Fantasy Football: Jeremy Maclin or Steve Smith (Giants)?

[Curly Bill]

Also, Matt Cassell or David Garrard?

Thanks

 

[tenureplan]

I would probably go with either over maclin...He is the #2 and isn't consistant on a weekly basis. Besides, Mcnabb is due for another "Oakland" game.

For QB, I dont like either choice...the Chiefs can't score and Garrard has been horrible over the past 2 weeks. He has had his better weeks when the Jags are getting beat handily and I don't see the Chiefs ever having the lead. Further, his coach took away his ability to check out of run plays and said they were going to put more emphasis on running after Jones-Drew only had 7 carries last week. I would pick up Alex Smith off waivers. Otherwise Garrard is probably the better play.

 

[dogfan96]

and has always had a very low INT ratio.. I'm still not sure I go with Maclin but not because of McNabb.. I think Philly is going to score 30-40 points.. just don't know who's going to be on the receiving end. They have Westbrook, McCoy, Jackson, and Celek. Lots of threats on offense.