OT brokerage platforms...
- Thread starter Handsome Jimmy
- Start date
Schwab all the way as far as mobile apps. It will take some time to get used to because there's so many functions and information at your fingertips, but as you grow into it, it will have all the functions you need as you get more knowledgeable.
Last edited:
I like Fidelity, especially if you don't want to put much in to get started.
I too use Fidelity even though all I have is an S&P 500 index find.
If you are just looking to lose money, I recommend DraftKings.
TradingView platform, IronBeam clearing. get a level 2 data feed
2nd place to Sierra Charts with Teton order routing and Denali data feed, IronBeam clearing
I use Fidelity and it’s simple to navigate for my simple self. I have a second checking account that’s linked to Fidelity for moving money in or out of the account I’ve never had an issue but I just didn’t want our primary joint account linked to a brokerage account.
I used fidelity for years. Had no issues with it. Went to all cash about a week and a half ago to switch to Edward Jones. Looks like I'll be buying back in at a discount. And they say you can't time the market*
I spent an hour chatting with grok today on this very topic.
Based on recent analyses from sources like NerdWallet, StockBrokers.com, Forbes Advisor, and Business Insider, as well as user sentiment and expert reviews up to March 11, 2025, here’s a comparison of the **top five stock trading apps**: **Fidelity Investments**, **Charles Schwab**, **Interactive Brokers**, **Webull**, and **Robinhood**. These apps are frequently highlighted for their strengths across various investor needs—beginners, active traders, and long-term investors alike. I’ll compare them across key factors: **fees**, **features**, **user experience**, **investment options**, and **drawbacks**.
---
### 1. Fidelity Investments
- **Fees**: $0 for stock/ETF trades, $0.65 per options contract. No account minimums or maintenance fees. Fractional share trades start at $1.
- **Features**: Robust research (20+ third-party providers), extensive educational content, Fidelity Spire (goal-oriented app), Fidelity Youth (teen accounts), and 24/7 customer support. Offers commission-free ETFs and two 0% expense ratio funds.
- **User Experience**: Highly rated (4.8/5 Apple Store, 4.6/5 Google Play). Intuitive yet feature-rich, though some find the interface cluttered due to its depth.
- **Investment Options**: Stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, bonds, options, fractional shares, limited crypto (Bitcoin/Ether). Strong retirement planning tools (IRAs, 401(k) integration).
- **Drawbacks**: Limited crypto offerings. Advanced charting lags behind competitors like thinkorswim or Interactive Brokers. Android users report occasional biometric login issues.
---
### 2. Charles Schwab
- **Fees**: $0 for stock/ETF trades, $0.65 per options contract. No minimums or maintenance fees. Margin rates competitive (e.g., 11.825% for $25K-$49K balances).
- **Features**: Includes thinkorswim (acquired from TD Ameritrade) for advanced traders with 350+ technical studies. Schwab Assistant (voice commands), extensive research, and banking integration (checking accounts, ATM rebates).
- **User Experience**: 4.8/5 Apple Store, 2.5/5 Google Play. Praised for accessibility, but Android performance is less consistent. Testers note a learning curve for beginners on thinkorswim.
- **Investment Options**: Stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, futures, forex, options, fractional shares (Schwab Stock Slices, min. $5). No direct crypto trading.
- **Drawbacks**: App suite can feel fragmented (Schwab Mobile vs. thinkorswim). Less intuitive for novices compared to Fidelity. No crypto hurts appeal for younger traders.
---
### 3. Interactive Brokers (IBKR)
- **Fees**: $0 for stock/ETF trades, $0.65 per options contract (volume discounts available). No account minimum, but $25K required for pattern day trading.
- **Features**: Three apps (IBKR Mobile, GlobalTrader, Impact) for different needs. Advanced tools include 200+ news/research services, ESG dashboard, and fast trade execution. Supports nine languages.
- **User Experience**: 4.5/5+ from testers for UX, but the app’s complexity can overwhelm beginners. Website navigation is jargon-heavy.
- **Investment Options**: Stocks, ETFs, options, futures, forex, commodities, bonds, fractional shares, crypto. Unmatched global market access (50+ exchanges).
- **Drawbacks**: Steep learning curve and less beginner-friendly education. Research selection is vast but not as curated as Fidelity’s.
---
### 4. Webull
- **Fees**: $0 for stock/ETF trades, $0 options fees (no per-contract charge). No minimums. Margin rates higher (e.g., 9.49% for $25K-$50K).
- **Features**: Advanced charting, paper trading, 500+ learning courses, AI-generated news, and high interest on uninvested cash (up to 4.5% APY). Clean, trader-focused design.
- **User Experience**: Highly intuitive, praised for simplicity (4.7/5 Apple Store, 4.2/5 Google Play). Ideal for mobile-first traders, though some report app glitches.
- **Investment Options**: Stocks, ETFs, options, fractional shares, crypto, micro futures. No mutual funds or bonds.
- **Drawbacks**: Limited research (fewer providers than Fidelity/Schwab). No mutual funds or robust retirement tools. Higher margin costs deter leveraged traders.
---
### 5. Robinhood
- **Fees**: $0 for stock/ETF/options trades (no per-contract fee). No minimums. Robinhood Gold ($5/month) unlocks 1-3% IRA match and higher instant deposits.
- **Features**: Streamlined app, fractional shares (min. $1), IPO access, high cash interest (4.9% APY with Gold), 24/5 trading. Gamified experience appeals to newbies.
- **User Experience**: 4.2/5+ across stores, lauded for simplicity but criticized for occasional crashes and identity verification delays. Polarizing due to its casual vibe.
- **Investment Options**: Stocks, ETFs, options, fractional shares, crypto. No mutual funds or bonds.
- **Drawbacks**: Weak research/education (little third-party content). Customer support lags (callback only). Not suited for advanced traders or retirement focus.
---
### Key Insights
- **Best for Beginners**: **Fidelity** and **Robinhood** shine. Fidelity offers education and retirement tools, while Robinhood’s simplicity and $1 minimum draw novices. Schwab’s thinkorswim is less beginner-friendly.
- **Best for Active Traders**: **Interactive Brokers** and **Webull** lead with advanced tools and low/no options fees. Schwab’s thinkorswim is a contender but lacks crypto.
- **Best for Long-Term Investors**: **Fidelity** and **Schwab** excel with mutual funds, retirement options, and research depth. Robinhood and Webull lack these.
- **Cost-Conscious**: **Webull** and **Robinhood** eliminate options fees entirely, beating Fidelity, Schwab, and IBKR’s $0.65/contract.
- **Versatility**: **Fidelity** and **Interactive Brokers** offer the widest investment range, while Webull and Robinhood are narrower.
---
### Conclusion
- **Fidelity** is the top all-rounder, balancing cost, features, and accessibility.
- **Schwab** competes closely, especially for traders with thinkorswim, but lacks crypto.
- **Interactive Brokers** dominates for advanced/global trading but isn’t beginner-friendly.
- **Webull** is a low-cost gem for active traders, though limited in scope.
- **Robinhood** wins for ease and entry-level appeal but falls short on depth.
Your choice depends on your goals: Fidelity for a broad foundation, Schwab or IBKR for trading power, Webull for cost savings, or Robinhood for a quick start.
Based on recent analyses from sources like NerdWallet, StockBrokers.com, Forbes Advisor, and Business Insider, as well as user sentiment and expert reviews up to March 11, 2025, here’s a comparison of the **top five stock trading apps**: **Fidelity Investments**, **Charles Schwab**, **Interactive Brokers**, **Webull**, and **Robinhood**. These apps are frequently highlighted for their strengths across various investor needs—beginners, active traders, and long-term investors alike. I’ll compare them across key factors: **fees**, **features**, **user experience**, **investment options**, and **drawbacks**.
---
### 1. Fidelity Investments
- **Fees**: $0 for stock/ETF trades, $0.65 per options contract. No account minimums or maintenance fees. Fractional share trades start at $1.
- **Features**: Robust research (20+ third-party providers), extensive educational content, Fidelity Spire (goal-oriented app), Fidelity Youth (teen accounts), and 24/7 customer support. Offers commission-free ETFs and two 0% expense ratio funds.
- **User Experience**: Highly rated (4.8/5 Apple Store, 4.6/5 Google Play). Intuitive yet feature-rich, though some find the interface cluttered due to its depth.
- **Investment Options**: Stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, bonds, options, fractional shares, limited crypto (Bitcoin/Ether). Strong retirement planning tools (IRAs, 401(k) integration).
- **Drawbacks**: Limited crypto offerings. Advanced charting lags behind competitors like thinkorswim or Interactive Brokers. Android users report occasional biometric login issues.
---
### 2. Charles Schwab
- **Fees**: $0 for stock/ETF trades, $0.65 per options contract. No minimums or maintenance fees. Margin rates competitive (e.g., 11.825% for $25K-$49K balances).
- **Features**: Includes thinkorswim (acquired from TD Ameritrade) for advanced traders with 350+ technical studies. Schwab Assistant (voice commands), extensive research, and banking integration (checking accounts, ATM rebates).
- **User Experience**: 4.8/5 Apple Store, 2.5/5 Google Play. Praised for accessibility, but Android performance is less consistent. Testers note a learning curve for beginners on thinkorswim.
- **Investment Options**: Stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, futures, forex, options, fractional shares (Schwab Stock Slices, min. $5). No direct crypto trading.
- **Drawbacks**: App suite can feel fragmented (Schwab Mobile vs. thinkorswim). Less intuitive for novices compared to Fidelity. No crypto hurts appeal for younger traders.
---
### 3. Interactive Brokers (IBKR)
- **Fees**: $0 for stock/ETF trades, $0.65 per options contract (volume discounts available). No account minimum, but $25K required for pattern day trading.
- **Features**: Three apps (IBKR Mobile, GlobalTrader, Impact) for different needs. Advanced tools include 200+ news/research services, ESG dashboard, and fast trade execution. Supports nine languages.
- **User Experience**: 4.5/5+ from testers for UX, but the app’s complexity can overwhelm beginners. Website navigation is jargon-heavy.
- **Investment Options**: Stocks, ETFs, options, futures, forex, commodities, bonds, fractional shares, crypto. Unmatched global market access (50+ exchanges).
- **Drawbacks**: Steep learning curve and less beginner-friendly education. Research selection is vast but not as curated as Fidelity’s.
---
### 4. Webull
- **Fees**: $0 for stock/ETF trades, $0 options fees (no per-contract charge). No minimums. Margin rates higher (e.g., 9.49% for $25K-$50K).
- **Features**: Advanced charting, paper trading, 500+ learning courses, AI-generated news, and high interest on uninvested cash (up to 4.5% APY). Clean, trader-focused design.
- **User Experience**: Highly intuitive, praised for simplicity (4.7/5 Apple Store, 4.2/5 Google Play). Ideal for mobile-first traders, though some report app glitches.
- **Investment Options**: Stocks, ETFs, options, fractional shares, crypto, micro futures. No mutual funds or bonds.
- **Drawbacks**: Limited research (fewer providers than Fidelity/Schwab). No mutual funds or robust retirement tools. Higher margin costs deter leveraged traders.
---
### 5. Robinhood
- **Fees**: $0 for stock/ETF/options trades (no per-contract fee). No minimums. Robinhood Gold ($5/month) unlocks 1-3% IRA match and higher instant deposits.
- **Features**: Streamlined app, fractional shares (min. $1), IPO access, high cash interest (4.9% APY with Gold), 24/5 trading. Gamified experience appeals to newbies.
- **User Experience**: 4.2/5+ across stores, lauded for simplicity but criticized for occasional crashes and identity verification delays. Polarizing due to its casual vibe.
- **Investment Options**: Stocks, ETFs, options, fractional shares, crypto. No mutual funds or bonds.
- **Drawbacks**: Weak research/education (little third-party content). Customer support lags (callback only). Not suited for advanced traders or retirement focus.
---
### Key Insights
- **Best for Beginners**: **Fidelity** and **Robinhood** shine. Fidelity offers education and retirement tools, while Robinhood’s simplicity and $1 minimum draw novices. Schwab’s thinkorswim is less beginner-friendly.
- **Best for Active Traders**: **Interactive Brokers** and **Webull** lead with advanced tools and low/no options fees. Schwab’s thinkorswim is a contender but lacks crypto.
- **Best for Long-Term Investors**: **Fidelity** and **Schwab** excel with mutual funds, retirement options, and research depth. Robinhood and Webull lack these.
- **Cost-Conscious**: **Webull** and **Robinhood** eliminate options fees entirely, beating Fidelity, Schwab, and IBKR’s $0.65/contract.
- **Versatility**: **Fidelity** and **Interactive Brokers** offer the widest investment range, while Webull and Robinhood are narrower.
---
### Conclusion
- **Fidelity** is the top all-rounder, balancing cost, features, and accessibility.
- **Schwab** competes closely, especially for traders with thinkorswim, but lacks crypto.
- **Interactive Brokers** dominates for advanced/global trading but isn’t beginner-friendly.
- **Webull** is a low-cost gem for active traders, though limited in scope.
- **Robinhood** wins for ease and entry-level appeal but falls short on depth.
Your choice depends on your goals: Fidelity for a broad foundation, Schwab or IBKR for trading power, Webull for cost savings, or Robinhood for a quick start.
I discounted Webull out of the box because it had ties to CCP.
Schwab was dropped for complete lack of crypto. I don't do crypto but I might want to one day.
I did further chatting with grok about the other 3. Including past fines and scandals etc. plus discussions about IPO access from each.
in the end, fidelity probably is best but gives no access to IPOs unless you're rich.
Robinhood offers everything I'm looking for but they have the red flag from their GameStop scandal which I feel like they've probably resolved.
I havn't picked one yet. I don't have a lot extra. Most of my stuff is just mutual funds in 401k and IRA but I want to dabble in direct stocks now.
Hope this helps on your search.
Schwab was dropped for complete lack of crypto. I don't do crypto but I might want to one day.
I did further chatting with grok about the other 3. Including past fines and scandals etc. plus discussions about IPO access from each.
in the end, fidelity probably is best but gives no access to IPOs unless you're rich.
Robinhood offers everything I'm looking for but they have the red flag from their GameStop scandal which I feel like they've probably resolved.
I havn't picked one yet. I don't have a lot extra. Most of my stuff is just mutual funds in 401k and IRA but I want to dabble in direct stocks now.
Hope this helps on your search.
what they did during that time was unethical, but I’m sure they wouldn’t do anything like that again if it helped their owners make money.
They also make money by selling their user buy and sell volume information. And it's perfectly legal for them to do it. Being a retail broker, your orders are filled slightly behind "Direct Access Brokers" orders, and the DAB AI agents use volume information that they buy from brokers like Robinhood to make trade decisions and fill those orders ahead of retail orders. Like all low or no fee brokers, when something's free, you're the product. An example of a direct access broker would be be Interactive Brokers or Lightspeed. I use a direct access broker, fwiw. It's something to consider, but not a huge deal unless you're scalping or swing trading. For buy and hold, I wouldn't worry about using a free or low commission service.
Last edited:
I have the Edward Jones app as well because that where all my retirement Accounts are but I really don’t like their app for trading . Fidelity is definitely easier to navigate, at least for me, and Fidelity seems faster and more up to date on stuff than EJ. Could just be me and what I’m used to.
I've always used Fidelity. No particular reason other than well established and it is what I picked a long time ago. No complaints.
Since you did not have any problems with Fidelity, what is the reason for moving?
All of the platforms had big fines for various scandals, I just remembered Robinhood from that incident which is what made me ask grok about any scandals. I agree it was BS. That's when I discovered webull was Chinese owned.
I just assume everyone is trying to rip me off or sell my info so im never shocked. If my account ever gets over a 4 figures I'll probably look for a more robust platform.
I left the company I was with who's 401k was set up with fidelity. A friend works for Edward Jones so I transferred everything to him. Our friendship is on the line now, I told him I want to retire at 45, the ball is in his court*
Tell him you have CD risk tolerance level but you expect S&P 500 returns...or else...
If anyone wants to walk me through how close my Robinhood account, please hit me up. Yes, I fell for Elon's Doge Coin pump and dump from the Super Bowl a few years back.
I'm not even sure I can open an account (no US phone number) much less help with closing one. Also, if Elon scammed you, that's on you, not Robinhood.
Can you not just withdraw all your money from it? There is also probably an option on Schwab the transfer accounts. You may be able to tell them the stock account at Robin Hood and let them handle the transfer. That’s how it worked for me when I moved from TD Ameritrade to fidelity a few years ago.