True, though I would argue Hack’s freshman year with BOB wasn’t all that bad. Once CJF’s offensive style came into play, Hack was toast.
Why do we always end up with the overrated guys? Other programs pump out QB’s like a factory.
Let’s look ahead to 2024 PSU Football. 😀
- Thread starter BobPSU92
- Start date
Why do we always end up with the overrated guys? Other programs pump out QB’s like a factory.
How about a competent offense? The one they trotted out there today was middle school. The QB has zero confidence in himself. He’s scared of making mistakes. He’s indecisive. He has no touch. He is the reason we lost OSU and UM, and now Miss. BOth QB a the head coach are in over their heads.
Aside from Iowa, the PSU offense is abysmal
Prediction: I predict that Allar will soon enter the portal. Think about it from his standpoint. He came to PSU as the second ranked QB in the country. I'm sure he was certain that after next year he would be a first round draft pick and make millions. It isn't working out for him at PSU. I doubt that he thinks it is his fault. He (and his supporters) will tell him that he isn't being coached very well, PSU has wide receivers that suck and they will be even worse next year, the OL will be worse next year, and the offensive coordinator is unproven. Allar will conclude he has a better chance at the NFL by playing elsewhere. Once other coaches sniff out that he may want to leave, Allar will get a lot of contacts. I bet a month from now he is gone. Just my opinion.
I bet Allar thinks about Michael Penix. He was a pedestrian QB at Indiana. After 1 season at Washington he was in the Heisman finals and is going to be a first round draft pick.
I bet Allar thinks about Michael Penix. He was a pedestrian QB at Indiana. After 1 season at Washington he was in the Heisman finals and is going to be a first round draft pick.
Last edited:
I believe that some of the opt out situations will be taken care of next year by the playoff expansion to 12 teams. You will have more players opting to play to have that shot at an NC. Right now, does it matter if you're ranked 11 or 16 at the end ?? No. And, I'm willing to give the new Co-ord's some slack. AK seems like someone who knows how to get the most out of his players and put them into position to succeed. Offense should be better, although tackle is thin and we need some portals, but D will take a hit with those corners, TA will need to have the safeties help over top if we have the same corners, which did not happen in todays game.
We need to hit the portal for a QB. I had high hopes for Allar but the kid just doesn’t have it. How many tipped passes today?
Why would any WR worth a damn want to portal to us?
I’m looking forward to hopefully better play calling next year but damn, the execution on passing downs has been deplorable.
Why would any WR worth a damn want to portal to us?
I’m looking forward to hopefully better play calling next year but damn, the execution on passing downs has been deplorable.
Drew had plenty of time, open receivers, and a kick a$$ running game today…but he was very inaccurate and not what we needed to win
Obviously the lions share is D-1 football and basketball . Would you think all the other stuff would add up to ? $3 billion ?
PSU was 9th most profitable per this determination.
I found 18 profitable & 211 money-losing NCAA Division-I public athletic programs in 2020
[EDITED to add "Profit without FB coaching salaries." 5:24 pm, 9/3/22].www.linkedin.com
Guy who put together that chart is an intellectually lazy turd. Oregon is such a major outlier and he fails to notate it? Di he even bother to ask why? Took me about three minutes: in 2020 they received nearly $300mm in donations (guess who the largest benefactor was) to fund the renovation of Hayward Field.
Hirko is the poster boy for why higher ed is failing in this country. From his profile:
Assistant Professor
Wayne State University · Full-time
Jan 2023 - Present · 1 yrJan 2023 - Present · 1 yr
Joined the Sport Administration & Management Program in January 2023, teaching Sport Finance, History of Sport, and Sport Communications & Media.
Do the other sports add to $3bn? Have no good idea. If there were an Over/Under, I'd take the under. Reason: Media rights contracts for the whoe kit and kaboodle don't amount to squadoosh (that may change for women's basketball in the near future). That leaves the gate as pretty much the sole contributor. Under.
He does mention Phil Knight and Oregon . I’m unsure of the legitimacy of the rest of his spiel .
At some point the university’s will kill the golden goose .
At some point the university’s will kill the golden goose .
Except that Knight doesn't account for anywhere near all of the donations and how does Hirko account for the future mismatch when the funds are disbursed (NCAA accounting gets funny with the handling of that).
In 2024, I want everyone to know that I will not be entering the Transfer Portal, however I may choose to Opt Out of Season Tix. Respect My Decision! 100%
Last edited:
I watched more MAC, Sunbelt, Ivy, and Mountain West games this year. I pretty much ignored the ‘paid’ players and enjoyed the season. It’s an option for those of you fed up with this bs.
How much control AK has for the offense, is critical, and that means who the starting QB is.
As far as the Defense goes , i liked Manny , but we got beat by the running game of Michigan two years
in a row , same goes for OSU , Harrison on almost the same routes. Hopefully TA can install some
nastiness in the Defense. They are tough but not nasty big difference.
As far as the Defense goes , i liked Manny , but we got beat by the running game of Michigan two years
in a row , same goes for OSU , Harrison on almost the same routes. Hopefully TA can install some
nastiness in the Defense. They are tough but not nasty big difference.
I think QB ability to run is table stakes in the new CFB game. Drew can run, but seems so hesitant even though ha often has success. Whoever is the QB we need to have that threat.
Well said, our Defense today was not he same defense of the season and it really impacted us especially in the passing game.
i keep hearing that no one will benefit more from the 12 team format than PSU. Im not so sure anymore.
Even Riddick a Pitt grad pointed out that it wasn't our players or their attitude, King, Carter, Miller, KJ, Singleton, our line, were all praised for their temperment and effort from Louis. Our kids our gems our coaches can't shine
If the people paying them agree, then yes. That might be a sort of temporary fix for the opt outs--people paying the NIL money contractually require the players to compete in ALL games, unless injured. Teams and players could fudge that probably but you can only bite the hand that feeds you so often.
I wonder though, if you are not going to play one game because of risk, then why play four?
I’m waiting for the day a player sees his team is not making the 12-team playoff, with say 3 games remaining, and opts out of the rest of the season.
The day is coming IMO.
OL
Hope springs eternal. Even in Joe's later years, we had 2005. We had 2008. (I think we would have matched up well with either Florida or Oklahoma in 2008. We didn't match-up at all with USC and it showed.) Given what we've seen after 10 years of Franklin's coaching limitations and the current landscape of CFB, what reason is there to believe we are on the cusp of joining the higher echelon of CFB?
I'll answer my own question with an admittedly unlikely answer: Michigan. At the end of 2020, Michigan and Harbaugh were left for dead. Heck, we had beaten them when we were 0-5. But now they're in their 3rd straight CFP. They've won 3 straight B1G championships. They've beaten OSU 3 years in a row. And they haven't lost a B1G game since mid-2021. I don't know what their NIL is and I don't think they're big portal players. So seeing their metamorphosis gives hope that maybe the same thing could happen here. But other than that, I don't see where the hope comes from.
Wake us up when you see any real progress in beating teams with a pulse.
Yeah I thought it was odd that Olu opted out but was on the sideline in his uniform.
I expect that to eventually happen. How soon?
Surprised it hasn't happened already,
What exactly is a JoeBot? I for one recognize and celebrate Paterno being one of the greatest college coaches of all time. However, he should have retired at least 10 years before 2011. He also was made the biggest scapegoat that I have ever seen over the Sandusky situation by spineless leaders who were only too happy to throw him under the bus to cover their butts. I also am a big Franklin supporter and defend him constantly against his many haters. Some people can walk and chew gum at the same time son.
With his knee braces on. Sorry, but that was a very silly picture. But I'm afraid appropriate for today's CFB landscape.
I think (hope?) most of us fall into this same camp. It's the vocal minority that makes it seem like we're nuts for deeply admiring Paterno and his contributions to PSU while also desperately wanting Franklin to succeed because he seems to have his priorities right.
