that baseball recruiting is a little bit easier than the others because baseball stats are so refined.
But I typically look at height, handedness, position, and for pitchers fastball velocity first.
I like pitchers who are at least 6'0" tall and I'm a big fan of the guys who are 6'3"- 6'5" because those are the guys that have the frame to put on weight and develop. Win/loss record for pitcher is kind of useless, it more or less tells how good their high school team was, but that's also not necessarily a bad thing. I look at strikeout to walk ratio and then strikeout to innings pitched ratio. A guy who has 100 K's and 10 walks in 50 innings is probably going to be a pretty good prospect as long as he doesn't come from a small MPSA school. Also look at ERA- a good D-I prospect should have an ERA of 1.50 or below. If you get a pitcher with an ERA of below 1.00, with the other stats I mentioned, he's probably pretty good.
Hitters are different. After you see how tall they are and how big they are, you then can look at the stats. A guy who hits at least 5 home runs in Mississippi is going to have a chance to be a decent power hitter in college by his senior year. Someone who has more than 10 is a legit power hitter. I expect ALL hitters to hit at least .400 in high school if they are a legit D-I prospect. Then you look at stolen base totals, and those kind of speak for themselves. So, a guy with 16 home runs, 60 RBI's a .480 AVG and 20 steals is going to be a pretty good prospect. Catchers you can kind of look past some things like AVG or power if they are very good defensively. That's a MUST for catching prospects. Also realize that most D-I prospects who are middle infielders are going to be SS for their high school team, and some 3B. Some corner guys play 3B- Barlow is a good example, and some 1B, especially LH 1B play first in high school. Most OF prospects play CF. So, if a guy plays second on his HS team, I'm going to be a little weary of his defense.
Another thing to look at is the community. A player from Madison Central is probably going to be more refined than a player from Canton High School.
Those are some of the main predictors, and also why I'm excited about a guy like CC Watson and think that Matt Lane is going to be a project.