Ellen/Elliot Page

Jan 28, 2007
20,397
30,168
0
I also think it’s telling that every major publication is calling Ellen “he” now and talking about how brave “he” is. This is another agenda move meant to change our culture, done by a bunch of nonsensical childless Brooklyn-based liberals who were the band and newspaper geeks in high school.
 

JumperJack

Heisman
Oct 30, 2002
21,997
65,619
0
Example?

Whats your definition of essentially?

There’s no threat to your free speech about the subject. In fact you’re discussing it now. However, people do have the right to verbally react to the speech just as you have the right to say it. Are you saying people will be mean to you online and that’s upsetting?

That’s how free speech works.

You are wrong. As usual. I won’t do your homework (yet again) for you. You can start with the law in NYC. You can read about Britain, or Jordan Peterson.

It is coerced speech, which is illegal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gassy_Knowls

BlueVelvetFog

Heisman
Apr 12, 2016
13,453
17,970
78
Freedom of speech doesn’t entail entail freedom from consequences of your speech. Do stupid stuff, win stupid prizes.

And also, private businesses don’t have to grant any freedom of speech. Therefore, the situation you posted isn’t trampling on freedom of speech because you legally never had it at that company to begin with.
You’re a solid poster, and I like your posts—but cancellation can come out of nowhere. A slip of the tongue and you lose your job? Like it did to Kappell? He was fired and driven out of Rochester by the hand of an incompetent mayor. I don’t think he signed on to do the weather that day for the purposes of playing stupid games.

What if it happened to you? No one is immune from this. Someone will mistake Jerry Rice for Daryl Strawberry then boom. It starts over
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JumperJack

Greatestalltime

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2019
1,084
1,209
0
You are wrong. As usual. I won’t do your homework (yet again) for you. You can start with the law in NYC. You can read about Britain, or Jordan Peterson.

It is coerced speech, which is illegal.
So basically you’re sayin that people shouldn’t speak out about their gender/what they feel they need to share—because that makes it difficult for you to speak out without people being upset about your speech?
 

JumperJack

Heisman
Oct 30, 2002
21,997
65,619
0
So basically you’re sayin that people shouldn’t speak out about their gender/what they feel they need to share—because that makes it difficult for you to speak out without people being upset about your speech?

 
  • Like
Reactions: Tinker Dan

JumperJack

Heisman
Oct 30, 2002
21,997
65,619
0
Always have and always do stupid.

Are you ever right?

Who’s switch names for internet facesaving? More projection by you. Only a person like you would stoop to that level.

I’m not always right, but am always right in comparison to you. Watched the Peterson clip yet?
 

Backer cutter

Heisman
Jul 8, 2019
7,707
20,355
0
Weird thread. I’ve fathered children. My wife has given birth to children. What’s the problem? It’s natural. Ohh, well, yeah. That’s not natural. So stop trying to reverse it, ain’t gonna work. Wasting your time man.
 
  • Like
Reactions: P19978

BMoore2

All-Conference
Nov 22, 2017
2,596
3,218
108
There is no freedom from consequences when it comes to public speech. There probably should be, but honestly, something that is expressly classified as an opinion and does not attack anyone in any way is the only thing that should be protected. I think unions need to do a better job of protecting those with politically unpopular viewpoints from being fired (those who are employees at Google or Twitter who get fired because they stand up to PC bullies). Racist/sexist/xenophobic slurs, etc, though? Bye.
 
Mar 23, 2012
23,493
6,068
0
There is no freedom from consequences when it comes to public speech. There probably should be, but honestly, something that is expressly classified as an opinion and does not attack anyone in any way is the only thing that should be protected. I think unions need to do a better job of protecting those with politically unpopular viewpoints from being fired (those who are employees at Google or Twitter who get fired because they stand up to PC bullies). Racist/sexist/xenophobic slurs, etc, though? Bye.
But the same people who are always crying about free speech are the ones that elect politicians that want to cripple the power of unions at every turn.
 

BMoore2

All-Conference
Nov 22, 2017
2,596
3,218
108
No, they don’t want that, but they are tired of liberal politicians sitting there, saying they should stand there and stop complaining about the way of life they enjoyed for many years being gradually ripped away.
No, they don’t want immigrants who are not lawfully here driving down wages while being a pet group for the Democrats.
No, they don’t want America’s history, which was once (ten years ago) revered as being spectacular, aside from the original sins of slavery and the genocide of Native Americans, being relitigated, so that future generations of children are taught America was never that great, and we have no reason to fight for its ideals.
Republicans are openly meaner and more gruff, but at least they don’t constantly try to create victim groups that they imply white people should bow to.
We need a third party.
By the way, I am a Democrat. I just get tired of people constantly trying to create new social constructs. Leave people alone, and help us try to move forward.
We were in a good spot in 1999. Things changed quickly.
 
Mar 23, 2012
23,493
6,068
0
No, they don’t want that, but they are tired of liberal politicians sitting there, saying they should stand there and stop complaining about the way of life they enjoyed for many years being gradually ripped away.
No, they don’t want immigrants who are not lawfully here driving down wages while being a pet group for the Democrats.
No, they don’t want America’s history, which was once (ten years ago) revered as being spectacular, aside from the original sins of slavery and the genocide of Native Americans, being relitigated, so that future generations of children are taught America was never that great, and we have no reason to fight for its ideals.
Republicans are openly meaner and more gruff, but at least they don’t constantly try to create victim groups that they imply white people should bow to.
We need a third party.
By the way, I am a Democrat. I just get tired of people constantly trying to create new social constructs. Leave people alone, and help us try to move forward.
We were in a good spot in 1999. Things changed quickly.
Have you ever taken an American History class, you think the only sinful things this country has done are slavery and Native American genocide?

Just to name one additional one, we literally ran internment camps for people of Japanese ancestry living in America (primarily on the West Coast due to designated wartime exclusion zones) during World War II and stole all their property and belongings just because of the color of their skin.
 

SDC_99

All-Conference
Sep 2, 2020
1,087
4,144
0
Have you ever taken an American History class, you think the only sinful things this country has done are slavery and Native American genocide?

Just to name one additional one, we literally ran internment camps for people of Japanese ancestry living in America (primarily on the West Coast due to designated wartime exclusion zones) during World War II and stole all their property and belongings just because of the color of their skin.

Just because they were waging an existential war for civilzation. Had they lost, you wouldn't exist and none of this would be like it is now but much, much worse.

The mindchuck they did on you people in "school" is really something else, really remarkable, really unbelievable and really pathetic.

That doesn't forgive the past evils, but whatever moment in time you look back on to wag your moralistic finger at like you are better (you aren't), the rest of the world at that time WAS MORE EVIL, MORE RACIST.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JumperJack
Mar 23, 2012
23,493
6,068
0
Just because they were waging an existential war for civilzation. Had they lost, you wouldn't exist and none of this would be like it is now but much, much worse.

The mindchuck they did on you people in "school" is really something else, really remarkable, really unbelievable and really pathetic.

That doesn't forgive the past evils, but whatever moment in time you look back on to wag your moralistic finger at like you are better (you aren't), the rest of the world at that time WAS MORE EVIL, MORE RACIST.
Just because someone else was worse at something than America was doesn’t make it right. If I steal three video games from Walmart while my friend steals a PS5 and five video games, that doesn’t make what I did any less of a sin. A sin is a sin no matter what anyone else does.

And a war doesn’t absolve the US from illegally detaining American citizens without due process. There’s a reason why even conservative hero Ronald Reagan publicly apologized on the record for the sin of Japanese internment and awarded reparations.
 

SDC_99

All-Conference
Sep 2, 2020
1,087
4,144
0
Never said it made it right, nor did I imply it, even explicitly said that it doesn't forgive past evils.

All sorts of things are happening today too that aren't right either. It is not like we've reached peak morality; there are going to be things we find acceptable today that "rightly" and "wrongly" won't be in the future, but foundational American values like freedom of speech are self-evident truths that cannot be infringed should not be one of them.
 

P19978

Heisman
Mar 30, 2004
9,319
24,571
0
Why cant the fat ugly chicks transgender?

This chick is not unattractive... would much rather keep the attractive ones hetero... and give them the Rosie O'Donnells of the world.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Atrain7732

PsychoticGerbil

Sophomore
Feb 27, 2020
152
112
0
Let me get this straight: Ellen, a very vocal lesbian and all things LBGTQ rights, has now come out as a 'trans' (no surprise to me as 'she' wasn't very feminine looking). Yet, he/she emphatically states that he/she is gay. So, 'she' was originally a 'he' who was attracted to women. Wouldn't that make 'him' hetero? Good God, a psychiatrist could make a complete fortune off this poor person's self-image. At most levels, I could not care less. At some level, I feel very, very sorry for this person who is very messed up in the head and, evidently, has some severe self-image problems. Somebody somewhere let her/him down and didn't get him/her the help needed.

Why do you even care?

I seriously doubt you're worried about this "poor person". Sounds more like prejudice that you're too cowardly to go full tilt on.
 

J_Dee

All-Conference
Mar 21, 2008
4,284
4,317
0
Elliot Page's statement on the topic at hand:

Elliot Page said:
Hi friends, I want to share with you that I am trans, my pronouns are he/they and my name is Elliot. I feel lucky to be writing this. To be here. To have arrived at this place in my life. I feel overwhelming gratitude for the incredible people who have supported me along this journey. I can’t begin to express how remarkable it feels to finally love who I am enough to pursue my authentic self. I’ve been endlessly inspired by so many in the trans community. Thank you for your courage, your generosity and ceaselessly working to make this world a more inclusive and compassionate place. I will offer whatever support I can and continue to strive for a more loving and equal society.

I love that I am trans. And I love that I am *****. And the more I hold myself close and fully embrace who I am, the more I dream, the more my heart grows and the more I thrive. To all the trans people who deal with harassment, self-loathing, abuse, and the threat of violence every day: I see you, I love you, and I will do everything I can to change this world for the better.

Excellent. I'm happy for him and I hope that his decision to openly share his feelings on this matter can help inspire confidence and self-worth in anyone else who's struggling against any form of intolerance. :)
 

812scottj

All-Conference
Apr 24, 2014
1,873
3,701
113
Identify as you wish...doesn’t make it true. Bottom line...leave my tax dollars out of it. This whole thing is about the fringe screaming, “LOOK AT ME!!!” There’s such a thing as negative attention
 

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
37,311
57,152
113
This is batshit crazy:


Deadnaming: A trans person’s given or former name that they no longer use, also often referred to as a “given name” or “legal name.” … While deadname is usually a noun, it’s also used as a verb to refer to the act of using the wrong name for a trans person.

How to correct it?


Practice (on your own time)
If you find that you’re having a difficult time remembering to use a trans person’s name or pronouns, Kleine suggests putting the time and effort into changing that. “Sometimes that means practicing when they’re not around, just getting comfortable with new pronouns to make sure that you can get it right when you are around this person that you care about,” they said. What would this look like? Perhaps just repeating the name while thinking of the person’s face, and saying it aloud alongside their pronouns.

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

So we all need to practice calling Ellen, or Elliot, by her real names and pronouns.. whatever she feels like she wants to be called.. And we need to do that for every individual trans person out there?

I don't care how awful this sounds: I have ZERO desire to interact with someone who would get this up in arms about me getting their name/pronouns wrong every now and then. If you're trans? Cool, whatever. If you're this uptight about it? You can stay away. Practicing your pronouns on MY won time.. **** out of here.
 
Nov 28, 2003
12,024
12,437
113
Have you ever taken an American History class, you think the only sinful things this country has done are slavery and Native American genocide?

Just to name one additional one, we literally ran internment camps for people of Japanese ancestry living in America (primarily on the West Coast due to designated wartime exclusion zones) during World War II and stole all their property and belongings just because of the color of their skin.
That's why all the asians are rioting, menacing, vandalizing, pillaging, desecrating, tearing down statues...oh wait...

America isn't perfect. But until recently it was the best thing going, politically, economically, diversity-wise, freedom-wise, etc. Now we're reduced to p!ssing matches over pronouns and attempts to mandate acceptance of an individual's self-delusions.
 

Bigtyrone

All-American
May 21, 2002
10,491
6,139
68
Then I misread it. I thought the article said that she used to be a he not that she is going to be transitioning to a he. So she has always felt like a he. But, if she successfully transitions to a he and dates women, wouldn't the new he be hetero? See how confusing this gets?

I think I just gave myself a headache.

I think the term ***** is now acceptable and can be used to cover any situation like this.