I work for a oil field services company and we do millions of bucks with BP each year. I've personally worked on engineering projects that have been deployed on BPs Thunderhorse development.
For those that are interested to know, BP had 2 barriers downhole to prevent (redundancy is prevalent in the oil field) that both failed. My company actually quoted for those pieces of a equipment and we were not awarded the work due to pricing issues (we were too high). So these cement retainers that you guys might've heard of... both of them failed. Another thing not mentioned prevalently is that a seal assembly on a running tool that was supposed to be left down hole to provide a third barrier was inadvertantly pulled out of the hole, because of tool failure (3 times now).
Also, every offshore rig has SCSSV (surface controlled subsurface safety valves). These valves are controlled from surface and are rated up to 25,000 PSI in some instances. If you find a well that is producing at 10,000 PSI, you'll be making tons of a money. Anyways, these valves are used in emergency situations, such as this one. Unfortunately, when you have a major explosion at the wellhead, the control lines used to function the valves are no longer functioning. Now you've basically got a live well, producing from high pressure (downhole in the reservior) to low pressure (gulf of mexico).
Currently, there isn't technology out there that can really shut off a well such as this. This catastrophe is 100% unheard of in the oil field and planning for it would cost billions upon billions of dollars. If all the Gulf of Mexico oil producers were to invest, research, and implement such safety mechanisms, the end user (everyone that uses oil/gasoline as a product) would experience astronomical price increases at the pump and everywhere else (because most goods have to be delivered by a gasoline/diesel powered vehicle).
I saw that this was a hot topic and thought I'd share some information with you guys. Please note that I'm not taking a stance either way, because what's going on in the gulf right now is atrocious. I really hope we never have to see another accident like this again.
That is all. <div>
</div><div>Edited for horrible grammar.</div>
For those that are interested to know, BP had 2 barriers downhole to prevent (redundancy is prevalent in the oil field) that both failed. My company actually quoted for those pieces of a equipment and we were not awarded the work due to pricing issues (we were too high). So these cement retainers that you guys might've heard of... both of them failed. Another thing not mentioned prevalently is that a seal assembly on a running tool that was supposed to be left down hole to provide a third barrier was inadvertantly pulled out of the hole, because of tool failure (3 times now).
Also, every offshore rig has SCSSV (surface controlled subsurface safety valves). These valves are controlled from surface and are rated up to 25,000 PSI in some instances. If you find a well that is producing at 10,000 PSI, you'll be making tons of a money. Anyways, these valves are used in emergency situations, such as this one. Unfortunately, when you have a major explosion at the wellhead, the control lines used to function the valves are no longer functioning. Now you've basically got a live well, producing from high pressure (downhole in the reservior) to low pressure (gulf of mexico).
Currently, there isn't technology out there that can really shut off a well such as this. This catastrophe is 100% unheard of in the oil field and planning for it would cost billions upon billions of dollars. If all the Gulf of Mexico oil producers were to invest, research, and implement such safety mechanisms, the end user (everyone that uses oil/gasoline as a product) would experience astronomical price increases at the pump and everywhere else (because most goods have to be delivered by a gasoline/diesel powered vehicle).
I saw that this was a hot topic and thought I'd share some information with you guys. Please note that I'm not taking a stance either way, because what's going on in the gulf right now is atrocious. I really hope we never have to see another accident like this again.
That is all. <div>
</div><div>Edited for horrible grammar.</div>