Hypothetical District Proposal

Patrick Devitt

Sophomore
Sep 13, 2025
208
188
43
This is an exercise for fun, unless the IHSA wants to put this onto their proposal ballot lol.

We’re pretending that I am in charge of the how the season will work.

We are going back to the traditional 256 teams making the playoffs.

I took all the 11 man playing schools and broke them up into regional based districts on geography and enrollment. The multiplier was used for this exercise, but I did not use success factor.

For Classes 1A-3A we have a perfect breakdown on 64 teams per classification with 8 districts of 8 teams. Each team in this classification will play 7 district games and 2 non-district games. The top four finishers from each district will advance to the playoffs. The district games will be what counts toward your playoff qualification, so if you go 0-2 in non-district, but 7-0 in district you’re in. This is to promote better non-district matchups.

For Classes 4A-8A the classifications have 65 teams per classification with 9 districts make up of either 7 or 8 teams. The number of non-district games will depend on how many district opponents you need to play, so either 6 of 7 district games, then 2 or 3 non-district games. The top 3 finishers from each district will qualify (27 teams) with the final 5 qualifiers being at-large bids (using a SOS formula)

Use \(w=1.00\) for a district game and \(w=1.25\) for a non-district game. Calculate each opponent’s win percentage excluding its game against the team being rated. A score near 60 would indicate a stronger schedule than a score near 50.

This harkens back to scheduling tough opponents in non-district games! You should be rewarded by going out and scheduling quality teams.

For the playoffs we will use entire W-L record and playoff points to seed the playoff brackets 1-32

Hope you enjoyed this fun exercise!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Roamin' Catholic

oldfan123

Freshman
Jun 20, 2013
272
96
15
Brother Rice, St.Rita, St. Patrick, Chicago Hope Academy & East St.Louis would NEVER lose a district game ever let alone have a game that wasn’t a running clock. Argo would be hard pressed to ever win a district game
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: cigaros

Cpacmel11

Sophomore
Aug 31, 2001
440
110
31
Pretty cool to see. Plainfield South and Plainfield North should be switched, especially if your shooting for Geography. Stagg should probably be with Sandberg too. Awesome work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Patrick Devitt

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,427
4,187
113
Some of these districts are just absolutely unsustainable. There are always going to be programs that are bottom feeders for a multitude of reasons but with districts they have no choice to change conferences ect. This also goes for the good teams as well that would be grouped with with teams that are not on their level. I'm a hard "No" on districts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: oldfan123 and 4Afan

oldfan123

Freshman
Jun 20, 2013
272
96
15
Some of these districts are just absolutely unsustainable. There are always going to be programs that are bottom feeders for a multitude of reasons but with districts they have no choice to change conferences ect. This also goes for the good teams as well that would be grouped with with teams that are not on their level. I'm a hard "No" on districts.
I’m not one for everyone gets a trophy but my god there will be some blood baths on a weekly/yearly basis
 

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,427
4,187
113
I’m not one for everyone gets a trophy but my god there will be some blood baths on a weekly/yearly basis
What does the mythical "everyone gets a trophy" line have to do with districts? There are some districts that are a kin to Alabama playing Chicago State and the like...ya no thanks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: oldfan123

RetiredReferee

All-Conference
Aug 27, 2011
1,099
1,093
113
Providence should not play in a conference/district that includes Tinley Park, Hillcrest, Evergreen Park, and CPS schools.

What districts also do not take into account is that for most school districts they want their schools in the same conference. 230, 228, 218, 214, 211, the Plainfields. They may be in different divisions, but they want them in the same conference.
 
  • Like
Reactions: good_nocall
Edgy Tim

Latest

  1. 01 Edgy Tim Football Preview: Week 9 Top Games to Watch
  2. 02 Edgy Tim Football Podcast: 3rd and Leng with Shawn Skinner
  3. 03 Edgy Tim Football Watch Live Tonight: WJOL Pigskin Preview
  4. 04 Blue and Gold Football Recruiting Notre Dame impressed Rivals300 four-star OT Kajus Muralis. Is it enough to stay No. 1?
  5. 05 Edgy Tim Football Breakdown: York Dukes