that was a nut hair away from being our QB. That would just twist the knife.

Alabama- Having to listen to that bunch of inbreds for the last year has been tough. (no offense Tusk) Can't imagine how bad they would be if they repeat.

Not to mention it makes it tougher for us to steal recruits away from these schools. I see nothing "nuts" about that.
 

DawgatAuburn

All-Conference
Apr 25, 2006
10,988
1,791
113
I will live with two in BCS games because that seems logical for the best conference in the country, and because of the financial boost to all 12 of us for the BCS payout. It also moves the rest of us up in the bowl pecking order. The down side of that last one is it gives lesser conferences more favorable matchups than they already have, like the Peach for instance which I think is ACC 2 vs SEC 3/4 or 4/5.
 

Incognegro

Redshirt
Nov 30, 2008
3,037
0
0
would be seeing Boise, TCU or both making it into the game. I know people would be pissed and would do their best to dismantle the BCS and try to instantiate some kind of playoff. The money is great and all, but I really want to know who the best team really is.
 

vandaldawg

Junior
Feb 23, 2008
2,134
308
83
Winning national championships just increases an already truly national recruiting profile. If you look at Bama's want list, it's four corners of the nation. And they are mostly five stars. These are guys that are going to come in and ride the pine behind a previous 5 star with game experience. This could actually end up helping you with an in-state star that is looking to play early and often.

I mean. It's a theory anyway.</p>
 

fishwater99

Freshman
Jun 4, 2007
14,072
54
48
Don't we receive more money for an SEC team winning, and for two SEC teams in the BCS? I think so, that alone should be motivation for the SEC to win.
Personally, I am pulling for Auburn to win it all this year, they got screwed back in 2004. I guess I just don't have the hatred for the other SEC teams that some people do.
 

DowntownDawg

Redshirt
May 28, 2007
3,494
0
0
....and that's fairly hard to do.

I have thought about this lately. In a year like this one, when it looks like State is headed to at least a minor bowl, I think it directly benefits State more to have two in the BCS than it hurts State to have a competitor win the NC.

It could mean the difference between the Liberty Bowl and Cotton Bowl. Or the Gator and Music City. Or God forbid, the Birmingham bowl vs. any other bowl.

Any team that is playing for the national title is just in a different league than us. Period. Bama gets who they want for the most part (Brassell remains to be seen), and this year, they are getting that tight end that we would like to have, but that's about it. They are just on a different playing field, recruit nationally, and we really need to outrecruit the bottom 6, including Ole Miss, to move up in the ranks.

So personally, I'd rather see Florida in the National Championship and another Eastern Division team in a BCS game. That keeps Meyer in good standing, gives State an opportunity at a good bowl, and keeps our closest neighbors out of it. This year? I think the best case scenario, barring us beating Bama, is for Bama to get hot, have some teams lose, and get two in the BCS (whether that is the NC or not). Those teams, at this point, will have to come from the West, and while that hurts us in recruiting directly against those two teams, it potentially puts us pretty high in the pecking order of good bowls.

It's been fun to see the SEC going on a NC winning streak, but I was definitely pulling against Bama last year. I would rather State do well in a weak SEC than do poorly in a strong one.
 

Hanmudog

Redshirt
Apr 30, 2006
5,853
0
0
fishwater99 said:
Don't we receive more money for an SEC team winning, and for two SEC teams in the BCS? I think so, that alone should be motivation for the SEC to win.
Personally, I am pulling for Auburn to win it all this year, they got screwed back in 2004. I guess I just don't have the hatred for the other SEC teams that some people do.

If I had to choose one it would be Auburn. Even though it would be painful to see Cam Newton win the Heisman AND a national title, it would absolutely kill Alabama fans to see Auburn win it. That would be worth it.

I don't hate all SEC teams, just LSU, Bama, and Ole Miss for the most part.
 

AssEndDawg

Freshman
Aug 1, 2007
3,183
54
48
The SEC being the best conference in the nation helps us all. I want us, as a conference, to win the National Championship every year. It's the reason an undefeated SEC will almost always go to the Championship Game (don't prove me wrong this year BCS bastards!).
 

FlabLoser

Redshirt
Aug 20, 2006
10,709
0
0
Match THE Ohio State U against Alabama for a good slober-knocking. Hopefully LSU and/or Auburn take care of business too.

Then everybody bitches about the BCS. Meanwhile, the other big conferences are still our *****.
 

karlchilders.sixpack

All-Conference
Jun 5, 2008
19,668
3,752
113
SEC or not. We are competing very well, and to have the BCS Champion come from the SEC West (which it must this year, or not at all)...I'll take it, and it will not hurt us. We are getting plenty of publicity out of this.

Actually, I'm for the SEC winning this thing on a regular basis.
 

Barkman Turner Overdrive

All-Conference
May 28, 2006
4,549
2,969
113
sidewalk alums have put a bad taste in my mouth. I want to grab them by the neck, shake them and say "you went to Huntingdon College (or Troy State or Birmingham Southern), numbnuts!" That and the whole Cam Newton thing.
 

SLUdog

Redshirt
May 28, 2007
2,149
9
38
If an SEC team happens to make it then I will probably be for that team....except Bama.
 

dogfan96

Redshirt
Jun 3, 2007
2,188
12
66
and the national title game is not the only scenario for two SEC teams getting BCS bowl bids.. it's probably the BEST way but certainly a 2nd team could get a BCS bid whether we have a team in the title game or not. So to answer the original post, not no but HELL NO.
And for the LAST time, Auburn didn't get screwed. They just picked a bad year to go undefeated.. when two teams ranked much higher than them to start off also went undefeated (not to mention one of those teams was USC and they had beaten Auburn in back-to-back seasons..no way were they leapfrogging SC or OU)