OT: best bourbon under $500

sefus12

Heisman
Dec 22, 2007
7,399
19,622
103
I assume you mean $50, so I’m going to answer in that direction. First off, there are tons of great bottles under $50. Wild Turkey Rare Breed would be my first recommendation, but that assumes the recipient likes higher proof whiskies. It’s just a fantastic pour for the money. For a lower proof, the Four Roses Single Barrel (red labels) are a lot of fun and you can pinpoint certain flavors based on which of the versions you go with. For something less traditional, Still Austin Barrel Proof, Green River Full Proof, and Ben Holladay Soft Red Wheat are all really good whiskeys for around that $50 mark.

Again, tons of options out there at that price point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blu-ish

AllBall

All-American
May 5, 2015
4,992
6,618
93
Getting Christmas gifts, what’s yalls recommendation?
Store picks are great to explore.
And:
EH Taylor single barrel, Weller Antique or Full proof, and Stagg if you like a fuller proof.

My personal favs I can afford on the reg are: Russell's Reserve 12, Penelope Toasted Marshmallow, Angel's Envy Rye, Eagle Rare, Blanton's, or Woodford Double Oak, and Ben Holloday Ryes.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JPFisher

JPFisher

Heisman
Jul 24, 2013
6,979
13,756
113
Weller, to me, is better than 99% of the fanciest bottles that cost an arm, a leg, and a left nut. Green or red labels are the most common I find, and they're both incredibly smooth. Supposedly, their other labels are all under $500 unless it's a limited edition release.

Personally, I'd save money and grab as many red labels as possible. Best damn fall/winter bourbon I've ever tried. Just a hint of spice to mingle with whatever's cooking in the kitchen.

As a rule, I treat pretty much anything Buffalo Trace puts out as the apex of the art form. I've had some great bourbons from other distilleries, though – Four Roses Single Barrel, Four Roses Barrel Strength, Woodford Double(or triple)-Oaked are some crowd pleasers too.

My take, again, is that any more than $150 for a bottle, and I start to feel like I'm paying for status rather than substance. I dunno about you all, but I partake for substance.
 

TheBlueMist

All-American
Feb 5, 2004
2,255
5,505
113
Pappy Van Winkle Family Reserve 20 Year.

That said, (and I love me some Pappy), I would rather save the money and buy Three Roses, Wild Turkey Rare Breed, Buffalo Trace, and many others for sipping whiskey.
 

@BigBlueFanGA

Junior
Jul 6, 2025
232
248
43
Anybody that pays more than 30-50 for a fifth of bourbon is, well, dumb.
So you've tried them all huh? I'm gonna guess you either won't or can't buy high end bourbon. I'm sure it's similar to tequila. There is a huge difference in most high end tequila compared to low or mid range tequila. I know this as a fact, not a guess.
 

BlueBallzz

Sophomore
Jul 3, 2025
161
167
43
I assume you mean $50, so I’m going to answer in that direction. First off, there are tons of great bottles under $50. Wild Turkey Rare Breed would be my first recommendation, but that assumes the recipient likes higher proof whiskies. It’s just a fantastic pour for the money. For a lower proof, the Four Roses Single Barrel (red labels) are a lot of fun and you can pinpoint certain flavors based on which of the versions you go with. For something less traditional, Still Austin Barrel Proof, Green River Full Proof, and Ben Holladay Soft Red Wheat are all really good whiskeys for around that $50 mark.

Again, tons of options out there at that price point.
Rare Breed is one of my favorite bourbons. It’s very smooth and for the proof, it tastes like 90. I always keep a bottle in hand, but my every day is Makers.
 

TheDude73

Heisman
Jan 7, 2006
24,498
24,543
113
Anything Willett Family Estate (not the rye). I was so bummed when they stopped selling it in the gift shop, but they had to fight the flippers somehow. Every time we go back to KY to visit family I go to the WFE bar and reminisce on the old days when I had more than 60 WFE barrel proof bourbon bottles in my liquor cabinet (I have photographic proof!).
 

BlueBallzz

Sophomore
Jul 3, 2025
161
167
43
Pappy Van Winkle Family Reserve 20 Year.

That said, (and I love me some Pappy), I would rather save the money and buy Three Roses, Wild Turkey Rare Breed, Buffalo Trace, and many others for sipping whiskey.
I have the Pappy 10, 12, 15, 20 and 23. The 20 is my favorite out of the bunch. Since I’m buying as a gift, going to splurge a little but I like all those. I keep a bottle of Rare Breed and Buffalo Trace but BT is hard as heel to get where I am. It’s starting to flow in a little bit but sells out quickly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheBlueMist
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Underdogs have owned Kentucky vs. Missouri series
  2. 02 KSR Basketball Kentucky Fouled Five Indiana 3-Point Shooters
  3. 03 KSR Football Will Stein's Message to Kentucky Ahead of Missouri Road Trip
  4. 04 KSR Football CFB Cheat Sheet: Week 12
  5. 05 KSR Football Bio Blast: Missouri Tigers