Here's where I'll agree with the OP . . .
before the Georgia game, I felt like it would be pretty okay for us if we won out (beating UGA and UT), but Florida still took the East.
If we had gone 8-4(6-2) and carried momentum into a bowl game that we won, I wouldn't be too disappointed.
It's not as if winning the East is a necessary program builder (see: Missouri).
That said, had we gotten there with a 6-2 record in the East, we would have been the feel good story and gotten a lot of attention that could have helped recruiting.
If we get to 5-3, and make it (especially if we lose to Louisville along the way), I'm not sure that we are going to get a lot of positive attention. The focus, instead, will likely be on how weak the SEC East is.