Official PSU - tOSU '25 game thread

PSUForever

Senior
Feb 17, 2007
685
618
93
Who doesn't stink on this team? Nwosu and Barker are arguably our best players. Maybe Kaytron.
Everyone has mailed it in. That secondary performance was horrible. We supposedly had talent in our secondary but you would never know it. Yes OSU has two top 5-10 WRs but you still gotta be better than that. That was bottom feeder B10 level which we clearly are. I also blame Knowles for confusing everyone on defense and not adapting.
 

Big_O

All-Conference
Jun 28, 2001
1,230
1,890
113
Watching the O$U and Indiana games today I have come to a couple of conclusions. Indiana is a really well coached team with decent players. O$U has the best talent in the country, probably all 4* and 5* starters, but does not have quite the same level of coaching.

Indiana leads the country in scoring, averaging a margin of victory of over 35 points per game. Not a good matchup for Penn State next week.
 

bdgan

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
3,151
3,140
113
Everyone has mailed it in. That secondary performance was horrible. We supposedly had talent in our secondary but you would never know it. Yes OSU has two top 5-10 WRs but you still gotta be better than that. That was bottom feeder B10 level which we clearly are. I also blame Knowles for confusing everyone on defense and not adapting.
I remember some very average secondaries under Paterno but they played zone and kept things in front of them. It was called bend but don't break.

This year the LBs & DBs look like they don't understand their assignments.
 

WaffleShopper

Senior
Sep 20, 2023
262
449
63
I remember some very average secondaries under Paterno but they played zone and kept things in front of them. It was called bend but don't break.

This year the LBs & DBs look like they don't understand their assignments.
Those defenses were so frustrating to watch but they were effective. The plan for today was supposed to be BBDB but our secondary absolutely blew it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bdgan

CaliLion79

Senior
Oct 8, 2021
442
721
93
  • Like
Reactions: UncleRoyBiggins
Oct 13, 2025
24
40
13
Watching the O$U and Indiana games today I have come to a couple of conclusions. Indiana is a really well coached team with decent players. O$U has the best talent in the country, probably all 4* and 5* starters, but does not have quite the same level of coaching.

Indiana leads the country in scoring, averaging a margin of victory of over 35 points per game. Not a good matchup for Penn State next week.
Indiana likes to run up the score. If you watch their games, they won't let up in the fourth when they are blowing someone away. I think Cignetti feels that he needs to keep scoring for the rankings.

E.G. He won't take a knee if he is destroying someone and is up 42-6 with a minute left in the fourth. He will throw a deep ball and keep going for the endzone until the clock strikes zero. This has rubbed some teams the wrong way, but it is what it is. That's not to say Indiana is not legit. But they show no mercy to opponents and Cignetti has got a reputation for rubbing it in when he has no need to.

IF PSU finds itself down like they were today 38-14 with a minute left, don't expect any knees to drop. Cignetti will tack another score if he can, just to rub it in. Think Indiana has a Napolean complex. Indiana has been so irrelevant for so long, now that they are legit good, they feel like they need to convince themselves further that they are legit by kicking someone even when they are down.
 
Last edited:

PSUwolf

Senior
Nov 11, 2014
2,386
416
83
Indiana likes to run up the score. If you watch their games, they won't let up in the fourth when they are blowing someone away. I think Cignetti feels that he needs to keep scoring for the rankings.

E.G. He won't take a knee if he is destroying someone and is up 42-6 with a minute left in the fourth. He will throw a deep ball and keep going for the endzone until the clock strikes zero. This has rubbed some teams the wrong way, but it is what it is. That's not to say Indiana is not legit. But they show no mercy to opponents and Cignetti has got a reputation for rubbing it in when he has no need to.

IF PSU finds itself down like they were today 38-14 with a minute left, don't expect any knees to drop. Cignetti will tack another score if he can, just to rub it in. Think Indiana has a Napolean complex. Indiana has been so irrelevant for so long, now that they are legit good, they feel like they need to convince themselves further that they are legit by kicking someone even when they are down.
I've watched 3 Indiana games this year and have to agree with you.........they love to run up the score even when the game is long decided
 

haveyoumethoward

All-Conference
May 27, 2019
902
1,635
93
Great. Then we can fire our next coach before we hire him.

So who are we getting to replace the guy we just fired, who has yet to replace the other guy we just fired?
Urban Meyer followed by Nick Saban, both deemed unworthy to be HC at PSU and finally Pat Narduzzi just to complete the circle of total ineptitude.
 
May 11, 2012
373
496
63
I m in no way defending his poor play thus far in his short career but Grunkenmeyer was a consensus 4 star recruit with major offers all over the country. Penn St does not develop QB s....it s jarring when you watch other games on Saturdays and see less heralded QBs play better all the time.
Well this year PSU had three high level OOC opponents....I guess that is why Allar needed to play 55 minutes....we were only up by 30 points! Seriously...I cannot remember ANY PSU backup QB getting quality in game playing time..
(Remember Ta' Quan Roberson at Iowa?)
 

leinbacker

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
2,280
3,642
113
Great. Then we can fire our next coach before we hire him.

So who are we getting to replace the guy we just fired, who has yet to replace the other guy we just fired?

That would be cool, we hire a new coach then during the press conference, Kraft and the new coach get into and Kraft fires him on the spot.
 

op2

Senior
Mar 16, 2014
11,335
787
103
Great. Then we can fire our next coach before we hire him.

So who are we getting to replace the guy we just fired, who has yet to replace the other guy we just fired?
I don't know but whoever it is, he's on the hot seat already so we'd better start looking for his successor.
 

dcf4psu

All-Conference
Nov 7, 2003
891
1,120
93
Indiana likes to run up the score. If you watch their games, they won't let up in the fourth when they are blowing someone away. I think Cignetti feels that he needs to keep scoring for the rankings.

E.G. He won't take a knee if he is destroying someone and is up 42-6 with a minute left in the fourth. He will throw a deep ball and keep going for the endzone until the clock strikes zero. This has rubbed some teams the wrong way, but it is what it is. That's not to say Indiana is not legit. But they show no mercy to opponents and Cignetti has got a reputation for rubbing it in when he has no need to.

IF PSU finds itself down like they were today 38-14 with a minute left, don't expect any knees to drop. Cignetti will tack another score if he can, just to rub it in. Think Indiana has a Napolean complex. Indiana has been so irrelevant for so long, now that they are legit good, they feel like they need to convince themselves further that they are legit by kicking someone even when they are down.
I agree and it's why I think he'll be yet another coach being fired with big dollars owed to him in about two years.
 

MrTailgate

All-Conference
Oct 19, 2021
934
1,739
93
That would be cool, we hire a new coach then during the press conference, Kraft and the new coach get into and Kraft fires him on the spot.
Well, the Boss and Billy Martin had their day. Maybe this is all a plan for Kraft to hire Franklin for an encore when the dust settles
 

Nittering Nabob

All-Conference
Sep 17, 2024
1,965
1,694
113
Indiana likes to run up the score. If you watch their games, they won't let up in the fourth when they are blowing someone away. I think Cignetti feels that he needs to keep scoring for the rankings.

E.G. He won't take a knee if he is destroying someone and is up 42-6 with a minute left in the fourth. He will throw a deep ball and keep going for the endzone until the clock strikes zero. This has rubbed some teams the wrong way, but it is what it is. That's not to say Indiana is not legit. But they show no mercy to opponents and Cignetti has got a reputation for rubbing it in when he has no need to.

IF PSU finds itself down like they were today 38-14 with a minute left, don't expect any knees to drop. Cignetti will tack another score if he can, just to rub it in. Think Indiana has a Napolean complex. Indiana has been so irrelevant for so long, now that they are legit good, they feel like they need to convince themselves further that they are legit by kicking someone even when they are down.
I don’t know why anyone would criticize Cignetti’s formula for sustained winning. 🤷🏼‍♂️

Why do I suspect that you’re under age 40 and got snacks after your soccer games, regardless of the outcome.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChandlerPearce58

CDLionFL

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2021
1,677
2,559
113
It's honestly ridiculous that anyone is trying to claim he's a dirty player. You clearly don't watch him often.

You and others are mad that targeting was overturned and are unfairly attacking the player instead of the inability of those to enforce the rules.

Headshots will always exist in football. They game is too fast to eliminate them completely. The NFL handles it far better.
I said he took liberties. Don't put ******* words in my mouth, *******. So fine, I'll ******* say it -- any player that goes for the head like Downs did is a dirty piece of ****. There, you happy now? Get bent.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: OUIrPSU

PAgeologist

Senior
Oct 19, 2021
555
848
93
Indiana likes to run up the score. If you watch their games, they won't let up in the fourth when they are blowing someone away. I think Cignetti feels that he needs to keep scoring for the rankings.

E.G. He won't take a knee if he is destroying someone and is up 42-6 with a minute left in the fourth. He will throw a deep ball and keep going for the endzone until the clock strikes zero. This has rubbed some teams the wrong way, but it is what it is. That's not to say Indiana is not legit. But they show no mercy to opponents and Cignetti has got a reputation for rubbing it in when he has no need to.

IF PSU finds itself down like they were today 38-14 with a minute left, don't expect any knees to drop. Cignetti will tack another score if he can, just to rub it in. Think Indiana has a Napolean complex. Indiana has been so irrelevant for so long, now that they are legit good, they feel like they need to convince themselves further that they are legit by kicking someone even when they are down.
I dont blame him. Indiana has been blown out of a lot of games over the years. Theyre just returning the favor.
 

WaffleShopper

Senior
Sep 20, 2023
262
449
63
Indiana likes to run up the score. If you watch their games, they won't let up in the fourth when they are blowing someone away. I think Cignetti feels that he needs to keep scoring for the rankings.

E.G. He won't take a knee if he is destroying someone and is up 42-6 with a minute left in the fourth. He will throw a deep ball and keep going for the endzone until the clock strikes zero. This has rubbed some teams the wrong way, but it is what it is. That's not to say Indiana is not legit. But they show no mercy to opponents and Cignetti has got a reputation for rubbing it in when he has no need to.

IF PSU finds itself down like they were today 38-14 with a minute left, don't expect any knees to drop. Cignetti will tack another score if he can, just to rub it in. Think Indiana has a Napolean complex. Indiana has been so irrelevant for so long, now that they are legit good, they feel like they need to convince themselves further that they are legit by kicking someone even when they are down.
I don’t think it has anything to do with them being Indiana. That’s just his coaching personality and part of why his teams win. He has no mercy and wants to stomp on the opponent no matter what the score is or how much time is left. I love that attitude and wish we had it.
 

MacNit

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
1,981
1,827
113
Indiana likes to run up the score. If you watch their games, they won't let up in the fourth when they are blowing someone away. I think Cignetti feels that he needs to keep scoring for the rankings.

E.G. He won't take a knee if he is destroying someone and is up 42-6 with a minute left in the fourth. He will throw a deep ball and keep going for the endzone until the clock strikes zero. This has rubbed some teams the wrong way, but it is what it is. That's not to say Indiana is not legit. But they show no mercy to opponents and Cignetti has got a reputation for rubbing it in when he has no need to.

IF PSU finds itself down like they were today 38-14 with a minute left, don't expect any knees to drop. Cignetti will tack another score if he can, just to rub it in. Think Indiana has a Napolean complex. Indiana has been so irrelevant for so long, now that they are legit good, they feel like they need to convince themselves further that they are legit by kicking someone even when they are down.
Franklin used to do the same. What goes around, comes around.
 

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
11,051
17,799
113


Kotelnicki:

 

Moogy

All-Conference
Jul 28, 2017
3,193
2,174
113

Unequivocally targeting. If you were going to define targeting with an example, this would be it.

Defender saw the ball was past him. The defender “wound up” and launched himself toward the head area, regardless.

If someone with authority thinks this isn’t targeting, we may as well just eliminate the rule and let all the cool kids try to give other kids permanent brain damage for fun.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pendal1

Wewantthelion

Redshirt
Oct 25, 2021
23
16
2
I don’t think it has anything to do with them being Indiana. That’s just his coaching personality and part of why his teams win. He has no mercy and wants to stomp on the opponent no matter what the score is or how much time is left. I love that attitude and wish we had it.
When I was in school which was a long time ago. My coaches always told me if you don’t like being scored on do something about it. No matter what the score was.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WaffleShopper

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
2,335
1,587
113
I said he took liberties. Don't put ******* words in my mouth, *******. So fine, I'll ******* say it -- any player that goes for the head like Downs did is a dirty piece of ****. There, you happy now? Get bent.
So you claim I put words in your mouth then you proved what I said was exactly what you were saying
Learn the game. He's not a dirty player.
Also, learn to control your emotions--maybe it's your time of the month--who knows.
 

bwc

Freshman
May 22, 2014
65
93
18
Unequivocally targeting. If you were going to define targeting with an example, this would be it.

Defender saw the ball was past him. The defender “wound up” and launched himself toward the head area, regardless.

If someone with authority thinks this isn’t targeting, we may as well just eliminate the rule and let all the cool kids try to give other kids permanent brain damage for fun.

It certainly was, however, the BIG isn't going to eject the best defensive player on the best team in the league, especially when they've spent all year promoting him as a defensive Heisman candidate. I won't go so far as to call him a consistently dirty player, but that play was cheap and dirty. Only an idiot would look for ways to excuse it.

What bothers me the most about it wasn't that it was called incorrectly. I expected nothing less. It's that zero of Dinkins teammates did anything about it. No fire, no standing up for your guy, no get back, not even any s**t talking. Someone should've put a helmet into the side of his knee on the next play to convey a message.