Jai Lucas

USARMYWILDCAT

All-Conference
Jan 11, 2016
600
1,332
93
I’m no saying Jai is the answer to our problems. Or he should definitely be our next coach. I will say after watching the second half of the Miami/North Alabama game last night. Anyone saying that he shouldn’t be on the shortlist needs to watch one of Miami’s games. I know this is a small sample size and you can’t make a judgment after just watching 1/2 of game. It’s just a few small things that I noticed about Jai’s coaching.

1. They beat an inferior opponent like they should have. They made North Alabama look like they shouldn’t even be on the floor. (They probably would’ve beaten Northern Arizona by 50 tonight).

2. Miami played extremely hard on offense and defense. Every player looked in sync and knew exactly what they were supposed to be doing at all times.

3. Miami played with effort at all times. Even when they were up by 40+ points. Jai was still coaching them and expecting effort no matter what the score was. He was still digging in there a$$ and not accepting mediocrity at any point.

4. Jai seems to be kind of a hard a$$. Even when being coached hard, you could tell his players really respected him and wanted to play hard for him.

This is just a few observations that I had watching that game. I’m not saying he should be at the top of the list for our next coach. I will be watching more of Miami games. We’ll see if they can make some kind of run in the ACC and the NCAA tournament this year.
 

USARMYWILDCAT

All-Conference
Jan 11, 2016
600
1,332
93
If we hire him, he's another buyout waiting to happen. Mediocre to above average at best.

That's way better than what we have, but he cant be a top target or this program is just cooked.
You know this how? He’s an elite recruiter we know that. What if he goes on a deep run in March this year and makes it to a final four? That would make his résumé just as good as Nate Oates. Everyone on this board seems to love and want Nate Oates.

My point is it’s too early to say. You could be right or he could be the next Rick Pitino we don’t know yet. I don’t think we can say either way we don’t have enough data. In my opinion, he’s definitely one to watch.
 

USARMYWILDCAT

All-Conference
Jan 11, 2016
600
1,332
93
Good grief, please STOP with this Jai Lucas nonsense. The kid has accomplished less than BCG. He is not ready at all to coach Kentucky Basketball.

HE. IS. NOT. READY.
How did you feel about Todd Golden three years ago? Wouldn’t you have loved for us to have hired him three years ago? I’m not saying Jai is the man for the job right now. I’m also not going to make a blanket statement and say absolutely not he shouldn’t be our coach. We don’t know yet, he very well could be the next Rick Pitino.
 
Jul 6, 2025
2,991
7,959
113
You know this how? He’s an elite recruiter we know that. What if he goes on a deep run in March this year and makes it to a final four? That would make his résumé just as good as Nate Oates. Everyone on this board seems to love and want Nate Oates.

My point is it’s too early to say. You could be right or he could be the next Rick Pitino we don’t know yet. I don’t think we can say either way we don’t have enough data. In my opinion, he’s definitely one to watch.

Even giving you the most benefit of the doubt possible, the best argument you made was its too early to say. Not the endorsement of someone who should be top of the list for UK.
 

USARMYWILDCAT

All-Conference
Jan 11, 2016
600
1,332
93
Even giving you the most benefit of the doubt possible, the best argument you made was its too early to say. Not the endorsement of someone who should be top of the list for UK.
Again how did you feel about Todd Golden three years ago? He was in the same position that Jai is in now. He was the young, up-and-coming, unproven coach. Me nor anyone else is saying that Jai should definitely be our next coach. Anyone saying that they know for a fact that Jai is not the answer. Probably said the same thing about Golden three years ago. Boy wouldn’t I love to have Todd Golden right now as our head coach.
 

CrimsonCats_rivals

All-Conference
Mar 22, 2022
1,816
3,759
61
Good grief, please STOP with this Jai Lucas nonsense. The kid has accomplished less than BCG. He is not ready at all to coach Kentucky Basketball.

HE. IS. NOT. READY.
I’m not necessarily saying that Lucas is the right guy, but we’re going to have to get comfortable looking forward instead of backwards in my opinion because we’re no longer living in the world where our history means that only the already acknowledged best coaches in the sport are our candidates.

A lot of our fans tried to act like Pope’s hiring was just because Barnhart was an exceptionally bad AD and not because blue blood status no longer means much, but then we just watched UNC go through the process of getting rejected by every established college coach they approached and settle for an out of work NBA guy who was hanging around campus to watch his daughter play volleyball. Whenever Pope is out (which needs to be at the end of this season), we’ll have to try and find the next great coach before he’s already proven it. Lucas may not be my first pick, but he’s somewhere on the list of guys who have that potential.
 

Sportspm

All-Conference
Jul 26, 2009
889
1,740
57
Agreed, Dusty would be my first call.

Just going to play Devil’s advocate here. What has Schwartz or Odom done that Jai hasn’t? At least we know Jai can recruit at a high-level.
Fair enough, everyone has different opinions, Schertz and Odom have more experience. Va was 30-6 last year, undefeated so far this year, including blowing out Arkansas. Schertz had the highest winning percentage in all of basketball at any level at one time, now after rebuilding Indiana St, then St. Louis, He’s still 3rd behind Few at Gonzaga and Bill Self is second.
He wins every where he goes, has a philosophy that reminds me of Rupp for some reason. But I can see people’s argument that he’s not done it on a high enough level yet. Can he recruit? Well money is the top recruiter these days and UK has a lot more to spend than St. Louis (I think)
 

USARMYWILDCAT

All-Conference
Jan 11, 2016
600
1,332
93
I’m not necessarily saying that Lucas is the right guy, but we’re going to have to get comfortable looking forward instead of backwards in my opinion because we’re no longer living in the world where our history means that only the already acknowledged best coaches in the sport are our candidates.

A lot of our fans tried to act like Pope’s hiring was just because Barnhart was an exceptionally bad AD and not because blue blood status no longer means much, but then we just watched UNC go through the process of getting rejected by every established college coach they approached and settle for an out of work NBA guy who was hanging around campus to watch his daughter play volleyball. Whenever Pope is out (which needs to be at the end of this season), we’ll have to try and find the next great coach before he’s already proven it. Lucas may not be my first pick, but he’s somewhere on the list of guys who have that potential.
This is spot on. A large percentage of this fan base needs to understand the logo means nothing anymore. To be honest with you if a guy like Jai makes it deep run in the tournament this year. Why would he want to come to Kentucky when he can do what he wants to do at Miami. Who would’ve ever thought Kentucky football would be able to compete in the SEC. With NIL and the right coach, anyone can do it now. Like it or not Kentucky’s next basketball coach is probably going to be a young up-and-coming coach. There is no John Calipari out there to come save us this time.
 

Dr.LutherSan

All-American
Sep 6, 2019
4,588
9,217
113
I worry about his allegiances. Seems to have a little Liam Coen in him where if he sniffs out a better situation, hes gone.
The "allegiances" thing shouldn't be something to be worried about. If he finds a better situation, then that means he's extremely successful. If given the tools at his disposal at UK, he would create the "better situation."

I'm sure your concern probably comes from him leaving UK for Duke. There were several factors in that:
-Everyone on Calipari’s staff were older buddy hires, with the exception being Joel Justus. Jai saw how stubborn Calipari was and didn't want to just be another "yes man".
-Jon Scheyer isn't as stubborn as Calipari and the coaching staff was much younger and willing to adjust to change. If we're honest, Duke is/was a better program currently.
 

JustBlue

Senior
Mar 29, 2009
374
865
93
How did you feel about Todd Golden three years ago? Wouldn’t you have loved for us to have hired him three years ago? I’m not saying Jai is the man for the job right now. I’m also not going to make a blanket statement and say absolutely not he shouldn’t be our coach. We don’t know yet, he very well could be the next Rick Pitino.

He could very well be the next Rick Pitino bit he could also be the next Josh Pastner. He has exactly ONE year of head coaching experience so nobody knows. Here is a breakdown of his P5 victories in his 1st year at Miami (I am not going to list the mid-majors they played. They scheduled nine and won nine.)

The won 26 games overall. Against Power 5 competition they went 17-9.

Here are the 17 teams they defeated with that teams conference finish in parentheses.

Georgetown (9th out of 11)
Ole Miss (15th out of 16)
Pitt (15th out of 18)
Wake Forest (13th out of 18)
GA Tech (18th out of 18)
Notre Dame (16th out of 18)
Syracuse (14th out of 18)
Stanford (10th out of 18)
Boston College (17th out of 18)
UNC (4th out of 18)
NC State (7th out of 18)
VA Tech (12th out of 18)
FSU (8th out of 18)
Boston College (17th out of 18)
SMU (11th out of 18)
Louisville (6th out of 18)
Missouri (8th out of 16)

Out of those 17 wins he beat four NCAA tournament teams - SMU, UNC (regular season) Louisville (ACC tournament) and Missouri (NCAA first round).

None of those teams made it to the 2nd weekend and only Louisville won a game.

I guess UNC could be his signature win and they fired their coach immediately after the season.

So could he be the next big thing? There's always a chance but he has not accomplished near enough to be seriously considered for head coach at UK.
 
Last edited:

LineSkiCat14

Heisman
Aug 5, 2015
39,933
63,120
113
Yeahy that's kind of what was in the back of my head. I get him not wanting to be apart of the Cal regime, especially when the ship was sinking, totally get that. I also think Scheyer is Duke's weak link right now, and I think he's a coaching seat we should start keeping an eye on. I personally don't think he's doing nearly as well as he should be considering what he's being given. So if we land Jai next year, and Scheyer gets the boot a year or two after.. I could see Jai maybe going there. Because lets face it, the Duke job is a better landing spot than Kentucky, it just is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dr.LutherSan

Wildcatmenace

All-Conference
Oct 29, 2025
1,316
1,938
113
Good grief, please STOP with this Jai Lucas nonsense. The kid has accomplished less than BCG. He is not ready at all to coach Kentucky Basketball.

HE. IS. NOT. READY.
Oats in our only call. If I had to make two other calls, I’d think about Bryan Hodgson and Ryan Odom, that’s it. Those three are the only qualifying candidates in my mind.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JustBlue

BookofMormon

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2026
1,430
1,886
113
I’m no saying Jai is the answer to our problems. Or he should definitely be our next coach. I will say after watching the second half of the Miami/North Alabama game last night. Anyone saying that he shouldn’t be on the shortlist needs to watch one of Miami’s games. I know this is a small sample size and you can’t make a judgment after just watching 1/2 of game. It’s just a few small things that I noticed about Jai’s coaching.

1. They beat an inferior opponent like they should have. They made North Alabama look like they shouldn’t even be on the floor. (They probably would’ve beaten Northern Arizona by 50 tonight).

2. Miami played extremely hard on offense and defense. Every player looked in sync and knew exactly what they were supposed to be doing at all times.

3. Miami played with effort at all times. Even when they were up by 40+ points. Jai was still coaching them and expecting effort no matter what the score was. He was still digging in there a$$ and not accepting mediocrity at any point.

4. Jai seems to be kind of a hard a$$. Even when being coached hard, you could tell his players really respected him and wanted to play hard for him.

This is just a few observations that I had watching that game. I’m not saying he should be at the top of the list for our next coach. I will be watching more of Miami games. We’ll see if they can make some kind of run in the ACC and the NCAA tournament this year.
What exactly do you love so much about Jai Lucas?

Did you watch them against Florida? It was a bunch of non shooters running to the rim wildly all game. Terrible offensive flow.

What about his track record gives you so much confidence exactly? He has one tournament win as a 7 seed his whole career. You think he's great because he was able to beat North Alabama? lol.

I don't understand why everyone is so enamored with this guy. It's not like he learned under a great. He learned under John Scheyer.
 

Get_over_it

Senior
Sep 23, 2026
346
544
63
Again how did you feel about Todd Golden three years ago? He was in the same position that Jai is in now. He was the young, up-and-coming, unproven coach. Me nor anyone else is saying that Jai should definitely be our next coach. Anyone saying that they know for a fact that Jai is not the answer. Probably said the same thing about Golden three years ago. Boy wouldn’t I love to have Todd Golden right now as our head coach.
Young / Rising Mid-Major Coaches Who Struggled After Moving Up
1. Archie Miller (Dayton → Indiana)

  • The Rise: Took Dayton to four straight NCAA Tournaments, including an Elite Eight run in 2014, before turning 40.
  • The Fall: Hired at Indiana in 2017 to restore a blue blood, he went 67–58 overall (33–43 in Big Ten play) and never made a single NCAA Tournament before getting fired after four seasons.
2. Shaka Smart (VCU → Texas)
  • The Rise: Became the ultimate young coaching prodigy after taking VCU to the Final Four at age 33 and making five straight tournaments with his "Havoc" press.
  • The Fall: Couldn't replicate the magic in Austin. Over six seasons at Texas, he went 109–86 and failed to win a single NCAA Tournament game before leaving to reboot his career at Marquette.
3. Chris Mooney / Kevin Keatts / Mike White (Florida) — Best example: Mike White (Louisiana Tech → Florida)
  • The Rise: Went 101–40 at Louisiana Tech with three straight regular-season conference titles, making him one of the hottest young names on the carousel at 38.
  • The Fall: Took over for Billy Donovan at Florida in 2015. While he made a few tournaments early, the program steadily stagnated, missing the Big Dance in his final season before he bolted for Georgia ahead of a likely firing.
4. Mark Fox (Nevada → Georgia)
  • The Rise: Racked up a 123–43 record with three straight WAC titles and NCAA Tournament appearances at Nevada in his late 30s.
  • The Fall: Spent nine largely mediocre seasons at Georgia (163–133), making just two NCAA Tournaments and never winning a tourney game before being let go.
5. Richard Pitino (FIU → Minnesota)
  • The Rise: Landed the Minnesota job at just 30 years old after a promising debut season turning around FIU.
  • The Fall: Struggled to find consistency in the Big Ten over eight seasons (141–123 overall, 54–96 in conference), making only two NCAA Tournaments before being dismissed.
6. Josh Pastner (Memphis → Georgia Tech))
  • The Rise: Took over Memphis at 31 and rattled off four straight NCAA Tournament appearances and 100+ wins right out of the gate.
  • The Fall: Left for Georgia Tech in 2016 and went 109–114 over seven seasons, making just one NCAA Tournament (and losing in the first round) before getting fired.
7. Kyle Smith / Niko Medved / Or Mike Boynton (Oklahoma State)
  • The Rise: Promoted to head coach at OSU at just 35 years old as a rising star recruiter.
  • The Fall: Despite landing Cade Cunningham, he went 119–109 over seven seasons with just one NCAA Tournament appearance before being let go in 2024.
8. Travis Steele (Xavier)
  • The Rise: Longtime top assistant promoted at 36 to keep Xavier's Big East momentum rolling.
  • The Fall: Went 70–50 over four seasons and missed the NCAA Tournament every single year—the first Xavier coach to miss four straight since the early 1980s—before being fired in 2022.
9. Patrick Ewing / Chris Mullin / Or Bryce Drew (Valparaiso → Vanderbilt)
  • The Rise: Won four Horizon League titles in five years at his alma mater, making him one of the hottest young mid-major coaches in the country at 41.
  • The Fall: Hired at Vanderbilt in 2016, he went 40–59 overall and completely bottomed out in Year 3—going 0–18 in SEC play—before getting fired.
I like your one example of Todd (the pervert) Golden, but what about the up and comers that failed?

 

Reggie Noble

Senior
Jul 5, 2025
287
461
63
He could very well be the next Rick Pitino bit he could also be the next Josh Pastner. He has exactly ONE year of head coaching experience so nobody knows. Here is a breakdown of his P5 victories in his 1st year at Miami (I am not going to list the mid-majors they played. They scheduled nine and won nine.)

The won 26 games overall. Against Power 5 competition they went 17-9.

Here are the 17 teams they defeated with that teams conference finish in parentheses.

Georgetown (9th out of 11)
Ole Miss (15th out of 16)
Pitt (15th out of 18)
Wake Forest (13th out of 18)
GA Tech (18th out of 18)
Notre Dame (16th out of 18)
Syracuse (14th out of 18)
Stanford (10th out of 18)
Boston College (17th out of 18)
UNC (4th out of 18)
NC State (7th out of 18)
VA Tech (12th out of 18)
FSU (8th out of 18)
Boston College (17th out of 18)
SMU (11th out of 18)
Louisville (6th out of 18)
Missouri (8th out of 16)

Out of those 17 wins he beat four NCAA tournament teams - SMU, UNC (regular season) Louisville (ACC tournament) and Missouri (NCAA first round).

None of those teams made it to the 2nd weekend and only Louisville won a game.

I guess UNC could be his signature win and they fired their coach immediately after the season.

So could he be the next big thing? There's always a chance but he has not accomplished near enough to be seriously considered for head coach at UK.
Miami was 7-24 and 18th in the ACC the year before he took over.
In his first year (last year) they were 26-9 and 3rd in the league and 24th in the final poll.
 

PushupMan

All-American
May 29, 2001
169,782
9,781
93
What exactly do you love so much about Jai Lucas?

Did you watch them against Florida? It was a bunch of non shooters running to the rim wildly all game. Terrible offensive flow.

What about his track record gives you so much confidence exactly? He has one tournament win as a 7 seed his whole career. You think he's great because he was able to beat North Alabama? lol.

I don't understand why everyone is so enamored with this guy. It's not like he learned under a great. He learned under John Scheyer.

Scheyer is an influence, as is Calipari. He probably also learned coaching under his big brother John.

Might be more difficult to get him than what people think, with the way Miami spends in the NIL market. He’s got a very nice set up with modest expectations at Miami.

I also tend to agree with the sentiment that he hasn’t proved much yet. Need to see if he can do as well or better than he did last year again this time.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Feral Manatee

JustBlue

Senior
Mar 29, 2009
374
865
93
Miami was 7-24 and 18th in the ACC the year before he took over.
In his first year (last year) they were 26-9 and 3rd in the league and 24th in the final poll.

Did you watch any ACC basketball last year? That conference was terrible on the bottom half and that is what Lucas feasted on. And Jim Larranaga quit in the middle of the previous year and they turned it over to Bill Courtney to finish out the season Anybody could have done better than he did. Let Lucas beat the top teams consistently and make some deep runs in the tournament and then maybe give him a look but he has nothing to even be on our short list at this time. Just not enough of a sample size.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wildcatmenace

Reggie Noble

Senior
Jul 5, 2025
287
461
63
Did you watch any ACC basketball last year? That conference was terrible on the bottom half and that is what Lucas feasted on. And Jim Larranaga quit in the middle of the previous year and they turned it over to Bill Courtney to finish out the season Anybody could have done better than he did. Let Lucas beat the top teams consistently and make some deep runs in the tournament and then maybe give him a look but he has nothing to even be on our short list at this time. Just not enough of a sample size.
Which coach that can be had fits that criteria in today’s climate? This isn’t 10 years or more ago.
 

USARMYWILDCAT

All-Conference
Jan 11, 2016
600
1,332
93
Fair enough, everyone has different opinions, Schertz and Odom have more experience. Va was 30-6 last year, undefeated so far this year, including blowing out Arkansas. Schertz had the highest winning percentage in all of basketball at any level at one time, now after rebuilding Indiana St, then St. Louis, He’s still 3rd behind Few at Gonzaga and Bill Self is second.
He wins every where he goes, has a philosophy that reminds me of Rupp for some reason. But I can see people’s argument that he’s not done it on a high enough level yet. Can he recruit? Well money is the top recruiter these days and UK has a lot more to spend than St. Louis (I think)
You still have to be able to recruit money is not the complete answer. See Mark Pope.
Young / Rising Mid-Major Coaches Who Struggled After Moving Up
1. Archie Miller (Dayton → Indiana)

  • The Rise: Took Dayton to four straight NCAA Tournaments, including an Elite Eight run in 2014, before turning 40.
  • The Fall: Hired at Indiana in 2017 to restore a blue blood, he went 67–58 overall (33–43 in Big Ten play) and never made a single NCAA Tournament before getting fired after four seasons.
2. Shaka Smart (VCU → Texas)
  • The Rise: Became the ultimate young coaching prodigy after taking VCU to the Final Four at age 33 and making five straight tournaments with his "Havoc" press.
  • The Fall: Couldn't replicate the magic in Austin. Over six seasons at Texas, he went 109–86 and failed to win a single NCAA Tournament game before leaving to reboot his career at Marquette.
3. Chris Mooney / Kevin Keatts / Mike White (Florida) — Best example: Mike White (Louisiana Tech → Florida)
  • The Rise: Went 101–40 at Louisiana Tech with three straight regular-season conference titles, making him one of the hottest young names on the carousel at 38.
  • The Fall: Took over for Billy Donovan at Florida in 2015. While he made a few tournaments early, the program steadily stagnated, missing the Big Dance in his final season before he bolted for Georgia ahead of a likely firing.
4. Mark Fox (Nevada → Georgia)
  • The Rise: Racked up a 123–43 record with three straight WAC titles and NCAA Tournament appearances at Nevada in his late 30s.
  • The Fall: Spent nine largely mediocre seasons at Georgia (163–133), making just two NCAA Tournaments and never winning a tourney game before being let go.
5. Richard Pitino (FIU → Minnesota)
  • The Rise: Landed the Minnesota job at just 30 years old after a promising debut season turning around FIU.
  • The Fall: Struggled to find consistency in the Big Ten over eight seasons (141–123 overall, 54–96 in conference), making only two NCAA Tournaments before being dismissed.
6. Josh Pastner (Memphis → Georgia Tech))
  • The Rise: Took over Memphis at 31 and rattled off four straight NCAA Tournament appearances and 100+ wins right out of the gate.
  • The Fall: Left for Georgia Tech in 2016 and went 109–114 over seven seasons, making just one NCAA Tournament (and losing in the first round) before getting fired.
7. Kyle Smith / Niko Medved / Or Mike Boynton (Oklahoma State)
  • The Rise: Promoted to head coach at OSU at just 35 years old as a rising star recruiter.
  • The Fall: Despite landing Cade Cunningham, he went 119–109 over seven seasons with just one NCAA Tournament appearance before being let go in 2024.
8. Travis Steele (Xavier)
  • The Rise: Longtime top assistant promoted at 36 to keep Xavier's Big East momentum rolling.
  • The Fall: Went 70–50 over four seasons and missed the NCAA Tournament every single year—the first Xavier coach to miss four straight since the early 1980s—before being fired in 2022.
9. Patrick Ewing / Chris Mullin / Or Bryce Drew (Valparaiso → Vanderbilt)
  • The Rise: Won four Horizon League titles in five years at his alma mater, making him one of the hottest young mid-major coaches in the country at 41.
  • The Fall: Hired at Vanderbilt in 2016, he went 40–59 overall and completely bottomed out in Year 3—going 0–18 in SEC play—before getting fired.
I like your one example of Todd (the pervert) Golden, but what about the up and comers that failed?

Miami is not a mid major school. They are in the ACC. Also, none of those coaches you mentioned had proven to be elite recruiters yet. Jai has already proven to be an elite recruiter.
 

JustBlue

Senior
Mar 29, 2009
374
865
93
Which coach that can be had fits that criteria in today’s climate? This isn’t 10 years or more ago.

Pearl. Oats. Lloyd. I'm not on the Donovan train AT ALL but he'd make a splash.

Just try some coaches. Do a real search. Don't just interview two candidates and say "screw it, Mark played here so he'll do it." Kentucky hasn't lost the history. Just the shine. People think that every coach just sits around and goes "I got it made here why change" but lots of these coaches have huge egos. They know what UK can be. Just go out and look a bit.
 

Dr.LutherSan

All-American
Sep 6, 2019
4,588
9,217
113
Scheyer is an influence, as is Calipari. He probably also learned coaching under his big brother John.

Might be more difficult to get him than what people might think, with the way Miami spends in the NIL market. He’s got a very nice set up with modest expectations at Miami.
Jai's father was the coach.
 

BBNinSCar

All-Conference
Apr 23, 2013
1,878
3,537
81
How did you feel about Todd Golden three years ago? Wouldn’t you have loved for us to have hired him three years ago? I’m not saying Jai is the man for the job right now. I’m also not going to make a blanket statement and say absolutely not he shouldn’t be our coach. We don’t know yet, he very well could be the next Rick Pitino.
If Lucas was the next Pitino, we would know that by now. He is not a UK-caliber coach, even has less credentials than Mark Pope.
 

BBNinSCar

All-Conference
Apr 23, 2013
1,878
3,537
81
Young / Rising Mid-Major Coaches Who Struggled After Moving Up
1. Archie Miller (Dayton → Indiana)

  • The Rise: Took Dayton to four straight NCAA Tournaments, including an Elite Eight run in 2014, before turning 40.
  • The Fall: Hired at Indiana in 2017 to restore a blue blood, he went 67–58 overall (33–43 in Big Ten play) and never made a single NCAA Tournament before getting fired after four seasons.
2. Shaka Smart (VCU → Texas)
  • The Rise: Became the ultimate young coaching prodigy after taking VCU to the Final Four at age 33 and making five straight tournaments with his "Havoc" press.
  • The Fall: Couldn't replicate the magic in Austin. Over six seasons at Texas, he went 109–86 and failed to win a single NCAA Tournament game before leaving to reboot his career at Marquette.
3. Chris Mooney / Kevin Keatts / Mike White (Florida) — Best example: Mike White (Louisiana Tech → Florida)
  • The Rise: Went 101–40 at Louisiana Tech with three straight regular-season conference titles, making him one of the hottest young names on the carousel at 38.
  • The Fall: Took over for Billy Donovan at Florida in 2015. While he made a few tournaments early, the program steadily stagnated, missing the Big Dance in his final season before he bolted for Georgia ahead of a likely firing.
4. Mark Fox (Nevada → Georgia)
  • The Rise: Racked up a 123–43 record with three straight WAC titles and NCAA Tournament appearances at Nevada in his late 30s.
  • The Fall: Spent nine largely mediocre seasons at Georgia (163–133), making just two NCAA Tournaments and never winning a tourney game before being let go.
5. Richard Pitino (FIU → Minnesota)
  • The Rise: Landed the Minnesota job at just 30 years old after a promising debut season turning around FIU.
  • The Fall: Struggled to find consistency in the Big Ten over eight seasons (141–123 overall, 54–96 in conference), making only two NCAA Tournaments before being dismissed.
6. Josh Pastner (Memphis → Georgia Tech))
  • The Rise: Took over Memphis at 31 and rattled off four straight NCAA Tournament appearances and 100+ wins right out of the gate.
  • The Fall: Left for Georgia Tech in 2016 and went 109–114 over seven seasons, making just one NCAA Tournament (and losing in the first round) before getting fired.
7. Kyle Smith / Niko Medved / Or Mike Boynton (Oklahoma State)
  • The Rise: Promoted to head coach at OSU at just 35 years old as a rising star recruiter.
  • The Fall: Despite landing Cade Cunningham, he went 119–109 over seven seasons with just one NCAA Tournament appearance before being let go in 2024.
8. Travis Steele (Xavier)
  • The Rise: Longtime top assistant promoted at 36 to keep Xavier's Big East momentum rolling.
  • The Fall: Went 70–50 over four seasons and missed the NCAA Tournament every single year—the first Xavier coach to miss four straight since the early 1980s—before being fired in 2022.
9. Patrick Ewing / Chris Mullin / Or Bryce Drew (Valparaiso → Vanderbilt)
  • The Rise: Won four Horizon League titles in five years at his alma mater, making him one of the hottest young mid-major coaches in the country at 41.
  • The Fall: Hired at Vanderbilt in 2016, he went 40–59 overall and completely bottomed out in Year 3—going 0–18 in SEC play—before getting fired.
I like your one example of Todd (the pervert) Golden, but what about the up and comers that failed?

This is exactly why you look for candidates that have won everywhere-the Curt Cignetti model. There is only one coach that has the highest winning percentage in the country over the past 10 seasons. There is one coach who wins everywhere at a high level immediately. There is one coach who wins without the benefit of highly paid NIL players or elite recruits.
It's Josh Shertz. I only hope our admin isn't as blind to what Kentucky needs as most of the posters here.
 

deplion

All-Conference
Nov 6, 2007
281
1,826
93
If our top tier candidates say no, bring in Pearl for a couple of years.

He'd rebuild the excitement, make us competitive immediately, and be a great ambassador for the UK brand until we could land our next HoF level coach.
 

senonesy

All-American
Nov 30, 2017
4,196
8,587
113
I’m no saying Jai is the answer to our problems. Or he should definitely be our next coach. I will say after watching the second half of the Miami/North Alabama game last night. Anyone saying that he shouldn’t be on the shortlist needs to watch one of Miami’s games. I know this is a small sample size and you can’t make a judgment after just watching 1/2 of game. It’s just a few small things that I noticed about Jai’s coaching.

1. They beat an inferior opponent like they should have. They made North Alabama look like they shouldn’t even be on the floor. (They probably would’ve beaten Northern Arizona by 50 tonight).

2. Miami played extremely hard on offense and defense. Every player looked in sync and knew exactly what they were supposed to be doing at all times.

3. Miami played with effort at all times. Even when they were up by 40+ points. Jai was still coaching them and expecting effort no matter what the score was. He was still digging in there a$$ and not accepting mediocrity at any point.

4. Jai seems to be kind of a hard a$$. Even when being coached hard, you could tell his players really respected him and wanted to play hard for him.

This is just a few observations that I had watching that game. I’m not saying he should be at the top of the list for our next coach. I will be watching more of Miami games. We’ll see if they can make some kind of run in the ACC and the NCAA tournament this year.
No thanks
 
  • Like
Reactions: jrpross_rivals

BookofMormon

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2026
1,430
1,886
113
Scheyer is an influence, as is Calipari. He probably also learned coaching under his big brother John.

Might be more difficult to get him than what people think, with the way Miami spends in the NIL market. He’s got a very nice set up with modest expectations at Miami.

I also tend to agree with the sentiment that he hasn’t proved much yet. Need to see if he can do as well or better than he did last year again this time.
His bro who works in the WNBA and hasn't coached a lick of college hoops?

Jai Lucas stock is WAY overhyped. The guy has been jumpy, hasn't proven a thing. All he's proven he can do is recruit, learned coaching under two coaches who can only recruit. So if you want to run it back to that model, sure. If he finishes no better than 4th in that rancid ACC this year, then he's not doing anything special. UNC doesn't look like a tournament team, Clemson lost at home to Georgetown last night. I'm not sure they have more than 4 bids in that conference as of now.

I would want to see at least 4 years out of Lucas before I made a move. He's got 1 year of HC experience.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Recruiting 4-Star Kentucky Commit Makes Surprise Visit to Louisville
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Jerone Morton nears Kentucky debut, Trent Noah officially week-to-week
  3. 03 KSR Volleyball Brooklyn DeLeye is SEC Player of the Year, Tuozzo Tabbed Libero of the Year
  4. 04 KSR Basketball Duke fans want to get rid of Jon Scheyer after getting blasted by Illinois
  5. 05 KSR Basketball A 69-year-old record held by Kentucky legend Grady Wallace was broken last night