Not a ridiculous suggestion. If you recall when FSU won a National Title with Charlie Ward at QB, it took Bobby Bowden to basically do the same thing and let the athlete do his own thing. That's gotta be a very difficult decision as a head coach, but in that case, it was one that resulted in success.
I totally get what you guys are saying. The coaches track the results of when he follows the system and when he doesn't - every intelligent thing I have seen posted is he is worse when he goes playground. UCLA game wasn't going playground - or beating Georgia; our coaches game plan throwing bombs, its part of their plan to keep the D honest. TA can absolutely do it in this system as modified and as suggested by many.
Someone had a great breakdown of him last year; he had multiple quarters completing over 70% in this system. Its when he audibles a lot or goes playground his %'s have dropped to the twenties and the interceptions come. I think they should pull him when he gets jumpy and then reinsert him. He is a very real talent.
Passes to uncovered linebackers and linemen near the goal line shouldn't be seen often or at all past middle school; ugh.
Looking at posts; if seen at an extreme; Are we suggesting falling into a trap of letting a low 50% passer, who throws a lot of crazy interceptions, run around in circles whenever he wants? How about a rb that reverses every time a hole starts to close and breaks one once in a while - but fumbles and tries to lateral a lot , sound like a starter ?
I would rather try Fyfe and others or rotate them in for relief to spell his bad spots.But I -2 more victories and the ridicule of a runaway qb ( won't happen and even TA would say change something ), don't add up to ok for me.