Immaculate Conception 33, Byron 14, FINAL

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
203
189
31
Montini just lost 41-7

Byron dominated IC last year but when IC beats Byron they need to petition up?

Make it make sense.

It took Byron having 2 generational talents to beat ic. Odds of them having another concidine and Talbert at the same time are very low. I’m a ccl guy but I don’t think ic or montini have any business playing in 3a. IC is loaded with d1 players. They also beat a team in the 6a and 8a semifinals.

At the same time if Fenwick wins it again I don’t think they should have to move up to 7a. They just got lucky that their AD had 2 sons that were both great players.
 

STIX815

Sophomore
Oct 4, 2021
110
114
43
I don’t have much faith in R-B after they struggled against the 4th best ICE team.
IC should be able to put up 50+ on them
With respect to the ICE, RB clearly played their worst game of the year against manteno. Multiple fumbles, penalties, and the offense was literally one-dimensional. All that, and the game was never really in question.
 

Doctor_D

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2016
3,414
3,029
113
And you failed to mention that two years ago IC didn’t Mike the playoffs at 5-4. Rear before the lost in quarters to Laurence. Next year they’ll take a step beck. Year after that it’s start over
Going 5-4 in the CCL and missing out on the playoffs doesn’t really indicate much when it comes to 3A football though.
The 2023 year when Byron was setting state records for scoring and margin of victory, they still almost lost to a Montini team that barely got in and was a pretty run of the mill Bronco team by their standards.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Colin2299

Doctor_D

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2016
3,414
3,029
113
With respect to the ICE, RB clearly played their worst game of the year against manteno. Multiple fumbles, penalties, and the offense was literally one-dimensional. All that, and the game was never really in question.
I thought it was still in question well into the second half, but Manteno kept forcing throws that led to interceptions.
Manteno was pretty talented, and they even gave Wilmington a bit of resistance for about a half this year, but I just thought that R-B would have made much quicker work of them.
 

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
203
189
31
Going 5-4 in the CCL and missing out on the playoffs doesn’t really indicate much when it comes to 3A football though.
The 2023 year when Byron was setting state records for scoring and margin of victory, they still almost lost to a Montini team that barely got in and was a pretty run of the mill Bronco team by their standards.

they lost to st Laurence 24-20 in the 4a playoffs. St Laurence took 2nd in state that year. If anything it prove they should be in 4a. Also with the current expanded playoffs they 5-4 team would’ve won state in 3a.
 

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
203
189
31
And you failed to mention that two years ago IC didn’t Mike the playoffs at 5-4. Rear before the lost in quarters to Laurence. Next year they’ll take a step beck. Year after that it’s start over

they will roll through 3a next year. After that they will lose a lot but with Baldwin and Sallis they would still be the hands down favorite in 3a.
 

eaglepwr47

Freshman
Sep 19, 2026
84
97
18
IC is already multiplied up. They have 500 kids in the school and should have to play up against schools 3x their size because they beat the defending state champs by 20 a year after losing to them handily? Byron claims to have 2-4 D1 kids on their roster, by that logic they need to petition up too then.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Colin2299

Dave Brody

Junior
Apr 30, 2024
341
380
63
IC is already multiplied up. They have 500 kids in the school and should have to play up against schools 3x their size because they beat the defending state champs by 20 a year after losing to them handily? Byron claims to have 2-4 D1 kids on their roster, by that logic they need to petition up too then.

IC enrollment is 277 according to IHSA, and 457 with the multiplier
 

Doctor_D

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2016
3,414
3,029
113
IC is already multiplied up. They have 500 kids in the school and should have to play up against schools 3x their size because they beat the defending state champs by 20 a year after losing to them handily? Byron claims to have 2-4 D1 kids on their roster, by that logic they need to petition up too then.
I think there are quite a few people that believe there should be some sort of success factor for publics.

I do think IC playing up would be more interesting, but it’s not like what they are going to do to the 3A field is unprecedented. There are lots of seasons where there is a clear cut favorite in a class that pretty much rolls through the playoffs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Colin2299

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
203
189
31

IC enrollment is 277 according to IHSA, and 457 with the multiplier

please tell me what d1 kids Byron has. By that logic ic shouldn’t be playing 5a,6a,7a and 8a during the regular season and beating them.

I think there are quite a few people that believe there should be some sort of success factor for publics.

I do think IC playing up would be more interesting, but it’s not like what they are going to do to the 3A field is unprecedented. There are lots of seasons where there is a clear cut favorite in a class that pretty much rolls through the playoffs.

When Rochester had their run they should’ve been moved up.
 

Dave Brody

Junior
Apr 30, 2024
341
380
63
please tell me what d1 kids Byron has. By that logic ic shouldn’t be playing 5a,6a,7a and 8a during the regular season and beating them.



When Rochester had their run they should’ve been moved up.
IC is playing who is on their CCL divisional schedule. If they didn't have generational talent like Bowen (who looks to be the best player to come out of IC), they'd no doubt struggle in the regular season.

Add Le-Win to the lst.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eaglepwr47

eaglepwr47

Freshman
Sep 19, 2026
84
97
18
please tell me what d1 kids Byron has. By that logic ic shouldn’t be playing 5a,6a,7a and 8a during the regular season and beating them.



When Rochester had their run they should’ve been moved up.
Their own AD has posted offers or “visits” for Edmonson,Auker, Bonvallet to D1/FBS schools. Petition up to 4A!
 

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
203
189
31
Their own AD has posted offers or “visits” for Edmonson,Auker, Bonvallet to D1/FBS schools. Petition up to 4A!

Big difference between going on a visit and actually committing to an d1 school. Let’s see how many actually sign with a d1 school. at the end of the day IC will have more than double the d1 offers that Byron does.

also out of those 3 only edmonson has a d1 offer and it’s valpo.
 

RB_RocketFan

Freshman
Oct 15, 2023
68
89
18
Non-boundaried schools should be assigned the same class as the public district they reside in. They are pulling from the same pool of kids. In most cases a larger pool of kids than the public district. From there they can go up based on success. If non-boundaried thinks that’s too high a class they can petition down and let IHSA hear their case and decide. But you shouldn’t have non-boundaries playing in lower classes than the public district they are in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: K58W
Aug 20, 2026
587
299
63
Non-boundaried schools should be assigned the same class as the public district they reside in. They are pulling from the same pool of kids. In most cases a larger pool of kids than the public district. From there they can go up based on success. If non-boundaried thinks that’s too high a class they can petition down and let IHSA hear their case and decide. But you shouldn’t have non-boundaries playing in lower classes than the public district they are in.
Are you saying IC should be in class 8?
 

eaglepwr47

Freshman
Sep 19, 2026
84
97
18
I wholeheartedly disagree with 8A (which seems to be what he's suggesting). I think there's a case to be made anywhere from 3-6.
But that logic the following would also be true:

Sterling Newman -5A
Rockford Lutheran-7A
Aurora Christian-6/7A
Bishop Mac-6A


I don’t think we are far off with increasing multiplier to 2.5 and just keep the success factor. Unless you are going to somehow add a “potential D1 athlete” exam to these private schools admittance exams.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DirtySixThirty

Colin2299

Senior
Aug 13, 2025
825
583
93
It took Byron having 2 generational talents to beat ic. Odds of them having another concidine and Talbert at the same time are very low. I’m a ccl guy but I don’t think ic or montini have any business playing in 3a. IC is loaded with d1 players. They also beat a team in the 6a and 8a semifinals.

At the same time if Fenwick wins it again I don’t think they should have to move up to 7a. They just got lucky that their AD had 2 sons that were both great players.
Why do people always say “it took Byron 2 generational talents to beat IC/Montini”?

Byron beat Montini when Considerine was a sophomore and Talbert was a freshman.

Talbert is a great baseball talent. While a good football player - wouldn’t say he’s generational.

It’s not basketball. To be as dominate as they’ve been it’s more than (2) players.

COULD SAY THE SAME THING ABOUT MONTINI AND IC - TOOK THEM HAVING GENERATIONAL TALENT TO BEAT BYRON.
 

Colin2299

Senior
Aug 13, 2025
825
583
93
Non-boundaried schools should be assigned the same class as the public district they reside in. They are pulling from the same pool of kids. In most cases a larger pool of kids than the public district. From there they can go up based on success. If non-boundaried thinks that’s too high a class they can petition down and let IHSA hear their case and decide. But you shouldn’t have non-boundaries playing in lower classes than the public district they are in.
When they start getting the same tax dollars as the in district public school I’ll agree with you.

Such a wild view on privates.
 

eagles2k3!

Junior
Aug 29, 2025
291
231
43
Why do people always say “it took Byron 2 generational talents to beat IC/Montini”?

Byron beat Montini when Considerine was a sophomore and Talbert was a freshman.

Talbert is a great baseball talent. While a good football player - wouldn’t say he’s generational.

It’s not basketball. To be as dominate as they’ve been it’s more than (2) players.

COULD SAY THE SAME THING ABOUT MONTINI AND IC - TOOK THEM HAVING GENERATIONAL TALENT TO BEAT BYRON.
This is such a stupid take. Byron had maybe their best teams ever the last few years and Byron barely beat Montini in 2023 when Montini had a bad team. They lost to Viator that year! That was before Izzy hit the transfer portal. The next year Byron lost 14-13. What does it say about Montini when they can’t beat a 3a school with the players they have? I know Bu was on the hot seat and barely squeaked into the playoffs in 2023 and were in 3a. If they don’t get Abrams in the transfer portal I wonder if he’s still there.

im not a private school hater at all. Theres a definite advantage to recruiting no doubt about it. But to say that you could say the same thing about IC and Montini is just downright ridiculous. Especially with the amount of championships IC and Montini have won over the years.
 
Last edited:

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
203
189
31
This is such a stupid take. Byron had maybe their best teams ever the last few years and Byron barely beat Montini in 2023 when Montini had a bad team. They lost to Viator that year! That was before Izzy hit the transfer portal. The next year Byron lost 14-13. What does it say about Montini when they can’t beat a 3a school with the players they have? I know Bu was on the hot seat and barely squeaked into the playoffs in 2023 and were in 3a. If they don’t get Abrams in the transfer portal I wonder if he’s still there.

im not a private school hater at all. Theres a definite advantage to recruiting no doubt about it. But to say that you could say the same thing about IC and Montini is just downright ridiculous. Especially with the amount of championships IC and Montini have won over the years.

ic could easily have 10 kids from this years team play d1 football. Byron will be lucky to have 1 kid. I’m a private school guy I just don’t get how anyone thinks a ccl school should be playing in 3a.
 

Colin2299

Senior
Aug 13, 2025
825
583
93
This is such a stupid take. Byron had maybe their best teams ever the last few years and Byron barely beat Montini in 2023 when Montini had a bad team. They lost to Viator that year! That was before Izzy hit the transfer portal. The next year Byron lost 14-13. What does it say about Montini when they can’t beat a 3a school with the players they have? I know Bu was on the hot seat and barely squeaked into the playoffs in 2023 and were in 3a. If they don’t get Abrams in the transfer portal I wonder if he’s still there.

im not a private school hater at all. Theres a definite advantage to recruiting no doubt about it. But to say that you could say the same thing about IC and Montini is just downright ridiculous. Especially with the amount of championships IC and Montini have won over the years.
That the 3A school was pretty darn good.

It’s ok to say a 3A public school is as good as Montini, IC, etc.

So what does it say about Montini, in Abraham’s SR year, getting boat raced to a 4A public school?
 

CCL65

Junior
Oct 28, 2015
726
367
51
That the 3A school was pretty darn good.

It’s ok to say a 3A public school is as good as Montini, IC, etc.

So what does it say about Montini, in Abraham’s SR year, getting boat raced to a 4A public school?
I’ll go out on a limb and say Moriris was a way better all around team
 

CCL65

Junior
Oct 28, 2015
726
367
51
they lost to st Laurence 24-20 in the 4a playoffs. St Laurence took 2nd in state that year. If anything it prove they should be in 4a. Also with the current expanded playoffs they 5-4 team would’ve won state in 3a.
They lost to Laurence in 4A because they had 365 students that put them in 4A. Now they have 277. Their 5-4 tram was not very good. Byron would have rolled them. Last years team was the third best team in 3A by a long shot. Byron beat them handily and TU scored 50 on Byron. Are you saying last years IC team should have been 4A? Why
 
Aug 20, 2026
587
299
63
Non-boundaried schools should be assigned the same class as the public district they reside in. They are pulling from the same pool of kids. In most cases a larger pool of kids than the public district. From there they can go up based on success. If non-boundaried thinks that’s too high a class they can petition down and let IHSA hear their case and decide. But you shouldn’t have non-boundaries playing in lower classes than the public district they are in.
Those kids' parents also have to pay money beyond their tax bill for their kids to attend private schools. Both have their pros and cons. It's out-of-touch to think five-figure annual tuition isn't keeping some families out who would like to go private.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eaglepwr47

K58W

Redshirt
Nov 25, 2025
55
30
18
If you look at the history of the 3A championship when a CCL team is part of it it’s never been a good game.

I think the biggest trophy is IC’s schedule with only the loss to Loyola.

Walking to pick up the 3A hardware is a step back from what they accomplished in regular season imop.

Ditch the multiplier and do districts with CCL included and let everyone see what the outcome would be.
 

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
203
189
31
Those kids' parents also have to pay money beyond their tax bill for their kids to attend private schools. Both have their pros and cons. It's out-of-touch to think five-figure annual tuition isn't keeping some families out who would like to go private.

The average tuition is probably 16k now. It’s naive to think private schools can just get anyone and they’re playing for free. Even with financial aid most people are paying a lot. Not to mention how expensive property taxes have gotten. I live in DuPage and I’m paying a ton in property tax
 
  • Like
Reactions: DirtySixThirty

Connorstallions

Sophomore
Oct 25, 2023
203
189
31
If you look at the history of the 3A championship when a CCL team is part of it it’s never been a good game.

I think the biggest trophy is IC’s schedule with only the loss to Loyola.

Walking to pick up the 3A hardware is a step back from what they accomplished in regular season imop.

Ditch the multiplier and do districts with CCL included and let everyone see what the outcome would be.

I think the multiplier will increase to 2.0 and then that’ll solve some of the issues.

personally I would think if Montini kept saying they were the best team in state that you would petition up. If you are worried about being thought of as the best team in state why are you playing in the 4a playoffs
 
  • Like
Reactions: K58W

K58W

Redshirt
Nov 25, 2025
55
30
18
I think the multiplier will increase to 2.0 and then that’ll solve some of the issues.

personally I would think if Montini kept saying they were the best team in state that you would petition up. If you are worried about being thought of as the best team in state why are you playing in the 4a playoffs
Montini wouldn’t have even been able to hang with IC this year.

Bukovsky must of got caught slacking on his coaching…
 

Doctor_D

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2016
3,414
3,029
113
personally I would think if Montini kept saying they were the best team in state that you would petition up. If you are worried about being thought of as the best team in state why are you playing in the 4a playoffs
I 100% agree with this sentiment. If you wanna be thought of as the best overall, then you can’t be slumming down in 3A or 4A.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Connorstallions
Edgy Tim

Latest

  1. 01 Edgy Tim Football 8A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  2. 02 Edgy Tim Football 7A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  3. 03 Edgy Tim Football 6A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  4. 04 Edgy Tim 5A: Semifinalist Player of the Year
  5. 05 Edgy Tim Football 4A: Semifinalist Player of the Year