HS Portal

31ocdavis

Junior
Aug 8, 2025
189
302
63
I'll start by saying I am open to changing my mind on this. I have been a teacher and coach in NC for about 10 years. I agree that for athletics, school choice has been bad. I also agree with the folks who are upset about private school vouchers. But I don't have any issue from the academic perspective with magnet programs and charter schools. I do not believe it is the job of school systems to fix societal inequality. When schools take on that responsibility it inevitably leads to bad policy and disillusionment, i.e. busing.

If I choose to live in a certain neighborhood or apartment complex, why should I get no choice in which school my kids can attend? What if my local school has a track record of awful state testing scores? What if my local school pushes curriculum I don't agree with (thinking less about culture wars and more about methods like Phonics to teach reading)? Without school choice, my kids are stuck attending the local school unless I make enough money to send them to a private school. In almost every other area of American society we encourage choice, mobility, and competition.

All that being said, I still believe schools are primarily about academics first, then extracurriculars. I have no solutions for all of the transferring that is being talked about in this thread. I don't like it, but other than forcing everyone into their local school and true enforcement, I don't know how you fix it.
Just watched State Lines, a program about issues facing the North Carolina legislature. Four panelists, two journalists and one legislator from each party. The Republican legislator just confirmed that they are looking at statewide open enrollment. It’s coming.
 

drop_tables

All-Conference
Aug 14, 2004
4,573
1,713
113
Just watched State Lines, a program about issues facing the North Carolina legislature. Four panelists, two journalists and one legislator from each party. The Republican legislator just confirmed that they are looking at statewide open enrollment. It’s coming.
its already here..... has been for years
 

31ocdavis

Junior
Aug 8, 2025
189
302
63
its already here..... has been for years
Maybe more in some places than others. But nowhere near what the legislature is talking about. For any student. For any reason. So, for instance, a high school student could attend four high schools in four years. Or conceivably, more than four.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: Kylar24
Jan 12, 2026
9
7
3
its already here..... has been for years
It is not here to that scale - at least not in Wake County, and I would guess most school districts in the state. There are some magnet schools in Wake County, but not all of them. And it is impossible to enforce transfer policies when a family lies or rents an apartment in a district. But what I assume 31ocdavis is talking about is anyone can attempt to attend any public high school if there is room.

If this happens, these schools are going to have to create legit admissions offices because this goes way beyond a handful of football players transferring to Hough.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bigdadd1110

Bigdadd1110

All-Conference
Jun 9, 2004
12,216
1,502
81
Maybe more in some places than others. But nowhere near what the legislature is talking about. For any student. For any reason. So, for instance, a high school student could attend four high schools in four years. Or conceivably, more than four.
Yes. exactly. We have previously had open enrollment with limitations. They are pushing FULL open enrollment where students can choose with residency being the key factor and a school having caps. IE we can now have white only and minority only schools and affluents that dont want public option will get voucher for public and politicians can open more charter schools which have business interest. Its crazy how welfare is called entitlement, but company subsidies, and private school vouchers are not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 31ocdavis
Jan 14, 2017
278
221
43
It just absolutely blows my mind that people uproot their family to move so that a kid can play a sport at a certain high school. I know i am growing into my grumpy old man role but still. And I already know the responses "doing it for the kid", "providing the best opportunity.." blah, blah blah.....i still stand by if you are good enough they will find you. I just got through checking out the article about what high school the starters for the super bowl teams played at and did a little digging. Anfernee Jennings, starting LB for the Patriots played at the power house Dadeville High school in Ala. with a student population of around 520 students. And some how he made it to the pro's without moving to increase his exposure, better his opportunity. He is not the only one who made it without having to move, transfer or relocate. In this day, in this transfer portal era it makes even less sense to move because most colleges aren't recruiting high schools the way they used to any ways. Why not let your kid play with the kids he grew up with and enjoy the sport while he can before it turns into the business that college has become?
 
Jan 12, 2026
9
7
3
It just absolutely blows my mind that people uproot their family to move so that a kid can play a sport at a certain high school. I know i am growing into my grumpy old man role but still. And I already know the responses "doing it for the kid", "providing the best opportunity.." blah, blah blah.....i still stand by if you are good enough they will find you. I just got through checking out the article about what high school the starters for the super bowl teams played at and did a little digging. Anfernee Jennings, starting LB for the Patriots played at the power house Dadeville High school in Ala. with a student population of around 520 students. And some how he made it to the pro's without moving to increase his exposure, better his opportunity. He is not the only one who made it without having to move, transfer or relocate. In this day, in this transfer portal era it makes even less sense to move because most colleges aren't recruiting high schools the way they used to any ways. Why not let your kid play with the kids he grew up with and enjoy the sport while he can before it turns into the business that college has become?
Ultimately I agree with you. But to play devil's advocate - there is a massive gap in the haves and have nots. It has been referenced already but to be more specific - some schools have constant coaching turnover, which means little to no offseason program, constant changing of offensive and defensive systems, etc. so they're unable develop talent. Some schools value football more by having a weightlifting or football class during the school day with students that are hand-picked by the staff. Some schools have coaches who are better connected and have been around longer so they know how to navigate recruiting and provide sound advice while others are just trying to field a team. Some schools are located in areas of the state where they can get lots of help from people outside of the school building. So I don't think it is purely about trying to get the best scholarship opportunity (although that is what dominates social media). For some families, they love football and the school down the road or across the county line loves football more than the one they are districted to.
 

Vik-Val 86

All-American
May 20, 2020
9,142
7,968
113
Reagan will pick up a transfer QB from Statesville. Add that along with the good RB that Reagan has. They will be in for good season