OT: Window Replacement in Omaha

KiewitHusker

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2016
16
8
3
Hi everyone,

Looking for suggestions on the best place (price and quality) to go to get new windows for house. I have had a quote from Americas Best Choice and seemed reasonable price but not sure of there quality. Would love any suggestions or advice given. Thanks and Merry Christmas!
 

forNU

All-Conference
Dec 15, 2004
5,139
2,504
0
Hi everyone,

Looking for suggestions on the best place (price and quality) to go to get new windows for house. I have had a quote from Americas Best Choice and seemed reasonable price but not sure of there quality. Would love any suggestions or advice given. Thanks and Merry Christmas!

Only suggestion I can offer. Avoid Pella at all cost. Just had two windows replaced ($9500 BTW) horrendous experience.
 

96WCDC

Redshirt
Sep 30, 2016
60
39
17
Interesting....we have had Pella windows replacements and have had no problems. We wanted the blinds in the glass and Pella is the only one that has that feature. The most important aspect of window replacement is the quality of the installation. Some guys are hacks while others actually care about their workmanship. Material wise you pay for the better quality windows in the number of panes and treatment for UV rays and like 3 of our Pella windows with the retractable screens. The other factor is how long you plan on living in the home. A guy can go cheap if he's looking to sell in the near future or look at it as an investment if staying for the duration.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SeaOfRed75
Nov 19, 2002
6,755
474
0
Hi everyone,

Looking for suggestions on the best place (price and quality) to go to get new windows for house. I have had a quote from Americas Best Choice and seemed reasonable price but not sure of there quality. Would love any suggestions or advice given. Thanks and Merry Christmas!

Quality will be lacking with America's Best Choice. The big thing is are they doing full replacement windows or pocket windows?

I have access to Anderson, MArvin, and Pella. All have quality that far exceeds America's best Choice.
 

forNU

All-Conference
Dec 15, 2004
5,139
2,504
0
Interesting....we have had Pella windows replacements and have had no problems. We wanted the blinds in the glass and Pella is the only one that has that feature. The most important aspect of window replacement is the quality of the installation. Some guys are hacks while others actually care about their workmanship. Material wise you pay for the better quality windows in the number of panes and treatment for UV rays and like 3 of our Pella windows with the retractable screens. The other factor is how long you plan on living in the home. A guy can go cheap if he's looking to sell in the near future or look at it as an investment if staying for the duration.

Thought the same. Pellas reputation sold me. They use subcontractors to install. They measured incorrectly twice. Finally got a poorly installed window that was a shade lighter than I picked. 4 months later, still no resolution. I'd probably opt for a company that has installations done by said company. I'm learning the hard way, regretfully.
 

KiewitHusker

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2016
16
8
3
Pretty sure ABC is doing pocket replacement and not new construction replacement windows. I had a quote in spring decided to wait and now thinking I might go through with it and get new windows my old windows have moisture issues in the glass panes.
 

Cloud_a_Heart

All-Conference
Aug 13, 2005
3,045
1,304
0
I have replaced thousands of windows, put myself through college because of siding, windows, and decks. I still install about a dozen a year for our vacation fund. I am adamant about using vinyl replacement windows. Wood rots, period.

Have the person that is going to install your windows, measure and order the windows. Asking for trouble when a salesman does it and then has subcontractors install, in my opinion/experience.

A good standard sized window can run between $175-$350, depending on what bells and whistles you desire. Install with insulation, caulking and reusing trim on the inside runs $75-$150 depending on type of old windows (window weights, brick, stucco). I used to charge $50 a window to cap the outside with aluminum that I bent with my break, but aluminum prices went up and now I charge $70. So depending on size, on most standard houses, I can tell the owners that I can replace their windows for about $400 a hole if they order quality windows without lots of fancy (like blinds between panes).

Lots of options, but don't just jump into a deal with the first pella or Anderson salesman that comes to your house saying that they are going to give a "deal" and knock $400 a window off and go from $1250 to $850... Don't fall for that crap. Get a contractor..... Most love to have a side job that will take three days (a couple of weekends) and still put a grand in their pocket.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SOHusker11

Woodland Parker

Redshirt
Feb 2, 2016
26
11
0
I have replaced thousands of windows, put myself through college because of siding, windows, and decks. I still install about a dozen a year for our vacation fund. I am adamant about using vinyl replacement windows. Wood rots, period.

Have the person that is going to install your windows, measure and order the windows. Asking for trouble when a salesman does it and then has subcontractors install, in my opinion/experience.

A good standard sized window can run between $175-$350, depending on what bells and whistles you desire. Install with insulation, caulking and reusing trim on the inside runs $75-$150 depending on type of old windows (window weights, brick, stucco). I used to charge $50 a window to cap the outside with aluminum that I bent with my break, but aluminum prices went up and now I charge $70. So depending on size, on most standard houses, I can tell the owners that I can replace their windows for about $400 a hole if they order quality windows without lots of fancy (like blinds between panes).

Lots of options, but don't just jump into a deal with the first pella or Anderson salesman that comes to your house saying that they are going to give a "deal" and knock $400 a window off and go from $1250 to $850... Don't fall for that crap. Get a contractor..... Most love to have a side job that will take three days (a couple of weekends) and still put a grand in their pocket.
You're talking about pockets as well, correct?
 

Cloud_a_Heart

All-Conference
Aug 13, 2005
3,045
1,304
0
You're talking about pockets as well, correct?

Yes... But even for new construction I still use about the same product only WITH a nailing flange around it. The nail flange can be cut off and used just like a pocket insert as well. It depends on how you want your finish to look both inside and out.
 

KiewitHusker

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2016
16
8
3
Yes... But even for new construction I still use about the same product only WITH a nailing flange around it. The nail flange can be cut off and used just like a pocket insert as well. It depends on how you want your finish to look both inside and out.
So can you explain the difference between pocket and new construction replacement regarding appearance of it on the inside and outside of the house. For example what is all remove during the process of both? Thanks for the info in your previous post it was very helpful! Do you have any recommendations of contractors to use? We do not plan on living at our current house forever so the windows do not need to be top of the line just better then what we have which is probably original to the house which was built in late 80's
 

KiewitHusker

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2016
16
8
3
Also being that is it winter do companies typically offer discounts to incentivize people to get windows during their slow season?
 

Cloud_a_Heart

All-Conference
Aug 13, 2005
3,045
1,304
0
My goal is to not have to do ANYThing to the inside of the house: Carefully taking off trim to reuse, pulling the nails through the back side with a vise grips, and not damaging the paint. Even when measuring for the replacement windows, you need to take off a few pieces of trim to see what you are getting into and how thick the jams are, so you know how big to order your windows.

The outside may require some 1x4 to be ripped and capped to make the outside both water tight and pleasing to the eye and maintenance free! If your walls are constructed using 2x4 or 2x6 is also something that may dictate how the outside is finished.

If your house was built in the 80s it should be pretty straight forward without weird dimension sashes, jams, or window weights so it should be an easy install.

I would recommend double hung windows that can be tilted in so that you can clean both the inside and outside of the window from the inside! Good selling point for resale.

I don't know of sales or seasonal deals... But I do know you won't get the best contractors starting in about May. They are swamped with bigger projects. I would order in the next month, the windows take 6 weeks on average to arrive, and then have them installed sometime in March as you don't want to do it when it's freezing and have your home open for hours.

Gotta run for Christmas meal! Happy holidays!
 

Rider

Senior
Jan 22, 2005
1,166
526
113
Hi everyone,

Looking for suggestions on the best place (price and quality) to go to get new windows for house. I have had a quote from Americas Best Choice and seemed reasonable price but not sure of there quality. Would love any suggestions or advice given. Thanks and Merry Christmas!

Marvin windows. Great. Installed mine myself. 15 windows and they are great.