But I will accept your apology and move on.
I do agree that more contributions can help with success. I only said that stuff to counter the belief of many that we 'owe' it to the university to contribute. I loved my time there, but they viewed me as an asset to be milked, as purely business, and i apply that view back to MSU now whenever money comes up. You reap what you sow.
Let me try to explain the StubHub thing by trying a different analogy. Think of a BBQ or cook off or whatever, where it's understood that the costs will be shared by all involved. But at the event, the host asks you for money, while many more 'connected' peeps are eating for free.
I don't think StubHub should be shut down. But it would not bethat hardfor the university to take up that action. They just choose not to. They could print 'owners' names on the tickets. If the owner can't attend and would like to gift their tix to a friend, then the university can process the request and print some sort of pass for that for a small fee. I'm sure there are other ways to accomplish the same thing. They could crack down on scalping/StubHub, and offer to exchange individual season tix back from owners for the face price, then auction them off much like StubHub. They could make clear that tix are the property of the university, for the exclusive use of the season ticket holder, are not to be resold or gifted, and issue cease-and-desist letters to StubHub. Let me reiterate that i undestand there are reasons not to do this, that it would cause some inconvienience for fans, and some effort by the AD. And i have no problem with them not doing it. BUT, for one thing, when they pass on that revenue, and then ask me for money, or even worse those like you suggest i'm obligated to help cover that revenue, that i have a problem with. Like i said, if they choose to pass on other sources of revenue, then they must not need mine that badly. And maybe it's not even that much revunue, but it's sure more than i can provide.
Second, the system as it stands incentivizes me not to join! I live far away, and cannot attend every game, especially if it's a Thursday game. The seats I can get in my name suck, and i am given no indication of how long it would take to move to the lower level, nor would i be given an indication of how much closer i would be to that goal each year. my understanding is you may get a phone call, like winning the lottery, if you get lucky enough. But with the current system, i can pass on games that are hard to attend, get tix from friends or cheap from scalpers for lower attended games, and put the money saved towards good seat tix off StubHub for the marque games, and if none of the above happen then watch on TV. That process just works better for my needs than what the university is offering. But nothing is stopping the university from offering something closer to my needs. They just choose not to.
You yourself are lamenting that there are only 8200 Bulldog club members. Are you going to attack all the rest as not being 'true' fans, or maybe consider that the system itself is why so few are members? Maybe the priorty system can be more clear?
Or think of it this way. What they are offering is to sell me something i don't want (upper level tix) for years, on the possibility thatin the futurethey will offer to sell me something i want (lower level tix), that i can get now and probably later without the AD (StubHub). See now why many don't join?</p>