I think as much as we didn't care for Cal one thing he allowed UK to operate with was an NIL "discount". Players would come here knowing his track record of getting them to the next level so they'd be willing to take less to come play for him. That's not going to be the case for any coach other than if you landed one of the guys we all knew wouldn't come here.
Justin Edwards cost UK Knecht. So coaching decisions on roster hurt there more than NIL.
I believe Coach Pope's belief in the "Front of the Jersey" but these guys go anywhere for the most $/playing time and guarantees and it's just how it is. If you want to build the "Front of Jersey" culture you'll have a better chance in the future recruiting HS guys as core which he's up against this Spring. But the Portal? I mean that will make up majority of the '25 roster and they are mercenaries all the way.
I think Pope fully understands the situation, but I think his plan (hope) is to not blow the team up every year and start over. You won't be able to stop a kid that has an unexpected great year, thinks he can earn more somewhere else and puts his name out, but if you have a decent NIL budget you should be able to retain the key players you are building with. The front of the jersey kid is a kid that isn't going to be on any NBA mock draft board the day he arrives on campus but is able to contribute and develop on a multi-year plan.
Under Cal those kids never got a look, and if they did, they'd bolt after the first year because they realized Cal was never going to give them any serious play. Calipari was all too happy to do it because he was all about the instant gratification of players arriving and moving them to a bigger stage.
There is always going to be inequity, you'll always be competing with what the market will bear, but there can be a mix of kids who are being paid well with NIL AND want to be playing at a major D1 college. Pope is challenged to avoid filling up a team with kids that would just as soon play at Virginia Tech as UK as long as the money was the same, and focus on kids that like the idea of playing for a blueblood that can offer competitive NIL money.
So yea, UK fans should get used to the idea that 5 stars are going to be much less attracted to UK than before, but in exchange we'll get some guys that get better, older, stronger and will compete with 5 star freshmen who come in raw, weak and want to get the hell out of college as fast as they can.