Most overrated bands/artists

UKRob 73

New member
Jan 25, 2007
14,967
2,480
0
Can't find any reference to The Eagles having the highest selling album. From everything I can find Thriller is number 1, Back In Black is number 2. The Eagles' Hotel California is somewhere in the mid-teens. And please oh please don't tell me you were counting The Eagles' Best Of album!?!

You must not have looked very hard. The eagles were recognized as the #1 selling album of the 20th century in US sales. As several others have said, it and thriller have gone back and forth worldwide, but in US sales it was #1. What's even more amazing is that it was released in 1976, the early part of their career. http://www.cnn.com/1999/SHOWBIZ/Music/12/08/eagles/
 

cantstandthecards

New member
Jan 7, 2009
1,259
140
0
Fugazi always charged $5 for their shows, never more, selling out 1000-3000 seat venues in every town. They have turned down millions of dollars multiple times to get back together.

Of course they wanted to sell records, and to suggest they don't is a strawman argument. However, what seems to escape you, besides facts that bands did turn down higher pay days, is that most "alt" bands or indie bands wanted to be part of something culturally with their art.

Art was the primary motivation, not money. It was a beautiful time. But it's also gone.
You know why it's gone? Because it sucked#
 
  • Like
Reactions: 420grover

JohnnyGentle

New member
Nov 6, 2007
1,559
466
0
If indeed "every grandma in church tomorrow probably loves and can sign along to Don't Stop Believing" , isn't that a complement to Perry.
I'd say the grandkids know a few Journey tunes as well.

If Joy Division was capable of stardom, they would have persued it.

You will never convince me that Alt bands don't want to sell records.

journey is trash

ian curtis offed himself at 23. i don't think it was because the band couldn't get booked on top of the pops. just a guess
 
  • Like
Reactions: DaBossIsBack

WildcatfaninOhio

New member
May 22, 2002
18,247
1,004
0
You must not have looked very hard. The eagles were recognized as the #1 selling album of the 20th century in US sales. As several others have said, it and thriller have gone back and forth worldwide, but in US sales it was #1. What's even more amazing is that it was released in 1976, the early part of their career. http://www.cnn.com/1999/SHOWBIZ/Music/12/08/eagles/

So, you ARE counting a Best Of as an album!?! Wow!
 
  • Like
Reactions: TortElvisII

roguemocha

New member
Jan 30, 2007
12,943
281
0
The Eagles are my number 1 too. Im pretty sure it all started when some people in high school argued that Hotel California was the greatest song ever written. Even at 15 I knew that was BS.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TortElvisII

rabidcatfan

New member
Jan 25, 2003
9,198
272
0
Kanye West - without question the most overrated "musician" (this is a lightly used term in his case) I've ever seen or heard of.

Runner up's:

Jack White. I saw a video on Youtube where Jack White is having a jam session with the Edge and Jimmy Page. White clearly, CLEARLY did not belong in that group. The most ridiculous part was when he was trying to show Edge and Page how to play the riff from Seven Nation Army. My 2 year old daughter could probably play that simple riff. White was showing that all the while Page was ripping out "Whole Lotta Love". It was like a 12 year old JV basketball player trying to go one-on-one with Jordan in his prime.

Kiss - definitely not a talented band (besides Ace Frehley). They just put on a pretty good show which was their bread and butter.
 

Ollie.ksr

New member
Jun 18, 2001
4,681
37
0
Pretty interesting thread......hated Springsteen until I listened to acoustic version of "No Surrender". The original version on "Born in the USA", I didn't like. The acoustic version I thought was great. At this time, he put out "Ghost of Tom Joad", I purchased it and then saw him at The Palace and was a fan. I can't stand his political views but as a musician and a performer, I really enjoy listening to him, but couldn't stand him during the 80's when I was in HS (graduated in '86). Also wasn't a fan of U2 until "Achtung Baby" -- really good album. Wasn't a fan of Pearl Jam until "Vitalogy", not the biggest fan but a few of their songs are great. Also Eddie's interview Steve Gleason was pretty awesome.

Kanye West -- terrible, don't get it at all. His interview years ago with Barbara Walters and he started rapping about her -- he thought he was awesome and it was hard for me to watch it. Just don't get it.

Rush -- don't get it. Have lots of friends that love them, but I don't get it.

Eagles -- not a big fan, but just watch their documentary and like them a little better. Funny, they didn't think their songs would last.

Today's country music -- can not listen to it at all.

In reading replies, it appears that there are categories people fall into --- people who enjoy lyrics -- Bruce, Neil, Dylan, etc. People who enjoy to sing along with catchy tunes -- Eagles, Journey, etc.

I also think the older you get, your music taste change. Really can't imagine that my kids will listen to the crap they listen to today, 25 years from now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mojocat_rivals48469

MegaBlue05

New member
Mar 8, 2014
10,042
2,686
0
...I also think the older you get, your music taste change. Really can't imagine that my kids will listen to the crap they listen to today, 25 years from now.

You'd be surprised. I grew up listening to exclusively heavy metal and rap in the 80s and 90s.

My two favorite genres today as a grown up: Metal and rap. (I find country too slow and depressing, and the stuff from my parents' generation is too tame. Not much on modern hip hop either. I still enjoy newer metal.)
 

Supreme Lord Z

New member
Jan 7, 2016
3,447
2,368
0
You'd be surprised. I grew up listening to exclusively heavy metal and rap in the 80s and 90s.

My two favorite genres today as a grown up: Metal and rap. (I find country too slow and depressing, and the stuff from my parents' generation is too tame. Not much on modern hip hop either. I still enjoy newer metal.)
This. My son loves the music I listen to just as I was heavily influence by the albums we kept in our Magnavox console stereo when I was growing up. Don't underestimate your influence.
 

Ollie.ksr

New member
Jun 18, 2001
4,681
37
0
You'd be surprised. I grew up listening to exclusively heavy metal and rap in the 80s and 90s.

My two favorite genres today as a grown up: Metal and rap. (I find country too slow and depressing, and the stuff from my parents' generation is too tame. Not much on modern hip hop either. I still enjoy newer metal.)

Do you listen to what you listened to back then or do you listen to today's metal and rap? It is very interesting.

I love depressing songs, about 20 years ago I made about 8 CD's of "Beer Drinking Songs".

My son is not into music much, but likes everything that I listen too and some of it is folk (John Prine, Todd Snider, etc.). He listens to today's music, but he likes the stuff I like.

I have a good friend of mine who loves music and he listens to today's country, which to me is just the same thing over and over and over and over. It is awful, but to each his own.
 

jameslee32

New member
Mar 26, 2009
33,643
920
0
The people that complain about The Boss, Dylan, Tom Waits, Lucinda Williams etc. just don't like songwriters. Stick to movies, video games or Toby Keith if you can. I could say something similar about Matchbox Twenty but won't. I just try something else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Supreme Lord Z