ESPN'S Todd McShay's Top 5 Heisman choices

[Thick]

1. Ingram - RB Bama
2. Spiller - RB Clemson
3. Devine - RB WVU
4. Keenum - QB Houston
5. McCoy - QB Texas

Who is Todd McShay? What say the Sixpackers?

 

[JohnDawg]

He should know by now, it's the best player on the best team. Come on Todd, get with the program. CJ Spiller is a great player, but should not be on this list. And if we're going by stats alone, I'd go with Jimmy Clausen over Colt McCoy. I'd probably agree with the others. Definitely Ingram and Keenum.

 

[Optimus Prime 4]

[No message]

 

[dogfan96]

although nobody will take him seriously bc he's a true freshman.

 

[FlabLoser]

He is the best college QB I have ever seen in person, thanks to Tebow's recent demotion.

 

[GBryne4Heisman]

No Charles Scott?

CJ Spiller is an outstanding player, but probably doesn't deserve much Heisman talk w/ 500 yards and 3 TDs on the season. Hell of a pro prospect though.

I dont believe Ingram in the front runner. He struggled against UT, ended up w/ 99 yards I think, but didn't look very good. On top of that he's got some tough teams coming up (MSU, UF, Auburn).

Clausen is my pick right now.

 

[Lion O]

Ingram or Clausen probably would get my vote.

If we're going just off of stats, I'd say Freddie Barnes for Bowling Green....99 catches, 1054 yards, 9 TD, 131 ypg......in 8 games. I know its for BG, but those numbers are sick.