Matt Rhule- pros and cons

Walleye 1

All-Conference
Mar 7, 2021
4,946
1,759
113
Listen Season 2 GIF by Paramount+
 

HuskerInCarolina

All-American
Dec 2, 2024
3,500
5,119
112
Cons: program building and player development

  • Ives was his first recruit. Now going on his 4th season here. Can hardly crack the depth chart. Has 22 carries to his career.
  • Cam Lenhardt recommitted to Nebraska after Rhule. Phenomenal freshman talent. Ghost as a sophomore. AWOL as a junior.
  • Barney...not much progression this season. Relatively same stats.
  • Offensive line...liability all 3 years under Rhule. The "we're gonna win the Joe Moore Award" grass fairies.
  • WR play....devoid of production and consistency.
  • Mekhi Nelson. "can start at any big ten program" 16 carries to his career. 3.6 yards per carry.
  • Rex Guthrie. "future NFL player" exposed. targeted. picked on.
  • Jeff freaking Sims. Mr. "sunday player". Mr. "NFL QB with NFL arm". FBI needs to look into Sims for prop bets during his time here.
  • Emmett Johnson. Expect me to believe Emmett magically became the beast he is this year while being forced down under Dowdell and Rahmir? He's always been a stud. Rhule AND Barthel AND Satterfield can all go pound sand for this one. Aggregious.
  • Elijah 'feel good story' Jeudy. Not a fan of walk-ons at all, but a walk-on should have played over him.
  • Riley Van Poppel. Did this dude do anything last offseason?
  • The entire DL. The "we're gonna break sack records" band of degenerates. 4 games with 0 sacks (1/3 of our season!!) 4 games with 1 sack. WE HAD 8 GAMES WHERE WE HAD 4 TOTAL SACKS!!!
  • Offensive Coordinator. Hired Dana to take over the offense. Offense added 5.8 points per game and 13.8 yards per game. What an improvement.
 

HawkinK.C.1

All-Conference
Jun 20, 2013
908
1,032
93
Pros - Other teams like him.
Cons - He's a dead man walking and all the players, current and future, know it.

It's doesn't matter, though, because your problems stem from higher up.
The fact that Trev left should scream that to anyone with a brain.
 
  • Like
Reactions: K Rod

redwine65

All-Conference
Jun 23, 2010
10,837
2,157
113
pros:
track record of rebuilds
communicates
doesn't drink and play golf
has us at 7 wins compared to coaches before him
brought special teams and dana coach

cons:
got trapped in pass happy qb statue collapsing pocket with raiola and pritchett
did'nt plan on replacing 0&9
lil slow on replacing unproductive coaches
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: TheSower

moralvictories

Sophomore
Jan 22, 2022
4,073
131
63
Pro's: Nice guy only redeeming quality....... but Fired immediately for cause
Con's : everything else
What cause? Unless something like the Sandusky scandal happens, Matt Rhule will be entitled to all compensation according to his contract.
 

dinglefritz

Heisman
Jan 14, 2011
51,371
12,788
78
pros:
track record of rebuilds
communicates
doesn't drink and play golf
has us at 7 wins compared to coaches before him
brought special teams and dana coach

cons:
got trapped in pass happy qb statue collapsing pocket with raiola and pritchett
did'nt plan on replacing 0&9
lil slow on replacing unproductive coaches
You lost me with the Pritchett and Raiola criticism. The problem with Raiola is largely our expectations. That said, if a con for a head coach is his loyalty to players and assistants, maybe in the long run that isn’t a terrible trait. By all accounts Rhule is a fair and well liked coach. Let’s hope he can build on what he’s done thus far. He knows it’s not been good enough yet.
 

dinglefritz

Heisman
Jan 14, 2011
51,371
12,788
78
not delivering on what he said we would do....... listen to his opening press conference

is the product anything he promised?
With EJ he has delivered to some degree on running the ball. As I recall he also talked about being a big physical team that played great defense. I think he has to rethink the 3-4 if he can’t find interior guys who demand double teams.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Truewooper

realHuskerDrew

All-Conference
Jun 12, 2001
13,138
3,690
81
Rhule is a freakin joke. And the extension a bigger joke.
The only credit I’ll give him is he did bring in Dana pretty quick, though what he is asking him to run doesn’t really work great. Have Sana run his old offense, or get a new power running OC.
Butler is not a great DC from what i see, but someone noted that the 3-3-5 is not his and if so let him run what he fvckin wants

Hoping all the Raiolas leave so that Rhule can can uncle Donnie, who sucks balls
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1FSB and Dylman

moralvictories

Sophomore
Jan 22, 2022
4,073
131
63
not delivering on what he said we would do....... listen to his opening press conference

is the product anything he promised?
Then a coach could be fired for any reason without receiving full compensation. Who would want to coach football if that were the case?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Truewooper

Spinner4

Senior
Jun 5, 2022
584
819
93
pros:
track record of rebuilds
communicates
doesn't drink and play golf
has us at 7 wins compared to coaches before him
brought special teams and dana coach

cons:
got trapped in pass happy qb statue collapsing pocket with raiola and pritchett
did'nt plan on replacing 0&9
lil slow on replacing unproductive coaches
Track record of rebuilds. Nebraska and Panthers think otherwise 🤣🤣🤣🤣

lil slow in replacing unproductive coaches? He hired them Jack🍑

and let’s stop acting like Dylan was a liability to Matt. Dylan saved Matt’s 🍑🍑🍑

what a dipsh*+
 
  • Like
Reactions: Macho Man and 1FSB

Spinner4

Senior
Jun 5, 2022
584
819
93
He’s a great promoter and is very likable.
Cons would be basically anything coaching related except for maybe recruiting.
Con artist are also great promoters and appear very likable. Just like brother Rhule.

Pack up the babies and grab the old ladies
And everyone goes
'Cause everyone knows Brother Rhule’s show
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wasker73

redwine65

All-Conference
Jun 23, 2010
10,837
2,157
113
Track record of rebuilds. Nebraska and Panthers think otherwise 🤣🤣🤣🤣

lil slow in replacing unproductive coaches? He hired them Jack🍑

and let’s stop acting like Dylan was a liability to Matt. Dylan saved Matt’s 🍑🍑🍑

what a dipsh*+
yeah the collapsing statue qb offense, was like the 95 huskers, good point poophead

he really took it to penn state and iow....
 

K Rod

Senior
Oct 1, 2025
345
521
93
Cons: program building and player development

  • Ives was his first recruit. Now going on his 4th season here. Can hardly crack the depth chart. Has 22 carries to his career.
  • Cam Lenhardt recommitted to Nebraska after Rhule. Phenomenal freshman talent. Ghost as a sophomore. AWOL as a junior.
  • Barney...not much progression this season. Relatively same stats.
  • Offensive line...liability all 3 years under Rhule. The "we're gonna win the Joe Moore Award" grass fairies.
  • WR play....devoid of production and consistency.
  • Mekhi Nelson. "can start at any big ten program" 16 carries to his career. 3.6 yards per carry.
  • Rex Guthrie. "future NFL player" exposed. targeted. picked on.
  • Jeff freaking Sims. Mr. "sunday player". Mr. "NFL QB with NFL arm". FBI needs to look into Sims for prop bets during his time here.
  • Emmett Johnson. Expect me to believe Emmett magically became the beast he is this year while being forced down under Dowdell and Rahmir? He's always been a stud. Rhule AND Barthel AND Satterfield can all go pound sand for this one. Aggregious.
  • Elijah 'feel good story' Jeudy. Not a fan of walk-ons at all, but a walk-on should have played over him.
  • Riley Van Poppel. Did this dude do anything last offseason?
  • The entire DL. The "we're gonna break sack records" band of degenerates. 4 games with 0 sacks (1/3 of our season!!) 4 games with 1 sack. WE HAD 8 GAMES WHERE WE HAD 4 TOTAL SACKS!!!
  • Offensive Coordinator. Hired Dana to take over the offense. Offense added 5.8 points per game and 13.8 yards per game. What an improvement.
Excellent post. It took Dana being hired to get EJ playing time. Wonder how many other impact players are buried on the depth chart because their position coach is too dunder headed to see the difference. I will be you 5 bucks there are more.
 

TouchdownTom

Junior
Jul 10, 2025
205
361
63
Pros - He is great at PR and can handle press conferences with embarrassing himself. But if you win most of your games you don’t need to be so good at PR.

Cons - Thinks he is great at anything else besides preaching and having to be forced to reconsider his decisions frequentl.
 

Anon1750875978

Heisman
Dec 26, 2018
6,428
11,136
113
With the number of coaches getting canned and with the amount of $$$$ still owed on a contract, it doesn't seem like Nebraska should have any trouble doing the same after next season if there isn't notable improvement.

Between wealthy donors and the TV money B1G schools are getting, I think HCMR gets one more year.

Football is king.