An uncle who worked as a printer gave us baseball cards in sheets, cut them up individually, what would an untouched sheet of the early 60's Yankees be worth ?
“Given the sale price of the two Mantles alone, the sheet is expected to go for $500,000 to $1 million, but it’s impossible to know precisely since many of the cards haven’t been offered before and five of the 18 All-Stars haven’t even by graded at all by PSA,” explained Steven Bloedow, owner of
CollectAuctions.net.
The rest of the sheet, including 16 of 18 players who appeared in the 1962 All-Star Game. includes Don Drysdale, Stan Musial, Mays, Frank Robinson, Del Crandall and Dick Groat at the top. In the middle are Jim Davenport, Bill Mazeroski, Bill White, Camilo Pascual, Al Kaline and Mantle. The bottom row has Leon Wagner, Earl Battey, Tony Kubek, Brooks Robinson, Bobby Richardson and Norm Siebern.
No cards of Groat, Mazeroski, Davenport, White and Siebern have ever been graded by PSA.
While the set has always been referred to as having a “1961” date, it’s more likely that the cards were produced around 1963. The single-most compelling evidence is the crudely airbrushed St. Louis insignia on Dick Groat’s cap while he clearly is still wearing the garb of his beloved Pira
The 1960 MVP was traded to the Cardinals in the winter of 1962. All of the 18 players in the set were All-Stars at some point between 1959-62 when MLB tested the adage about “too much of a good thing” and held two All-Star games each summer during that span.
While ostensibly created to raise monies for the players’ laughably modest pension fund at the time, the dual ASG notion was mercifully put to rest after 1962, restoring the game to its previous stature; it might take a while, but the players’ pension fund would ultimately develop other revenue streams to notable success.
While the sheet is the star, there is plenty of other material headed to the auction, including a signed near set of 1952 Topps, dozens of unopened boxes, wax and cello packs, hundreds of Post Cereal baseball and football panels, Hartland statues, Kail football figures and other vintage and modern material.
The auction runs from March 17-April 3.
About Rich Mueller
Rich is the editor and founder of Sports Collectors Daily. A broadcaster and writer for over 40 years and a collector for even longer than that, he's usually typing something somewhere. Type him back at
[email protected].