New Scout Ratings

esplanade91

Redshirt
Dec 9, 2010
5,656
0
0
Scout updated and Chris Jones and Sandberg bumped to 4 stars.

They gave Wells and Claayborn 3 stars. Updated the PG kids to 3 stars.

Team rankings, we're now at #17.

I know these things don't matter but it's nice to see some recognition. When you factor in Mullen's relative nobodies mixed with these blue chip guys I think Mullen is recruiting on the same level as every single coach in the SEC. Saban, Miles, and Chizik go after the same kids Notre Dame goes after and 5 star southern guys, while we spend time at games watching kids like Banks. Arkansas is a Sugar Bowl team and I think we have a better roster minus some receiver talent.
 
Last edited:

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
Right on time...

Scout always overranks us. Rivals always underranks us. And in their short history, 24/7 gets it about right IMO...

This is setting up to be a top 15 or better class on Scout... in reality another top 20-25 class.
 

TheStateUofMS

All-Conference
Dec 26, 2009
10,500
2,503
113
Does Cord Sandberg really have all those offers? Florida, Auburn, Clemson, West Virginia, etc...I don't think we've ever had a QB commit with those type offers if they are all legit.

And dude you're dead wrong about Saban and who he recruits. He doesn't give a flying 17 who Notre Dame recruits. He goes after the people he wants, who happen to be the top players in the nation, and he develops the **** outta them. Dan goes after players who fit his program and if they happen to be highly ranked, then that's great, but he goes after players he think he can develop into SEC football players by year two. Sometimes, yes he goes after the big boys, but he doesn't waste his time on primadonas that will more than likely go somewhere else. Dan does develop as well as Saban, problem is Saban develops kids with more talent. For the record I think Mullen is a good recruiter.
 

esplanade91

Redshirt
Dec 9, 2010
5,656
0
0
I didn't mean that Nick Saban looks at who Notre Dame has offered and then offers them. Don't be rediculous. My point was that Nick Saban goes after every consensus top recruit, like every perennial top 10 program. Dan does his own scouting and consistently picks up off-the-radar kids. See see this Chris Jones kid.
 

shotgunDawg

Redshirt
Nov 13, 2011
2,035
0
0
Engie,

How can you say which classes are about right? Do you know how these players will end up? I understand the trends, but to say that one is right and is wrong is a completely subjective matter. Your correct in that the rankings usually end up with Scout being the highest, 247 next, and Rivals hates us, but to say that one is right or wrong is incorrect. Personally, I have always thought that, due to how raw MS players are, they are usually underrated. This obviously isn't the rule, but in many cases a redshirt year, for a MS player, can equal another star.
 

JackShephard

Senior
Sep 27, 2011
1,763
938
113
I don't think that's quite true. They do their own rankings, but they also offer a "composite" ranking which is an average of scout, rivals, 247, and ESPN.
 

coach66

Junior
Mar 5, 2009
12,720
347
83
Victory Red is gonna kick my *** but the boys on the spirit are distressed by

these new rankings and have declared them total **********
 

GloryDawg

Heisman
Mar 3, 2005
20,930
20,310
113
You recruit what you need. You don't recruit based on stars. If you can land a few four and five star guys while getting what you need that's great. As we all know the stars don't always pan out. Just because your recruiting classes are always top 10 doesn’t mean you team is going to be top ten. How many top ten classes have GA and FL had in the past 10 years? Almost every year they are in the top 10. But as we all have seen in the past few years they have not panned out. I think Mullen is right to concentrate on Mississippi. Build the relationship with the high school coaches, give two and three star guys who might not have any other opportunity that opportunity. Who knows that guy’s best friend might turn out to be a five star guy who wants to play football with his friend or that guy himself might turn out to be another diamond in the rough. Also I might add one year Mississippi Highschool might have a loaded Senior class and we might be able to land a bunch of them.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
15,285
5,834
113
I didn't mean that Nick Saban looks at who Notre Dame has offered and then offers them. Don't be rediculous. My point was that Nick Saban goes after every consensus top recruit, like every perennial top 10 program. Dan does his own scouting and consistently picks up off-the-radar kids. See see this Chris Jones kid.

Only have to look at the cb from a couple of years ago (arenas?) that Crooms didn't think was worthy of a scholarship but slipped into one of Saban's classes at the last second to see that Saban does his own evaluations.
 

Victory Red

Redshirt
Aug 24, 2012
518
0
0
Honest question, why do you read over there so much? Not trying to start a pissing contest, I'm just wondering why you would read them most homer of all Rebel sites. I don't read BDJ, GP, or whatever that 247 site is, for any reason, and I certainly wouldn't be paying for a subscription. Just curious what motivates you to read that board so intently.
 

coach66

Junior
Mar 5, 2009
12,720
347
83
Honestly, I do get some good laughs reading the delusional **** both there and

on the Lake as they are somewhat mirror images of each other; as you say homers.
I think both places are pretty good examples for the stereotypes of both schools. Understand, I don't take any of these boards too serious,
as I said yesterday it is just good entertainment. There is plenty of good material in both places to stir the pot a little and let's
face it, stirring the pot is what both Nafoom and Sixpack excel at.
 

Spanky.sixpack

Redshirt
Jul 6, 2012
498
0
0
Wrong. You recruit the best football players you can find.....

If you are recruiting based on need, then chances are you've got a problem. Honestly, why do you recruit JUCOs (ie immediate impact players)? 80% of the time it will be because you had a hole to fill. 20% of the time it is because it's a very talented player, like McPhee, Newton and/or Autry.
 

GloryDawg

Heisman
Mar 3, 2005
20,930
20,310
113
Then you end up with eight QB's and one running back just like Ole Miss. Recruit what you need and if one of the needs can be field by a five star go for them. I will take three stars and someone who fields a need any time then to leave that need there just to get a four star in a positon you already have covered.
 
Last edited:

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
Engie,

How can you say which classes are about right? Do you know how these players will end up? I understand the trends, but to say that one is right and is wrong is a completely subjective matter. Your correct in that the rankings usually end up with Scout being the highest, 247 next, and Rivals hates us, but to say that one is right or wrong is incorrect. Personally, I have always thought that, due to how raw MS players are, they are usually underrated. This obviously isn't the rule, but in many cases a redshirt year, for a MS player, can equal another star.

Technically all I was saying is "the truth lies somewhere in the middle" which also happened to be where 24/7 ranked us(and that is not by accident).

24/7 is about 5x as thorough on evaluations as the other two. They actually go to highschool games. Evaluate tons of film. They have a system of checks and balances in place that prevent an overzealous writer from inflating rankings for any given team. They hire writers that live and work in the area they are covering(not living in Baton Rouge writing about recruiting at Mississippi State). They also do the 24/7 composite which takes the ranking of all 4 sites and average them together, giving equal value to all 4. There is NO better current way of "guessing" at this...and this is just another reason that they are better than the other guys.

Last season:
Scout - 18
Rivals - 30
24/7 - 23
24/7comp - 23

This season:
Scout - 17
Rivals - 28
24/7 - 19
24/7comp - 23
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
If you are recruiting based on need, then chances are you've got a problem. Honestly, why do you recruit JUCOs (ie immediate impact players)? 80% of the time it will be because you had a hole to fill. 20% of the time it is because it's a very talented player, like McPhee, Newton and/or Autry.

Talk in circles much?

So you are saying we didn't have a hole to fill at QB or DE, they were just "very talented players"? You've got to be kidding. No reason we can't recruit very talented players FOR our holes to fill. That is the reality of what you do, especially in juco recruiting.

There will be several 4* JUCO OL in MS this year... why aren't we actively recruiting them, since they are "very talented players"? It's because it is not a position of need in which we feel they are BETTER than what we already have on roster.

You always, ALWAYS recruit based on need first. That's why we are in the position we are in and Ole Miss is in the position they are in(taking your approach to "best players").
 

Spanky.sixpack

Redshirt
Jul 6, 2012
498
0
0
Listen and you'll hear me......

I'm not talking about stars. I'm talking about getting the most talent you can on your football team. Obviously you exercise common sense. You don't pass on an outstanding Safety prospect because you need a Tight End. You take the best player available. And truth be known, typically the best athletes on high school teams are playing QB, so it's not a bad idea to take more than a few QBs each year. They make great Wide Receivers.
 

Spanky.sixpack

Redshirt
Jul 6, 2012
498
0
0
Wrong. Ole Miss didn't go get the best players......

I honestly think Houston Nutt recruited based on the internet. And Ole Miss' problem isn't that they didn't sign good players, it's that none of them actually came to school.

And if there is a Super Stud OL in JUCO, then we should try and get him. If it's a talented guy that can help your team and you have a good opportunity to sign him, you do it. Alot of teams didn't NEED Cam Newton in December of 2009 either. I bet they wish they could take that decision back.

Get out of here with this weak crap, dude. You won't win. How the hell will any coach know what they'll need in 4 years. You take the best 25 players you can find. Again (hate I'm having to explain this), you exercise common sense. Obviously you have to have linemen so you don't take 25 skill players. You let your talent pool dictate how you build your team.
 
Last edited:

aTotal360

Heisman
Nov 12, 2009
22,679
16,732
113
Technically, Dan didn't go after Jones. He fell in our lap.

Story I have heard was when the Houston bus showed up one of the assistants saw them unload and said "who in the 17 is this beast?". Then Jones proceeded to kick *** in all of Wilson's drills. By the end of practice, he was offered. Next day he committed. He went from literally unknown to our coaches, to getting an offer.

But you are right. In our current state, we have to turn off the radar guys into quality SEC players.
 

engie

Sophomore
May 29, 2011
10,764
106
63
Get out of here with this weak crap, dude. You won't win. How the hell will any coach know what they'll need in 4 years. You take the best 25 players you can find. Again (hate I'm having to explain this), you exercise common sense. Obviously you have to have linemen so you don't take 25 skill players. You let your talent pool dictate how you build your team.

Dubmass, just took both sides of your argument in this one paragraph. Are you arguing with me or yourself? Shouldn't have disagreed in the first place if you couldn't state your point in a clear and concise manner.

"You take the best 25 you can find" = take best 25 players regardless.

"Obviously you have to have linemen" = recruiting to NEED which you argued initially.

Of our recruiting class this season, only a few guys are "best player regardless of position" takes. Tony Conner, Ashton Shumpert, etc...The rest are the best players available to us at positions OF NEED.

We go into recruiting season expecting a certain number of expected future NEEDS at every position. We balance this out at about 20 players or so total. We then setup a "board" at those positions of NEED with the top priority, 2nd, 3rd, etc. Then we go after those players. Only 5 or so spots are reserved for "best players" regardless of position.
 

Spanky.sixpack

Redshirt
Jul 6, 2012
498
0
0
I see you ignored the Cam Newton part.....

Figures.

Looks to me like our commitment list is pretty much the best players we can find. I don't see an emphasis on any one position. I see alot of guys that can play multiple positions. Looking at Cord Sandberg, he's a great QB commitment. If we had one spot left, do you think Mullen would tell a QB like Ryan Buchanan no if he wanted to sign with us at the last minute, but we 'needed' one more OL and had nothing but off the wall average players left on the board? NO.
 

GloryDawg

Heisman
Mar 3, 2005
20,930
20,310
113
In that case maybe yes but as bad as we needed Offensive lineman in the past that senerio doesn't work. You can only sign 25 each year and you damn well better sign what you need and not let some other position lapse to sign a extra DB when you already got enough.
 

tenureplan

All-Conference
Dec 3, 2008
8,582
1,220
113
There are a small handful of players that we would take no matter what. Other than that, the board is filled with needs 2 years and out (hs) and juco for next years needs.
 

Spanky.sixpack

Redshirt
Jul 6, 2012
498
0
0
Croom recruited based on need......

Any successful coach will tell you differently. Ask Gene Stallings, who has explained this process countless times.

Stop listening to Paul Jones and Rosebowl Robertson so much. They don't know ****.
 

tenureplan

All-Conference
Dec 3, 2008
8,582
1,220
113
Croom had no idea what he needed. I don't need Paul or Steve to tell me what is obvious to anyone with half a brain.
 
Aug 22, 2012
2,761
1
31
Figures.

Looks to me like our commitment list is pretty much the best players we can find. I don't see an emphasis on any one position. I see alot of guys that can play multiple positions. Looking at Cord Sandberg, he's a great QB commitment. If we had one spot left, do you think Mullen would tell a QB like Ryan Buchanan no if he wanted to sign with us at the last minute, but we 'needed' one more OL and had nothing but off the wall average players left on the board? NO.

You don't have to be Engie to see you are an idiot. You recruit for what you forecast you will NEED. You need some of certain positions in every class (regardless of stars). What good is a second great QB recruit if you're OL depth is crap? Ask Matt Barkley and that freshman center that Stanford was steamrolling all night long...
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Points of Focus from Jeff Lebby in Week 12 media availability
  2. 02 Maroon and White Football What Mississippi State HC Jeff Lebby said about Sunday staff changes
  3. 03 On3 Football Over 35% of Power Four starting quarterbacks missed games with injuries in 2026
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football Sunday Notebook: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State
  5. 05 Rivals Football Recruiting Biggest rankings risers in the updated 2027 Rivals300 rankings