Fantasy Baseball question - Who to keep for next season?

[missouridawg]

In a keeper league and I gotta keep 3 for next season. 1 pitcher for sure and 1 hitter for sure.... the third can be either.

I currently have:
Tim Lincecum
Josh Johnson
Carlos Gonzalez
Matt Holliday
Ryan Zimmerman

I know Lincecum and Cargo are pretty much locks, but I'm having trouble with the final spot. What say ye?

 

[jeremyrbrown]

nmnm

 

[cheat2win]

For example are your picks averaged with where they are drafted and predicted to be?

 

[missouridawg]

You get your 3 keepers and the draft order next year is based on your finish this year.

 

[EmoryBellard]

Holliday is merely ite as a fantasy player, and ite OFs are readily available.

 

[fishwater99]

From your list Johnson or Zimmerman, and has been below par this year with the Nats...

 

[dawgs.sixpack]

i'd try to trade zimmerman at an inflated value due to someone buying into position scarcity.

i think position scarcity can be overrated. zimmerman is a good player, but if you are spending a top 3 round pick on him, you might get holliday numbers, but really zimmerman is a .290-20-90 guy. that's it. and he's been awful this year (yeah injuries i know, but he's always dinged it seems - another negative). i'd see if you could swing zimmerman for a guy you like more (play up the 3B eligibility) and just take beltre or someone next year.

 

[pchaney301]

I'd go with Gonzalez. He'll bounce back.