DYLAN STEWART SUSPENDED FROM PROGRAM

I4CtheFuture

All-Conference
Oct 5, 2024
1,476
1,497
113
I am wondering if Stewart did this intentionally to take his $$$ and get off this Shanetrain wreck of a team. Now he can relax, train, care for his injured back and get ready to be a 2d round draft pick.

I don’t recall him being much of a discipline problem before. Then suddenly he is refusing to come out of the game, arguing with coaches and punching big white dudes in the head. Does not make sense to me.
No.

It doesn't make sense to you because it's clear Dylan has had some sort of "mental break." - I do not believe Stewart planned all this out and then executed the plan on national TV. - If he didn't want to be out there playing for the "Shanetrain wreck" - he could've just kept milking the injury thing, go through the motions, and not play. --- Nah, something snapped in the kid. He needs help. That is clear to me. And I also don't think it was a "moment of hot headedness" - I think there's probably some things going on in Stewarts mind that are deeply troubling and he's feeling pressure and he snapped. - Maybe it's the draft thing. Maybe it's the $$ thing and his family counting on him, etc...maybe he knocked his GF up and no one knows yet. - Whatever it is, the kid is in trouble and needs to surround himself with good people that can help him help himself. I do believe our coaching staff are those good people.....even if they're pissed at him right now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cockofdawn

Cockofdawn

Senior
Aug 16, 2009
767
511
93
I am wondering if Stewart did this intentionally to take his $$$ and get off this Shanetrain wreck of a team. Now he can relax, train, care for his injured back and get ready to be a 2d round draft pick.

I don’t recall him being much of a discipline problem before. Then suddenly he is refusing to come out of the game, arguing with coaches and punching big white dudes in the head. Does not make sense to me.
I too, do not think this was done "Premeditatedly" (i know maybe not a word) but look at that IDIOT QB from Vandy last year, Atitude means a lot to NFL scouts.. A stunt like this could cost him a round or two in the draft. Scouts, i am sure, already question his Health and durability...
 

Deathstar

Sophomore
Sep 6, 2026
198
161
43
I hope he gets the help he needs if he is having some kind of mental problem. You know it could be a brain trauma from playing sports or something like this. He was a good player for us, I wish him the best with his NFL draft.

He has plenty of time now to rehab his back and practice for the combine.
 

Harvard Gamecock

All-Conference
May 5, 2014
3,303
3,033
113
Miami maybe. UGA spends less on NIL than we do and Kirby is all about "hard coaching", he doesn't put up with thug behavior on the team. He has sent several 5 stars packing over the years. Ohio State doesn't want a troublemaker either.

Miami is still Thug U. They would welcome him.
What an inane take.
You clearly have no idea whatsoever how Mario Cristobal runs his team, and the expectations he demands from his players.
Try to keep up with times, and pull yourself out of the 80"s
 
  • Haha
Reactions: USCEE82

Gr8spur

Joined Sep 16, 2003
Sep 16, 2003
574
1,248
93
Here’s part of Beamer’s excuse for a losing season. “We didn’t have the best defensive end in the country playing!”
 

hillna2

Junior
Feb 2, 2022
199
202
43
Y'all are acting like he's the first player to ever throw a punch in a game. He punched a guy that was visibly standing over top of him as he was trying to stand up. I don't think this is some mental breakdown, it's football and he's annoyed. Do I think he should've done it? No, but to take this as a stretch this far, holy cow. The guy has obviously put in the effort and makes a difference on the field. He lives in the backfield and draws double teams almost every play. He even drew at least 3 holding calls against Mississippi St and probably should've been more.

He deserves some type of punishment, but this speculation is insane.

As to the NFL aspect, I don't think they care. Myles Garrett literally hit a dude over the head with his helmet and is the highest paid DE in NFL history. He will be a difference maker at the next level once he gets actual coaching, in reference to the many comments y'all have made in other posts regarding the current status of our head coach...

Edit: Also remember that we love Alshon Jeffrey and he got thrown out of the Capital One Bowl for fighting - he still had a great NFL career and won a Super Bowl. And his name is plastered on the wall of our stadium.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cockofdawn

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
20,664
17,573
113
Y'all are acting like he's the first player to ever throw a punch in a game. He punched a guy that was visibly standing over top of him as he was trying to stand up. I don't think this is some mental breakdown, it's football and he's annoyed. Do I think he should've done it? No, but to take this as a stretch this far, holy cow. The guy has obviously put in the effort and makes a difference on the field. He lives in the backfield and draws double teams almost every play. He even drew at least 3 holding calls against Mississippi St and probably should've been more.

He deserves some type of punishment, but this speculation is insane.

As to the NFL aspect, I don't think they care. Myles Garrett literally hit a dude over the head with his helmet and is the highest paid DE in NFL history. He will be a difference maker at the next level once he gets actual coaching, in reference to the many comments y'all have made in other posts regarding the current status of our head coach...
He's probably suspended more for his blatant disregard of Beamer and the assistant coaches, refusing to come out of the game.
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
6,913
5,701
113
Y'all are acting like he's the first player to ever throw a punch in a game. He punched a guy that was visibly standing over top of him as he was trying to stand up. I don't think this is some mental breakdown, it's football and he's annoyed. Do I think he should've done it? No, but to take this as a stretch this far, holy cow. The guy has obviously put in the effort and makes a difference on the field. He lives in the backfield and draws double teams almost every play. He even drew at least 3 holding calls against Mississippi St and probably should've been more.

He deserves some type of punishment, but this speculation is insane.

As to the NFL aspect, I don't think they care. Myles Garrett literally hit a dude over the head with his helmet and is the highest paid DE in NFL history. He will be a difference maker at the next level once he gets actual coaching, in reference to the many comments y'all have made in other posts regarding the current status of our head coach...

Edit: Also remember that we love Alshon Jeffrey and he got thrown out of the Capital One Bowl for fighting - he still had a great NFL career and won a Super Bowl. And his name is plastered on the wall of our stadium.

Didn't Garrett also do the helmet thing while already in the NFL?

My meaning is that the NFL will take him, vut will he slip spots or rounds due to the fighting, interacting with coaches and the injury thing.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
25,734
3,317
113
Y'all are acting like he's the first player to ever throw a punch in a game. He punched a guy that was visibly standing over top of him as he was trying to stand up. I don't think this is some mental breakdown, it's football and he's annoyed. Do I think he should've done it? No, but to take this as a stretch this far, holy cow. The guy has obviously put in the effort and makes a difference on the field. He lives in the backfield and draws double teams almost every play. He even drew at least 3 holding calls against Mississippi St and probably should've been more.

He deserves some type of punishment, but this speculation is insane.

As to the NFL aspect, I don't think they care. Myles Garrett literally hit a dude over the head with his helmet and is the highest paid DE in NFL history. He will be a difference maker at the next level once he gets actual coaching, in reference to the many comments y'all have made in other posts regarding the current status of our head coach...

Edit: Also remember that we love Alshon Jeffrey and he got thrown out of the Capital One Bowl for fighting - he still had a great NFL career and won a Super Bowl. And his name is plastered on the wall of our stadium.
No player gets to ignore the head coach and asst. coaches, throw punches in a game and expect no consequences. I have to think there must have been a lot more that happened away from the cameras as well. Throwing a punch should/will get a player thrown out of a game, but usually does not get the player suspended. Arguing with the coach, showing no respect for the coach or coaches and having a general bad attitude WILL get a player suspended. I think Beamer has been kissing his a** and Stewart was of the opinion he was bigger than the team and Beamer and/or Donati decided to show him he is not.

Stewart has 1 solo tackle this season, no sacks and no forced fumbles. He isn't exactly a terror on the field this season so far.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

hillna2

Junior
Feb 2, 2022
199
202
43
Didn't Garrett also do the helmet thing while already in the NFL?

My meaning is that the NFL will take him, vut will he slip spots or rounds due to the fighting, interacting with coaches and the injury thing.
He did it while in the NFL, but has gotten more lucrative contracts since then. They're still willing to shell out major money for a guy that assaulted another player on national tv.
 

hillna2

Junior
Feb 2, 2022
199
202
43
No player gets to ignore the head coach and asst. coaches, throw punches in a game and expect no consequences. I have to think there must have been a lot more that happened away from the cameras as well. Throwing a punch should/will get a player thrown out of a game, but usually does not get the player suspended. Arguing with the coach, showing no respect for the coach or coaches and having a general bad attitude WILL get a player suspended. I think Beamer has been kissing his a** and Stewart was of the opinion he was bigger than the team and Beamer and/or Donati decided to show him he is not.

Stewart has 1 solo tackle this season, no sacks and no forced fumbles. He isn't exactly a terror on the field this season so far.
I am in no way saying he shouldn't be suspended, I even said he should have been punished in my post. I'm pointing out the insane speculation everyone has thrown out and stating he's going to lose millions moving forward. What has Shane done to warrant no backlash from players? It is pretty clear that he does not rally the team or coaches to make adjustments in-game. No one here has any hope in him as a leader, why would it be different in the locker room?

He's played 43 snaps this year, in SEC games, and is essentially only a pass rusher, he's not going to have a high tackle count. But he draws double teams and holding calls. Our defense has a total of 5 sacks across 4 games with two opponents being the children of the poor. There really isn't anyone else on the line that other teams are worried about. I would be willing to bet our pressure drops without his presence in the game.
 

Deathstar

Sophomore
Sep 6, 2026
198
161
43
I cannot disagree with you that Beamer’s leadership, or lack thereof, is probably causing some issues with our players. These players work hard and are well paid to do this job, but they have no say in the system or the assistant coaches. Beamer is ultimately responsible for the coaches, discipline, the system and adjustments. Right now we are lacking in all of these areas.
 

Tngamecock

All-Conference
Sep 10, 2000
29,724
2,671
113
100% promise you - it wasn't his call. He's just the face.

Decision was made by the AD. He was asked if he had spoken with the AD today. Answer: Yes.
That’s because he had to inform the athletic Director of what he was doing. When you suspended a player you let your A.D. know. This ain’t hard stuff people.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3USC1801

I4CtheFuture

All-Conference
Oct 5, 2024
1,476
1,497
113
That’s because he had to inform the athletic Director of what he was doing. When you suspended a player you let your A.D. know. This ain’t hard stuff people.
Lol, I don't disagree with you. - What baffles me is that you, and others, apparently believe that it could not have possibly been the other way around. IE: AD calling Shane and telling him it was not an option.

So, you're really going to sit there and deny that it's not even a possibility?
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
25,734
3,317
113
Lol, I don't disagree with you. - What baffles me is that you, and others, apparently believe that it could not have possibly been the other way around. IE: AD calling Shane and telling him it was not an option.

So, you're really going to sit there and deny that it's not even a possibility?
I've never been the biggest Beamer fan, but even I think it was Beamer's call. No coach, at any level, can allow a player to completely disrespect the coach and staff and act like a thug on the field without any consequences. Beamer knows this.

Now, the question is, how long is he suspended? If it is for one game, it shows that Beamer will give in to a star player. The rest of the team will see this and Beamer will have lost whatever authority he had.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Harvard Gamecock

I4CtheFuture

All-Conference
Oct 5, 2024
1,476
1,497
113
I've never been the biggest Beamer fan, but even I think it was Beamer's call. No coach, at any level, can allow a player to completely disrespect the coach and staff and act like a thug on the field without any consequences. Beamer knows this.

Now, the question is, how long is he suspended? If it is for one game, it shows that Beamer will give in to a star player. The rest of the team will see this and Beamer will have lost whatever authority he had.
Fair enough. Math says it will be 3 weeks before Stewart sees the field again. - Given what I think, that Stewarts meltdown went beyond "normal" and there's something else going on in his brain.... I think 3 weeks is a decent amount of time to evaluate if Stewart is following all the advice / directions of coaches, etc.... or if he still has a bad attitude towards everything. I think 3 weeks to evaluate is beyond fair to see some kind of remorse, regret, change, etc. If not, bye. That would be a total shame for all.
 

3USC1801

Joined Dec 10, 2020
Dec 10, 2020
1,281
3,469
113
That’s because he had to inform the athletic Director of what he was doing. When you suspended a player you let your A.D. know. This ain’t hard stuff people.
Correct! Beamer initiated the suspension. Donati had to approve the action since he interfaces with boosters/donors who pay $$$$ for Stewart.
 

USCEE82

Senior
Feb 17, 2024
990
760
93
I am wondering if Stewart did this intentionally to take his $$$ and get off this Shanetrain wreck of a team. Now he can relax, train, care for his injured back and get ready to be a 2d round draft pick.

I don’t recall him being much of a discipline problem before. Then suddenly he is refusing to come out of the game, arguing with coaches and punching big white dudes in the head. Does not make sense to me.
You might be giving him too much credit.
 

USCEE82

Senior
Feb 17, 2024
990
760
93
Didn't Garrett also do the helmet thing while already in the NFL?

My meaning is that the NFL will take him, vut will he slip spots or rounds due to the fighting, interacting with coaches and the injury thing.
Yes. He hit Mason Rudolph in the head with his own helmet! Rudolph is a product of my old high school: Northwestern in Rock Hill.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cockofdawn

JohnnySolo

Senior
May 6, 2011
669
514
63
Hmm hearing some rumblings about portal. Wouldn’t surprise me. I’ve been one of the loudest haters of Stewart for a while. Hope he’s refilling my sweet tea soon.
 
GamecockCentral

Latest

  1. 01 GamecockCentral Baseball Gamecocks in the MLB: 2026 regular season recap
  2. 02 GamecockCentral Football Practice highs become gameday lows for South Carolina
  3. 03 GamecockCentral Baseball Notes and takeaways from Kevin Schnall previewing fall baseball practice
  4. 04 GamecockCentral Football A statistical audit of South Carolina's offense through four games: What's gone right, and what's gone wrong for the Gamecock offense?
  5. 05 GamecockCentral Football Grading the Gamecocks' performance in blowout loss at Alabama