If Beamer Leaves for V.Tech....

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
18,677
15,652
113
True, I don't understand why we start worrying about them leaving after one good season. I can see a one-year extension and/or a modest raise but throw the bank at them is ridiculous.

In some respects, I get it. Teams everywhere are looking for the next big thing and are wiling to jump on any head coach who has shown a pulse. See Mel Tucker. So, yeah, like you say, some modest raise/extension, but we certainly overreact.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Skuddy

kidrobinski

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2004
1,245
1,068
113
I personally haven't lamented it much more than other losses.

I understand your point. I felt somewhat the same way about the 1999 team. The results were ugly but you could see groundwork being laid for what transpired the following season. However, I've seen us give valiant effort in a losing cause more times than I can count. I would eventually like to see us be a winning program.

Of course, I certainly understand it doesn't matter I feel or you feel or anyone else feels. It doesn't change one iota about the program. But it would sure would be nice to get to cheer for a winner one day.
Gotcha. And it would be nice. And I’ve seen that mountain top with our men’s basketball team. You’ve seen it with our baseball team. And here we are, right back in our lane, with both programs.

I don’t much care about the fan’s desires anymore; I’ve been embarrassed at road games enough to where I had enough. I feel for our coaches and players though. The outside world sees it as a business. Inside there are life lessons and relationships being made and being built; the work and investment the players and coaches put in, whether it’s ultimately manifested in terms of winning games or not, affects each of them deeply and permanently for the most part. They are the ones I would wish success for.

In the meantime, Stephen Stills stated it eloquently; if you can’t be with the one you love….
 
  • Like
Reactions: 18IsTheMan

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
18,677
15,652
113
Logical post; well done.

You and others call it'serious about football.' To me its that we are not willing to go to the depths and actions that other programs do and have done just to win football games. I have quite a few Georgia friends and when they lose a game, to many of them the season is over; lose another and its over for all of them. Thats just not the way I roll, and many, many are like me. I don't see ESPN highlights and talking heads when I think Gamecock football; I see green grass, time spent with my father and now my son on the way up and back as well as being there, talking strategies and players, etc. Using Georgia as an example again and now LSU, Richt and Kelley, thats just not something I admire and thats not 'worth it' to me personally. I've said before, Gamecock sports is what I have chosen and to me, its like a set of books; each season is a volume that I wait eight months for and each game, preseason and postseason are chapters. I enjoy reading the books. I know this is a very unpopular perspective on social media, but here we are.

Carry on.

I would assume this speaks to your shunning of the "win at all cost" mentality?

Frankly, I am highly aligned with him philosophically on most things.

 

kidrobinski

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2004
1,245
1,068
113
I would assume this speaks to your shunning of the "win at all cost" mentality?

Frankly, I am highly aligned with him philosophically on most things.

That’s the general idea yes. I played for Dick Sheridan in high school; Swinney is very similar. Other than that, I’d throw up in my mouth if I said anything else.
 

SouthernBelly

Senior
Sep 16, 2024
755
581
93
Wait a minute. Smart ain't close to Franklin or Herman. Both of the latter are overhyped guys with good agents and a year or two good seasons that "made" them. What Clark Lea has done at Vandy in PRESENT day football is more impressive than anything Franklin or any other Vandy coach has done in the last 50 years. I know we aren't getting Lea and aren't going after him.....just to illustrate Lea > Franklin.
Which ones were Franklin's one or two good years that his agent leveraged? The back to back 9-4 seasons at Vandy or 2 of the 5 seasons at PSU where he got at least 10 wins?
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
18,677
15,652
113
Wait a minute. Smart ain't close to Franklin or Herman. Both of the latter are overhyped guys with good agents and a year or two good seasons that "made" them. What Clark Lea has done at Vandy in PRESENT day football is more impressive than anything Franklin or any other Vandy coach has done in the last 50 years. I know we aren't getting Lea and aren't going after him.....just to illustrate Lea > Franklin.

Lea so far is 23-34 at Vandy in his 5th season. He was 7-6 last year. If he takes Vandy to the playoffs, that will be an accomplishment indeed. Franklin had 24 wins in 3 seasons.

However, Franklin's accomplishments there still dwarf Lea's at this point. Lea is winning right now b/c he has a QB who transferred there after playing a decade or so elsewhere and then sued b/c he wanted to keep playing into his retirement years.

Franklin led Vandy to back-to-back 9-4 seasons, 3 consecutive bowl appearances with 2 consecutive wins and 2 consecutive top 25 finishes WITHOUT any of the massive benefit from NIL or transfer portal or essentially unlimited eligibility that players have now. THAT was a monumental achievement. All he did at PSU was have six 10+ win seasons and five top 10 finishes.

Lea may very well be a great coach, but so far he has one decent season and is in the middle of his first very good season.
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,462
3,097
113
What do you think about Chesney at JMU?
One word comes to mind: IMPRESSIVE.

He has won BIG at 4 different schools. He would win big here, too, I believe. If we have to say Sayonara to Beamer next year, he needs to be interviewed and seriously considered.

HE is the kind of coach we should have hired after the Muschamp gamble blew up in our faces. But, we decided to gamble AGAIN.

You must like him, too.
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,462
3,097
113
That is basically what I have observed since 1975. One way or another, the powers that be F it up. Why was Jim Carlen fired?

I like Beamer and want him to be successful and so far, he has done pretty well with that big boy conference and a schedule that Drinkwitz and Kiffin haven't had to face but it looks like his poor choices for OC and OL coaches as well as his stubbornness holding on to them will be his demise. I don't know a damn thing about coaching football, but I would have fired Teasley after his first season and Shula after the bowl game.

I agree with you on the hire not looking very good on paper, but you act as if we haven't even gone to a bowl under his leadership much less sniffed the playoffs last year.
Anyone who has read my past comments, knows I praised and credited Beamer for producing a number 23 and number 19 teams. (NOTE: not everyone is going to nor should remember a faceless internet poster). My beef with Beamer is that here we are in his 5th season and we are struggling to have just a winning season. What it looks like, thus far, what we are getting from Beamer is an Up and Down, Up and Down program rather than a consistent winner like Josh Heupel, Eli Drinkwitz and Lane Kiffin are producing.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
18,677
15,652
113
Anyone who has read my past comments, knows I praised and credited Beamer for producing a number 23 and number 19 teams. (NOTE: not everyone is going to nor should remember a faceless internet poster). My beef with Beamer is that here we are in his 5th season and we are struggling to have just a winning season. What it looks like, thus far, what we are getting from Beamer is an Up and Down, Up and Down program rather than a consistent winner like Josh Heupel, Eli Drinkwitz and Lane Kiffin are producing.

My biggest beef with this year, and I've been as "vocal" as I can be about on here (as if it matters what I say on here...it's cathartic) is that this season was 100% preventable. We are in this predicament b/c he retained a KNOWN major liability with Teasley and then made as uninspired of an OC hire as he could. If you upgrade our OL this season to even just mediocre, we are likely around 5-3 instead of 3-5. Throw in a better OC and we might be 6-2 or better. Of those, promoting Shula was the lesser evil as he was an unknown entity in that capacity. But the WHOLE world knew Teasley was awful. But we retained him AND gave him a huge raise.

That one decision resulted in a stillborn season.
 

Lurker123

All-Conference
May 4, 2020
5,598
4,642
113
On board with stock and 18 here.

It signals to me a coach that is still learning on the job. If I had one complaint about Shane, its that he should have spent a few years at a coordinator, or as a HC at a smaller school.

He needed to be involved with running a program before he was handed an SEC program.

It is frustrating to be finishing up year 5, a losing season, and hoping that the coach will learn and make the right decision this time.
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,462
3,097
113
My biggest beef with this year, and I've been as "vocal" as I can be about on here (as if it matters what I say on here...it's cathartic) is that this season was 100% preventable. We are in this predicament b/c he retained a KNOWN major liability with Teasley and then made as uninspired of an OC hire as he could. If you upgrade our OL this season to even just mediocre, we are likely around 5-3 instead of 3-5. Throw in a better OC and we might be 6-2 or better. Of those, promoting Shula was the lesser evil as he was an unknown entity in that capacity. But the WHOLE world knew Teasley was awful. But we retained him AND gave him a huge raise.

That one decision resulted in a stillborn season.
If we have to make a change next year, I am encouraged that we now have a professional AD who was hired on his merits rather than rewarded for winning 2 baseball national championships.
 

Legal_fowl

Junior
Apr 3, 2019
421
259
63
One word comes to mind: IMPRESSIVE.

He has won BIG at 4 different schools. He would win big here, too, I believe. If we have to say Sayonara to Beamer next year, he needs to be interviewed and seriously considered.

HE is the kind of coach we should have hired after the Muschamp gamble blew up in our faces. But, we decided to gamble AGAIN.

You must like him, too.
I only know what I have read and it is impressive.
 

Legal_fowl

Junior
Apr 3, 2019
421
259
63
My biggest beef with this year, and I've been as "vocal" as I can be about on here (as if it matters what I say on here...it's cathartic) is that this season was 100% preventable. We are in this predicament b/c he retained a KNOWN major liability with Teasley and then made as uninspired of an OC hire as he could. If you upgrade our OL this season to even just mediocre, we are likely around 5-3 instead of 3-5. Throw in a better OC and we might be 6-2 or better. Of those, promoting Shula was the lesser evil as he was an unknown entity in that capacity. But the WHOLE world knew Teasley was awful. But we retained him AND gave him a huge raise.

That one decision resulted in a stillborn season.
Remember after the first 2 games when we were saying the offense was inept against VT and SCSU? Where are the folks who said, just wait - we will get better and finish strong?
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
18,677
15,652
113
Remember after the first 2 games when we were saying the offense was inept against VT and SCSU? Where are the folks who said, just wait - we will get better and finish strong?

Some poster kept smacking me around for not believing even after we rebounded from our ODU debacle last year.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
18,677
15,652
113
How much of it was a true rebound as opposed to Sellers just doing some rather unexpected things?
Defenses definitely did not know what to do with him last year. I don’t know how much of his struggle this year you would call a sophomore slump…I know he’s not a sophomore, but it’s his second year as a starter…as opposed to defenses getting a better bead on him.
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,462
3,097
113
Here's a fact:

If we fire Beamer next season, there will be good, experienced, proven Head Coaches available. I do not know who they are. But if Jeremiah Donati's one time at bat in hiring a Head Football Coach is any indication, he will bring in such a good one. Sonny Dykes record at TCU since Donati hired him is 33-15.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

Go Gamecocks

All-Conference
Jan 19, 2021
1,257
1,091
113
Lea is winning right now b/c he has a QB who transferred there after playing a decade or so elsewhere and then sued b/c he wanted to keep playing into his retirement years.
Pavia might be the best QB @ Vandy since Jay Cutler.
 

Uscg1984

All-Conference
Mar 9, 2006
2,326
3,071
113
Defenses definitely did not know what to do with him last year. I don’t know how much of his struggle this year you would call a sophomore slump…I know he’s not a sophomore, but it’s his second year as a starter…as opposed to defenses getting a better bead on him.
I think it's more than just a sophomore slump (and, yes, he's a RS sophomore). Ever since the bowl game last year, it has seemed as if he is playing tentatively. Even when he breaks open a run this year, it seems like he is immediately looking to slide or go out of bounds rather than predatorily using his athletic gifts to gain more yards. Obviously, you don't want your starting QB to take the same hits that a RB takes, but it just seems like there's a tentativeness there this year that wasn't there prior to the bowl game last year. Maybe it's all on him and he's overthinking the game on his own, but he sure looks like a guy that's been "coached down."
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
24,609
2,144
113
I think it's more than just a sophomore slump (and, yes, he's a RS sophomore). Ever since the bowl game last year, it has seemed as if he is playing tentatively. Even when he breaks open a run this year, it seems like he is immediately looking to slide or go out of bounds rather than predatorily using his athletic gifts to gain more yards. Obviously, you don't want your starting QB to take the same hits that a RB takes, but it just seems like there's a tentativeness there this year that wasn't there prior to the bowl game last year. Maybe it's all on him and he's overthinking the game on his own, but he sure looks like a guy that's been "coached down."
It's a combination. The defenses know how to defend him better and he IS more tentative this season because he doesn't want to get injured (I can't say I blame him).
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
18,677
15,652
113
I think it's more than just a sophomore slump (and, yes, he's a RS sophomore). Ever since the bowl game last year, it has seemed as if he is playing tentatively. Even when he breaks open a run this year, it seems like he is immediately looking to slide or go out of bounds rather than predatorily using his athletic gifts to gain more yards. Obviously, you don't want your starting QB to take the same hits that a RB takes, but it just seems like there's a tentativeness there this year that wasn't there prior to the bowl game last year. Maybe it's all on him and he's overthinking the game on his own, but he sure looks like a guy that's been "coached down."
Yeah, I mean it's not only his second year.

It is like a flip switched between the Clemson game and the bowl game and it's never switched back. He's had a few flashes this year, but nothing consistent.
 

HWGcock

Joined Nov 2, 1998 • Garnet Trust Supporter
Nov 2, 1998
1,685
2,870
113
One word comes to mind: IMPRESSIVE.

He has won BIG at 4 different schools. He would win big here, too, I believe. If we have to say Sayonara to Beamer next year, he needs to be interviewed and seriously considered.

HE is the kind of coach we should have hired after the Muschamp gamble blew up in our faces. But, we decided to gamble AGAIN.

You must like him, too.
The national rumor is that is who we would pursue if Beamer went to Va Tech.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gamecock stock

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
18,677
15,652
113
The national rumor is that is who we would pursue if Beamer went to Va Tech.
The national rumor is that is who we would pursue if Beamer went to Va Tech.

I don't know if there are national rumors about who would pursue, but it seems like a promising future coach. Thing that would scare me off is what are the statistical odds that 2 consecutive head coaches from JMU would go on to be successful P4 coaches?

It would look like we're just trying to copycat IU and it probably wouldn't work.
 

HI Cock1

Joined Oct 14, 2012
Jan 22, 2022
2,120
2,659
113
My choice as replacement.....JIMMY ROGERS (Currently HC at Wash. State) Doing a great job at a school left out in the non-conf. wilderness.

He's proven, young and hungry.
I thought they were in the Pac-2.
 

Sandstorm

Senior
Feb 6, 2022
218
455
63
For those of you who think Beamer is leaving, would any of you be interested in buying a bridge?