It's kind of unfair to judge him yet, but I'm pretty hesitant at this point in this deal.
He's just now getting the team turned around, and for a while there I was worried we wouldn't even make World Cup. It's going to be hard to judge him on wins and losses if we do lose out of that group, because it's a crappy draw. I'm a "quality of play" believer, anyway. He's had some games where the quality of play was good, but a LOT of it was bad. And some of it was him trying to establish his system, and I get that- but I think he underachieved at times.
I dont know. I'm not in tuned enough to know what major changes he's made at the youth level- I know he's working at getting that better, and that should be a primary target. I still don't know if I think he needs to be signed like this right now, though.