Does Philips win ...

Cross Bones

All-Conference
Aug 19, 2001
52,877
3,952
113
I can't see Phillips winning. I don't even know what either has back. I got LA by 2 scores. Maybe I'll come back and revise once the color and color scrimmages take place, but I don't know.
 

BigJohn34

Redshirt
Jul 5, 2017
70
24
0
Don't count out Phillips. The QB is crazy athletic and the skill players can flat out play. Only concern is the O line. What is back is the question
 

McCaravan

All-American
Feb 1, 2016
4,714
7,455
113
They have a punchers chance but I'll say LA 35-21. They will come out strong with their athleticism but they will tire out and run out of gas in the second half
 

ClownBaby

Heisman
Oct 26, 2006
22,188
76,472
113
LA wins by 3 TD's the game will never be in question.

Maybe the top end talent at Phillips is better then the top end at LA but once you get to kids 3-20 the the talent gap will slide heavily to LA.
 

woody6

Junior
Jun 24, 2016
673
280
0
If history tells us anything, special teams disparities that may exist between the 2 programs can not be ignored. I vaguely remember such being a factor in the Johnsburg playoff win against Phillips last fall.
 
May 21, 2017
244
188
0
Saw some of the Phillips kids at the Lake Forest camp and had a chance to briefly speak to them. They are super pumped up for this game. Not only do they truly believe that they will win, but they don't think it'll be a close game. The will to win matters, many times more often than skill. Ask Maine South about that in the final game. If LA matches the desire and the motivation and avoids mental mistakes in that complicated defensive scheme, they'll be fine. Hopefully for them they remember the final game against Maine South as a tool for the motivation and fire they'll surely need and that its not always about the talent.
 

Cclman

Sophomore
Nov 17, 2016
134
171
0
LA graduated a lot of studs on both sides of the ball. Coach Holocek does not prefer to play his players both ways. It'll be interesting how they reload.
 

Cross Bones

All-Conference
Aug 19, 2001
52,877
3,952
113
Saw some of the Phillips kids at the Lake Forest camp and had a chance to briefly speak to them. They are super pumped up for this game. Not only do they truly believe that they will win, but they don't think it'll be a close game. The will to win matters, many times more often than skill. Ask Maine South about that in the final game. If LA matches the desire and the motivation and avoids mental mistakes in that complicated defensive scheme, they'll be fine. Hopefully for them they remember the final game against Maine South as a tool for the motivation and fire they'll surely need and that its not always about the talent.
I don't think people are questioning Phillips skill, but I may be mistaken. But I agree somewhat with @ClownBaby that LA will be better at more positions, most importantly along the lines.

That said I think they'll compete.
 

CPSFan

Sophomore
Nov 15, 2015
271
168
0
Loyola has a major advantage in the trenches. I just don't think Phillips can overcome that.

I would love to be wrong though.
 

McCaravan

All-American
Feb 1, 2016
4,714
7,455
113
LB/DE Terrance Taylor transfered to Phillips from MC. They got TE Jaheel Billingsley too from MC after he was dismissed.
 
May 21, 2017
244
188
0
LB/DE Terrance Taylor transfered to Phillips from MC. They got TE Jaheel Billingsley too from MC after he was dismissed.
This Phillips team is loaded with talent, especially with these latest Mt. Carmel transfers. Tough D1 and possible All Staters at Qb, rb, te, de, dl and the one junior in the secondary. LA will need to bring it.
 

25sparky

Redshirt
Oct 22, 2014
110
7
0
This Phillips team is loaded with talent, especially with these latest Mt. Carmel transfers. Tough D1 and possible All Staters at Qb, rb, te, de, dl and the one junior in the secondary. LA will need to bring it.


So will Byron.
 

SOUTHSIDECFD

Senior
Oct 1, 2009
1,876
767
0
Phillips will make a game of it but with half time adjustments LA wins. Better coaching is key in a game like this.
 

jsoulis

Redshirt
Oct 27, 2015
31
15
8
LA wins easily. 8a vs 5A is a big difference, as if that alone was not enough, they will play one of the most dominant teams not just in the state but the country (have been ranked in top 25 in nation last 2 years). Game over by halftime.
 

Doctor_D

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2016
2,998
2,635
113
LA wins easily. 8a vs 5A is a big difference, as if that alone was not enough, they will play one of the most dominant teams not just in the state but the country (have been ranked in top 25 in nation last 2 years). Game over by halftime.
5A? Phillips is 3A, bro.
 

Voodoo Tatum 21

All-Conference
May 18, 2016
2,970
1,765
0
Makes my point even more. 8A vs 3A?! no chance.

But to quote some on this board - Phillips can pull from 4.9 million population base and they get a lot of transfers into the school. Shouldn't that "even out" the 3A to 8A gap at least some?
 
May 21, 2017
244
188
0
Ok boys - The LA magic will need to be in full force Saturday night. Just informed that their top 4 offensive players are out including the QB plus a sophomore starting on the O line. If they pull this one off - Coach Holocek goes to the top of my list as the top coach in Illinois.


 
May 21, 2017
244
188
0
I couldn't agree more with JC that are not what you think of as 3A. They have D1 level talent at every position from all the transfers. It doesn't matter how big your school is or where you're slated when you have all conference players transferring in. By the way, I don't personally have an issue with that. The kids are doing what they think is best and are within bounds of the current IHSA rules, ( good or bad).
 
  • Like
Reactions: CGsupporter