Naz may have some troubles

jwarigaku

All-Conference
Jan 30, 2006
4,201
1,559
73
For what it’s worth there is no reason he can’t stay for his 3.5 years and head to school early as long as he plans it out with home schooling and understanding his diploma will be issued by the home school and not Naz. It’s still a full and honored high school degree. Now stop trying to make trouble where it doesn’t exist. WADR there is only one kid this would apply to, so stop fishing.

No wants to go to college early
 

crusader_of_90

All-American
Nov 1, 2003
11,278
9,226
113
If you have not yet, watch Love Mean Zero about the precursor to IMG, which was the Nick Bollettieri tennis academy.
 

TonPlugZeroLock

Sophomore
Nov 19, 2016
297
145
0
Is this based on facts? or just the fact that he's a really good player in Illinois and that is what some of them do.
 

SilverHelmets

Junior
Nov 29, 2014
553
212
0
IMG has kids from all over the world on their athletic rosters. Only recently have any kids from the area gone there for basketball or football. Those are the money sports so that is why it is getting any attention.
 
Sep 24, 2009
881
658
0
Is this based on facts? or just the fact that he's a really good player in Illinois and that is what some of them do.

Jwar's post above was the only reply that got to the heart of the issue, if I'm understanding. The story isn't that "he" might go to IMG next year or year after. The claim initially made in this thread was that "he" wanted to leave early for college... not skip a year but be a December graduate who enrolls in college in January. This is done by those wanting to take part in spring football practice prior to the freshman year in hopes of being a true freshman starter. It is my understanding that Nazareth may not allow for early graduation, thus the "work around" Jwar explained as a possibility. The thought of the original poster is that "he" would transfer from Nazareth to another HS at some point that allows for early graduation.
 

jwarigaku

All-Conference
Jan 30, 2006
4,201
1,559
73
No Bias,

More or less what I was getting to yes, however, it’s not the player that is making the choice to come to the college he chooses, but rather a request by the university athletics department for the athlete to enroll in January to get a jump start on adjusting to being a student athlete.

The student is usually set up with a light schedule(12ish credits) to allow for the adjustment to workloads on and off the field and to allow the student to go home for things like Prom and graduation. I did have an extended discussion with the administration at Naz about this very topic in 2015 and cautioned them about finding flexibility in the program to allow for this to happen was important for future and some then current students. Of course this all was said with the caveat that the student was willing and able to complete the necessary work to then graduate with his or her classmates.

Jwar's post above was the only reply that got to the heart of the issue, if I'm understanding. The story isn't that "he" might go to IMG next year or year after. The claim initially made in this thread was that "he" wanted to leave early for college... not skip a year but be a December graduate who enrolls in college in January. This is done by those wanting to take part in spring football practice prior to the freshman year in hopes of being a true freshman starter. It is my understanding that Nazareth may not allow for early graduation, thus the "work around" Jwar explained as a possibility. The thought of the original poster is that "he" would transfer from Nazareth to another HS at some point that allows for early graduation.
 
Sep 24, 2009
881
658
0
No Bias,

More or less what I was getting to yes, however, it’s not the player that is making the choice to come to the college he chooses, but rather a request by the university athletics department for the athlete to enroll in January to get a jump start on adjusting to being a student athlete.

The student is usually set up with a light schedule(12ish credits) to allow for the adjustment to workloads on and off the field and to allow the student to go home for things like Prom and graduation. I did have an extended discussion with the administration at Naz about this very topic in 2015 and cautioned them about finding flexibility in the program to allow for this to happen was important for future and some then current students. Of course this all was said with the caveat that the student was willing and able to complete the necessary work to then graduate with his or her classmates.

Apparently you weren't persuasive enough in your discussions with said administrators?!
 

crusader_of_90

All-American
Nov 1, 2003
11,278
9,226
113
The likely snag is Religion class. We were required four years and much of the senior Religion class revolved around retreats and volunteering. You can't duplicate that in summer school like you can an English class.
 
  • Like
Reactions: USD24

jwarigaku

All-Conference
Jan 30, 2006
4,201
1,559
73
There are other Catholic schools in the Chicago Diocese that have allowed student athletes to graduate early. That said I’m certain this is the claim.

The likely snag is Religion class. We were required four years and much of the senior Religion class revolved around retreats and volunteering. You can't duplicate that in summer school like you can an English class.
 

Bwm57

All-Conference
Sep 12, 2011
3,734
1,096
103
Doesn’t seem right to me to not let a kid who can qualify academically to graduate early if that is their wish.
 

NazDad2828

Redshirt
Sep 2, 2018
10
2
0
Naz will be just fine. Studs come and go. Racki has built a tradition at naz that will have them winning for years to come.
 

Snetsrak61

Senior
Aug 16, 2008
1,209
681
113
Doesn’t seem right to me to not let a kid who can qualify academically to graduate early if that is their wish.
How does it normally work when a kid graduates HS early? Credits from summer school? Taking an extra class instead of a study hall period?
 

crusader_of_90

All-American
Nov 1, 2003
11,278
9,226
113
Either way - heavy courseload or summer school. Just accumulate the required credits in the categories required and you can graduate early.
 

eagles2k3

All-Conference
Dec 26, 2003
1,922
1,212
0
Doesn’t seem right to me to not let a kid who can qualify academically to graduate early if that is their wish.
They’re a private school. If they feel that it is necessary to have a student for a full four years to fulfill their requirements then they can do it. I can understand the thought process behind it. They probably feel that their growth as a student cannot be completed properly in 3.5 years(more than likely the religious/character side). If students or families don’t like it they can go to a public school.
 

Bwm57

All-Conference
Sep 12, 2011
3,734
1,096
103
They’re a private school. If they feel that it is necessary to have a student for a full four years to fulfill their requirements then they can do it. I can understand the thought process behind it. They probably feel that their growth as a student cannot be completed properly in 3.5 years(more than likely the religious/character side). If students or families don’t like it they can go to a public school.
Sure it’s their prerogative since they are a private school, I just don’t understand or agree with why they would hold a kid back.
If the kid was smart enough and judged mature enough to go to Harvard at 14 would that be right to hold that student back too?
 

Bwm57

All-Conference
Sep 12, 2011
3,734
1,096
103
How does it normally work when a kid graduates HS early? Credits from summer school? Taking an extra class instead of a study hall period?
Sure, as well as concentrating on core requirements vs. taking a bunch of electives.
It’s becoming much more common for even the top academic schools to try to get those kids they can in early to give them a head start.
 

jwarigaku

All-Conference
Jan 30, 2006
4,201
1,559
73
Let’s be candid and completely open in this discussion, the last 4.5 months of senior year is pure fluff and the student would develop a deep respect for either the academic or religious formation in the first 3.5 years. Proof of this development would exist in the quality of work produced during those 3.5 years.

They’re a private school. If they feel that it is necessary to have a student for a full four years to fulfill their requirements then they can do it. I can understand the thought process behind it. They probably feel that their growth as a student cannot be completed properly in 3.5 years(more than likely the religious/character side). If students or families don’t like it they can go to a public school.
 

McCaravan

All-American
Feb 1, 2016
4,715
7,458
113
Welcome to Mount Carmel’s world! Transfers happen, especially at Catholic schools. MC had Pierre Thomas transfer from there and that class still won state. Good programs don’t rely on one player, but it sucks I know. Dean and I joke that the end of the season through Christmas break is known as the “transferring season”
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gene K.

mc140

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
8,781
2,830
113
Let’s be candid and completely open in this discussion, the last 4.5 months of senior year is pure fluff and the student would develop a deep respect for either the academic or religious formation in the first 3.5 years. Proof of this development would exist in the quality of work produced during those 3.5 years.

I am waiting for the reclassifying and skipping of Senior year you now see with all the basketball players that were held back in junior high.
 

Snetsrak61

Senior
Aug 16, 2008
1,209
681
113
Sure, as well as concentrating on core requirements vs. taking a bunch of electives.
It’s becoming much more common for even the top academic schools to try to get those kids they can in early to give them a head start.
Hm, my experience at catholic schools is that there isn't much in the way of electives (with religion being a core requirement and taking up what might be elective courses in a public school).
 
Sep 24, 2009
881
658
0
I am waiting for the reclassifying and skipping of Senior year you now see with all the basketball players that were held back in junior high.

That's exactly what JT Daniels the freshman QB at USC did. There was much ballyhoo that he "skipped" his senior season at Mater Dei. He was a hold back who then simply classified back to his originl grad class when he decided he didn't need the extra year to reach his goal.
 

jwarigaku

All-Conference
Jan 30, 2006
4,201
1,559
73
Well not exactly true. Church history at Naz is considered a History/civics course by Naz, however, when we relocated to Pennsylvania the public ciriculum did not recognize it as a suitable course to fulfill the PA state education requirement. Hence, my son Justin had to take two full years of History/Civics his senior year. There is room in the schedule to make the 3.5 year graduation mark achievable at Naz.

Hm, my experience at catholic schools is that there isn't much in the way of electives (with religion being a core requirement and taking up what might be elective courses in a public school).
 

Snetsrak61

Senior
Aug 16, 2008
1,209
681
113
All this talk from the word on the street...
The "troubles" part of this is dumb. I do find the general idea of graduating high school interesting though. Is this like a special exception type thing or just a flexible type of scheduling thing that any student, top athlete or not can take advantage of without special accomadations being made?
 

crusader_of_90

All-American
Nov 1, 2003
11,278
9,226
113
The "troubles" part of this is dumb. I do find the general idea of graduating high school interesting though. Is this like a special exception type thing or just a flexible type of scheduling thing that any student, top athlete or not can take advantage of without special accomadations being made?
Anyone can take advantage of it - just complete the required credits.

My girls decided NOT to do this so to enjoy the end of senior year festivities. It's not difficult.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gene K.

PowerI66_

All-Conference
Oct 11, 2012
3,943
2,894
0
I would assume they could "graduate early" by taking the HSE (the new GED), and going from there. Similar to Bryce Harper.