I think you are conveniently forgetting how horrid those teams were.
Remember tying Arkansas State? Remember giving up 65 points to Steve Taneyhill?
1993: 3-6-2 (4-5-2 in the record books, with the forfeit from Bama)
Lost to Memphis (our last loss to them)
Got stomped by UF and AU
Got hammered by a ****** UK team at home (coldest game ever)
and the best of all - tied Arkansas State.
1995: 3-8
Outscored 165-73 by Tenn, S Carolina and Auburn. 65 to Carolina, 52 to UT and 48 to Auburn.
Lost to LA-Monroe
That's pretty freaking terrible. On par with the shittiness of Croom. 1993 can *almost* be excused, since we were still building, and Sherrill had won with Felker's players (primarily) in '91 and '92. But '95, coming off a Peach Bowl berth? Sherrill nearly got shitcanned in 1996, as you recall, until the upset of Bama and then the beatdown in Oxford saved his ***. Then, he started bending the rules a little and the winning started, which we all enjoyed of course. But you can't seriously tell me that those 2 years weren't some of the crappiest football you've ever witnessed.