This is important...for potato salad.
OT: Best Mayo
- Thread starter HotMop
- Start date
Then why is it not a mustard poll?**
I grew up on Blue Plate, but I prefer Duke's now.
Whichever brand you like the olive oil variant is the best one.
Have eaten Blue Plate and Bama my whole life. Dukes became widely known a few years ago so I had to try it. It’s not good.
I wouldn't touch Mayo with a 200 mile long pole, so all of it is bad.
We are a Blue Plate household.
Duke's isn't anything to be ashamed of; I'll sometimes buy it if it's on sale. Like village dog mentioned, I don't recall Duke's being a thing in South Mississippi in the late nineteen hundreds into the early 2000s - if the Jitney Jungle carried it, we certainly didn't buy it. I'm not being a hater when I say Duke's marketing has really done a fantastic job convincing folks it's the REAL Southern mayo.
Duke's isn't anything to be ashamed of; I'll sometimes buy it if it's on sale. Like village dog mentioned, I don't recall Duke's being a thing in South Mississippi in the late nineteen hundreds into the early 2000s - if the Jitney Jungle carried it, we certainly didn't buy it. I'm not being a hater when I say Duke's marketing has really done a fantastic job convincing folks it's the REAL Southern mayo.
I completely agree, but boy can you set off a firestorm with some folks saying it.
I don't get too uptight about personal preferences. We're all different. I'm fine with the vast majority of Mayo's. Prefer Hellman's and Blue Plate, and Dukes is one of the few I don't care for. But even it's fine when used in something. Some folks swear by it in their pumenter cheese.
I guarantee you if we did a blind taste test none of you could distinguish any of the mayo listed. It all tastes the same.
I could pick out Dukes. Zero doubt. You're probably right on the rest.
I don't think anybody can blind pick Hellman's over Walmart brand. They probably make it
I'm looking, but I didn't see "Not a damn one of 'em" as a choice. No thanks to emulsified egg and oil.
I'm of the opinion that one is not really supposed to taste the mayo on a sandwich, burger, etc. Store brand is often sufficient. It definitely shouldn't over power anything else. That said, I can see where as an ingredient in a recipe, some would be preferable to others. I don't recall the brand, but I know there's one or two that just taste off, like an extra or missing ingredient in the mix.
I despise mayo. My entire family loves to put it on sandwiches it seems. I just don’t understand it.
You can pick out Duke's because it's tangier. Take that one out, and I 100% agree.
Falls solidly in the category of "Yeah, it's better, but not worth the effort" for me, but thanks.
I put mustard and mayo on a hot dog.
Dukes first, Hellmans and Blueplate a close second. My mom made Mayonnaise rolls, it’s nothing but mayonnaise, flour and milk. Best damned rolls you’ve ever tasted.
I bet you can't say that with Coke and Pepsi. Maybe De. Pepper and Mr. Pibb.
I had never heard of Dukes until they sponsored that bowl game. After hearing all the hype about I finally bought some a months ago. fairly disappointing. I’ll be back to Blue Plate next time.
We are a Blue Plate household but McCormick Mayonesa is also pretty good
Any mayo works on a grilled cheese instead of butter
I drink all four of those at times. Pibb and Dr Pepper are very similar. I do think Pibb is just a touch sweeter with less bite than Dr Pepper.
Coke and Pepsi taste nothing alike to me. Cherry Pepsi Zero is one of the best diet drinks out there.
Works great to toast your hamburger buns on a griddle too. I do that when making smash burgers.
Dublin Dr. Pepper used to be the most delicious Dr. Pepper. They used to use pure Cain sugar where every other Dr. Pepper use corn syrup. Too bad Dr. Pepper Snapple Group sued them for trademark and ended it.
how many times have we been thru this, mayo potato salad is straight up garbage.........It's not any good even if you put bacon in it and bacon makes everything better...........
The jar that is never purchased is the best mayo. That stuff is disgusting.
You use mustard for potato salad. Unless you're an old maid or gay. Then you use Hellman's.
Dukes is the go to Mayo for everything else. Except...
A plain tomato sandwich. Then you use Blue Plate ---but only if you have a really tasty right-out-of-your-own-or-someone-you-love's-garden tomato.
If you have a S H I T T Y tomato from Walmart or some other grocer, use Dukes.
Follow me at www.ICANTBELIEVEITSMAYONAISSE.com for more mayo instructions.
Dukes is the go to Mayo for everything else. Except...
A plain tomato sandwich. Then you use Blue Plate ---but only if you have a really tasty right-out-of-your-own-or-someone-you-love's-garden tomato.
If you have a S H I T T Y tomato from Walmart or some other grocer, use Dukes.
Follow me at www.ICANTBELIEVEITSMAYONAISSE.com for more mayo instructions.
Love me some mustard on a hot dog.
I think the same pretty much, we buy the store brand whatever that may be. I don't allow Blue Plate or Miracle Whip in the house though, they are nasty.
I'm a Ranch dressing on the broccoli guy myself, never done just mayo but can see where it wouldn't be bad