Possible Defensive Depth Chart

Feb 11, 2013
275
0
0
What do y'all think? Did I forget anyone? I like the depth we are accumulating, but the D-Line has major question marks. We better hope Quay and Nick James are in shape enough to play 3/4 of the game. I think Chris Jones has a chance to do this as a freshman.

SDE: D. Autry, Torrey Bell, AJ Jefferson, John Harris
WDE: Preston Smith or Chris Jones, Ryan Brown, Corvell Harrison

DT: Eulls or Juco DT signee or Virges, N. Adams
NT: PJ Jones or Quay or Nick James, Jordan Washington

SLB: Matt Wells or Skinner, Zach Jackson
WLB: Chris Hughes or Benny Brown, K.Market
MLB: McKinney, Richie Brown, Bohanna, C. Holmes

BCB: Love or Calhoun, Myles
FCB: Giles or Redmond, Cleveland
FS: Nickoe, Coman, Antoine,
SS: Cox, Arrington, Hughes, B. Wells

I've been reading this board since it started and have never posted. I would really hate to see my first comment come from RailinJemmye, so please someone else beat him to it.
 

MzTerry

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
97
0
0
No way Richie Brown doesn't start at one of those linebacker spots. Quay will start - may not matter, I'm sure our top 3 will get equivalent PT with the 4th and 5th DTs getting about half the time the first 3 get, but Quay will get starter reps. I'd like to see P.J. and Quay in together on passing downs. Ryan Brown over Preston Smith.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,396
33,172
113
How can you possibly say there's no way a redshirt who has never played a snap won't start?
 

MzTerry

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
97
0
0
he has the best combination of size, speed, and strength and he is the smartest (not saying this because he is white, but because he is smart)

McKinney started last year and there has been even more buzz around Brown than McKinney, so don't tell me a RsFR can't start on this team.

watch his film. what did you see that was so great from our LB corps last year that makes you think there is some huge hurdle to earning a starting spot?
 
Last edited:

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
61,396
33,172
113
I never said he can't start. Just that you're going way too far in saying there's no way he won't. I'm not saying he's a Gene's Page All-American and at this point I have no reason to think that he is. But none of us has ever seen him play a snap. We don't have a 17ing clue how good he's going to be, especially not as a redshirt freshman. All we know is he wasn't good enough to see playing time last year or he wouldn't have redshirted. How many players have we seen hyped up all over this page who turned out to not be any good at all? Plenty. Let's hope he winds up on the list of players who turned out to be as good as or better than expected and not on the other list.
 

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
he has the best combination of size, speed, and strength and he is the smartest (not saying this because he is white, but because he is smart)

McKinney started last year and there has been even more buzz around Brown than McKinney, so don't tell me a RsFR can't start on this team.

watch his film. what did you see that was so great from our LB corps last year that makes you think there is some huge hurdle to earning a starting spot?

R, Brown is not going to start in 2013

Our starting LB's are likely going to be Skinner, McKinney, and Wells

Why will Brown not start? Because he is competing against a 2 year starter and a Freshman AA for playing time- thats why. He wont overtake either of those. I'm not saying Richie wont be a good player- but he wont take Skinner or McKinney out of the starting line-up
 

MzTerry

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
97
0
0
Makes you wonder what I'm looking at? I'm looking at a sub-SEC caliber linebacking corps and hoping a player of superior talent steps up. McKinney got some tackles, yes, but he got burnt repeatedly. I still think he could be a good one, but I think we need another year before the jury is out on that one. If he doesn't show marked improvement I hope they beef him up and make him a defensive end because I do think he has great athletic ability for someone his size.

I think they didn't want to waste a year of Richie's eligibility playing special teams when we were deep and he didn't know the defense (if he could have come in for spring last year, I do not think he would have redshirted). I also have NO faith in Wilson's ability to make personnel decisions last year (see Cherrington). If he doesn't start then to me he is already on that list of underperforming 4 stars under our current regime. This has nothing to do with an all-genespage team, this has to do with our coaches reporting on his practice, his measurables, and his film.

If cary hudson's depth chart holds then we will have a terrible front 7 next year. Need someone to step up and BE BETTER THAN Eulls (I don't understand why people think moving him underneath is the answer, I just think he is a bust - hope I'm wrong) and need someone to step up at linebacker. Hopefully Wells is good enough to earn more consistent playing time and has continued to bulk up.

To go with your point, when has Chris Hughes proven to be anything but inconsistent? If we start two linebackers under 225 (Wells and Hughes) we are in big trouble.

We should expect more talented players to develop and earn reps over inferior players.
 

Will James

Redshirt
Feb 11, 2013
1,342
0
0
Makes you wonder what I'm looking at? I'm looking at a sub-SEC caliber linebacking corps and hoping a player of superior talent steps up.

Hopefully an improved DL will allow them to perform better than this year. Hard to make plays with no pressure on the QB up front.
 

MzTerry

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
97
0
0
freshman awards have everything to do with reps and you all know that.

You said McKinney and Skinner - thats only two linebackers and last I checked we start 3 (although I disagree and think he could easily take a spot from McKinney).
 

MzTerry

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
97
0
0
I completely agree. However, I think Wells (who I love and hope he plays up to his potential this year) at this point has not proved to be an every down linebacker and McKinney got exposed big time in coverage.
 

skb124

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2008
1,270
0
0
We ran a zone and got no pressure on the QB

Every defensive player we had looked bad in coverage last year. Mckinney was asked to cover Cobi Hamilton too. Wouldn't fault him for that.
 

FISHDAWG

Redshirt
Dec 27, 2009
2,077
0
36
Makes you wonder what I'm looking at? I'm looking at a sub-SEC caliber linebacking corps and hoping a player of superior talent steps up. McKinney got some tackles, yes, but he got burnt repeatedly. I still think he could be a good one, but I think we need another year before the jury is out on that one. If he doesn't show marked improvement I hope they beef him up and make him a defensive end because I do think he has great athletic ability for someone his size.

I think they didn't want to waste a year of Richie's eligibility playing special teams when we were deep and he didn't know the defense (if he could have come in for spring last year, I do not think he would have redshirted). I also have NO faith in Wilson's ability to make personnel decisions last year (see Cherrington). If he doesn't start then to me he is already on that list of underperforming 4 stars under our current regime. This has nothing to do with an all-genespage team, this has to do with our coaches reporting on his practice, his measurables, and his film.

If cary hudson's depth chart holds then we will have a terrible front 7 next year. Need someone to step up and BE BETTER THAN Eulls (I don't understand why people think moving him underneath is the answer, I just think he is a bust - hope I'm wrong) and need someone to step up at linebacker. Hopefully Wells is good enough to earn more consistent playing time and has continued to bulk up.

To go with your point, when has Chris Hughes proven to be anything but inconsistent? If we start two linebackers under 225 (Wells and Hughes) we are in big trouble.

We should expect more talented players to develop and earn reps over inferior players.

GOATS TWIN BROTHER ???
 

MzTerry

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
97
0
0
I'm "assuming" he will play over Wells/Hughes. I think he could also play over McKinney. Brown's as much of a freak as McKinney. 6-2 237 4.5.
 

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
freshman awards have everything to do with reps and you all know that.

You said McKinney and Skinner - thats only two linebackers and last I checked we start 3 (although I disagree and think he could easily take a spot from McKinney).

I noted those two guys because that is his competition. McKinney is freakish athlete that was still learning the position last season. He is going to be the MLB and from accounts we will move Skinner to Cam's spot because of size and speed. Then Wells will play the WLB spot to add more speed to the LB's to play against all these 3 and 4 WR sets.

Brown is going to be good- and he will definitely play. But he is not going to replace a 2 yr Sr starter in Skinner or an athletic Fresh AA MLB in McKinney
 

Coach34

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2012
20,283
1
0
I'm "assuming" he will play over Wells/Hughes. I think he could also play over McKinney. Brown's as much of a freak as McKinney. 6-2 237 4.5.

No- we are not going to play Ritchie to move out and cover slot WR's- he's going to play inside like McKinney and Skinner will- Wells will be on the field for coverage purposes due to his speed and athleticism
 

MzTerry

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
97
0
0
So you think Cherrington was good? You think Eulls was good? You think we couldnt upgrade from Preston Smith? You think Wells was consistent? You think McKinney is a lock for All-SEC and never got burnt last year?

I think Eulls will be BETTER inside, but I hope Quay is better than Eulls or else I think that probably means our d-line didn't improve much. I hope Wells will be more consistent. I hope McKinney gets quicker (which some of that will come with him also continuing to learn and get comfortable on the defensive side of the ball) and improves in coverage.

Please tell me, king of the homer's fishdawg, what you disagree with from that post instead of trying to be sixpack cool?

Bottom line is if one of the browns or quay or jiles or someone doesn't step up then I think we will have some problems.
 

MzTerry

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
97
0
0
I can buy this argument coupled with Wells to provide coverage, but I don't think playing Richie sacrifices much in coverage.

I will just personally be surprised if he isn't a starter by the end of the season.

Also, thank you for providing an actual argument instead of something alluding to our past busts having something to do with R Brown not starting.
 

FISHDAWG

Redshirt
Dec 27, 2009
2,077
0
36
I'll take experience over an unproven @ LB anyday ... what makes you think it was ALL on the player ? ... several schemes mandate the DT's keep opposing OLmen off the linebackers, maybe this was Cherringtons task or maybe he just wasn't a good player ... but what does make sense is the coaching staff knows these players and their abilities much more than your dumbass does ..... 6-pack cool ???
 
Feb 11, 2013
275
0
0
To go with your point, when has Chris Hughes proven to be anything but inconsistent? If we start two linebackers under 225 (Wells and Hughes) we are in big trouble.

Against Okie St., A&M, the Rebelz, and spread teams I hope we have Hughes and Wells out there. Good open field tacklers. Skinner, McKinney, Wells against Aubie, Bama, LSU and non-gimmick run-first offenses.
 

skb124

Redshirt
Jul 20, 2008
1,270
0
0
I just want to throw this out there though that my comments are no shot at Richie's abilities. I'm very excited about him playing this year, I just believe that it will be tough for him to crack the starting rotation with what we have returning. I think he will definitely contribute, but he has to earn his due.
 

kired

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2008
7,192
2,655
113
Here's my best shot. I just listed 11 starters & who I think will be the main backups in SEC play. Biggest difference is that I put Cox at CB. I have no idea where he'll play. But I think we let Hughes & Arrington battle it out for the safety spot opposite Whitley. That third LB spot will be tricky - I haven't been overly impressed with Wells or Hughes. Wells has had flashes, but disappears at times. I thought Preston Smith & Ryan Brown both came on strong last year, and I don't see Chris Jones starting over either of them this year. I missed where Eulls is moving to DT but it makes sense & the board seems to think its a done deal. I still think we have package with him at DE just due to starting there for 2 years.

DE starters: Autry, Smith</SPAN></SPAN>
DE backups: Ryan Brown, Chris Jones, AJ Jefferson, Eulls

DT starters: Eulls, PJ Jones
DT backups: Evans, James, Virges

LB starters: McKinney, Wells, Skinner</SPAN></SPAN>
LB backups: Hughes, Bohanna, Brown & Brown, Jackson

CB starters: Love, Cox</SPAN></SPAN>
CB backup: Jiles, Calhoun, Redmond</SPAN></SPAN>

FS starter: Whitley </SPAN></SPAN>
FS backup: Market </SPAN></SPAN>

SS starter: Hughes</SPAN></SPAN>
SS backup: Arrington</SPAN></SPAN>
 

Coach 57

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
374
0
0
Saw Richie play in bowl prep practices and watched him scrimmage. I'm not screaming from the hill tops he'll start but man McKinney better watch out! He isn't playing around he told Collins a few times "I'm gone sew up that Mike spot!" Ben is a great talent and has incredible size. But to play the mike in the SEC you better have your thinking cap on. Saw many times late in the year offenses were forcing him to make bad reads. Go watch the Arky game, the aTm game and even Troy. Yeah he had alot of tackles because he guessed wrong and got caught trying to get back. I do think he'll start but he better get after it. Richie will be a heck of a player for us.
 

MzTerry

Redshirt
Aug 22, 2012
97
0
0
... but what does make sense is the coaching staff knows these players and their abilities much more than your dumbass does ..... 6-pack cool

sixpack cool is referencing you posting something about goat instead of refuting my post with anything of substance at all.

I think the coaches should know the players abilities much more than my "dumbass" should. This is not me posting halfway into the season and saying "Richie Brown should be starting wtf are the coaches doing"??? This is me responding to someone's projected depth chart which in no way refutes what any coach has ever said about any player.

We didnt have better options than Eulls last year, but I hope we do this year. However, if you think Cherrington should have played a snap then you, sir, are the dumbass. I am saying I know more about a player's ability than the coaching staff" here. The only thing Cherrington kept any o-linemen from doing was looking bad. He got dominated in every facet of the game. Cherrington starting and playing the amount of snaps he played is a great symbol of why Coach Wilson was fired - so Mullen agreed with you that the coaches should've known better.

I think McKinney is good, but I think Skinner is better. I hope Wells is more consistent. I just think Richie Brown is going to be very special. I think Quay, a second year player, should probably develop into a starter over a 2 year underachiever. Kind of my sentiment at several positions although not as extreme of a talent differential btw new guys and old guys.
 

SPMT

Redshirt
Aug 25, 2012
187
0
0
Why in the hell would you play cox at ss? He's too light and too athletic. Put your best athletes at corner and fs. Whitley is currently a terrible fs. He lacks the range that a fs needs and that cox has.
 

esplanade91

Redshirt
Dec 9, 2010
5,656
0
0
SDE: D. Autry, Torrey Bell, AJ Jefferson, John Harris
WDE: Preston Smith or Chris Jones, Ryan Brown, Corvell Harrison

DT: Eulls or Juco DT signee or Virges, N. Adams
NT: PJ Jones or Quay or Nick James, Jordan Washington

SLB: Matt Wells or Skinner, Zach Jackson
WLB: Chris Hughes or Benny Brown, K.Market
MLB: McKinney, Richie Brown, Bohanna, C. Holmes

BCB: Love or Calhoun, Myles
FCB: Giles or Redmond, Cleveland
FS: Nickoe, Coman, Antoine,
SS: Cox, Arrington, Hughes, B. Wells

I agree with everything except for I think Quay plays DT next to James at NT, Market is a safety and already has PT there, and Antoine is ahead of Coman... He's going to be a freak.
 

The Peeper

Heisman
Feb 26, 2008
17,012
12,897
113
I see a lot of talk about Quay but I didn't see anything out of him in mop up duty last year to excite me. I specifically watched him when he was in and he never got manhandled or pushed around. He was able to stand his ground but never seemed to fight off a block and do anything. I hope that was just the rookie in him.
 
Aug 5, 2011
1,222
0
0
Cox will be a starter at CB by mid season...

I don't think Love can get the job done. I think it will be a toss up who starts by mid season at the other CB spot, probably Giles. A lot will have to do with how they perform this spring. Also, McKinney is a beast, no way Brown starts over him. Finally, Wells should have been on the field a lot more this past season, we needed his speed and often times he was MIA.
 

AzzurriDawg4

Redshirt
Nov 11, 2007
3,206
12
38
I actually agree with most of this, but I do think Preston Smith can be a player.

It should become more and more evident what a total waste of oxygen Chris Wilson was last year. I can only hope Collins and Turner turn this unit around. There is a lot of talent to play with on that D-Line. Ryan Brown looks like an outstanding 3rd down specialist, Preston Smith a solid short distance end, Autry the total package. Then you mix in Chris Jones and Dale and you have a really complete group at DE.

I am not sold yet on Eulls being an impact player at DT, as C34 apparently is. Have we seen that he has been definitively moved there by the way? Not being facetious, just havent seen it myself. Eulls couldnt get upfield only trying to get around one guy - hate to see how it works out if he is bracketed. Maybe he beefs up and turns into a run-stuffer, but if he gets snaps at Quays expense, or PJs...I just dont know.

I also believe that McKinney had some major lapses last year, but as a rFR. His potential is immense - but I also thought Skinner would make more of an impact last year. I still think Wells should shed some LBs and play safety. Just gets swallowed up sometimes at LB. He has just been a streaky player to date. Not to say he cant become more consistent.
 

AzzurriDawg4

Redshirt
Nov 11, 2007
3,206
12
38
Is this post for real? I think you were watching someone else.

Quay was the only DT we had that knew how to get in the backfield. I suspect because Wilson hadnt had enough time to screw him up yet.
 
Feb 11, 2013
275
0
0
Why in the hell would you play cox at SS and Whitley at FS.

I've seen Justin Cox play three times. He can drop any RB and cover slot guys. I think he will play closer to the line. If Nickoe is 100% healthy then I could see him playing that role and Cox sliding back to CF. Our CB's will be good enough that we don't need to stick Cox at CB.
 
Maroon and White

Latest

  1. 01 Maroon and White Football Jeff Lebby fires assistants Phil Loadholt and Cliff Odom after Auburn loss
  2. 02 Maroon and White Mississippi State PFF Grades from 41-9 loss to Auburn
  3. 03 Maroon and White Football Lopsided analytics illustrate Mississippi State's collapse against Auburn
  4. 04 Maroon and White Football "Not good enough": Jeff Lebby answers questions of performance and job security following blowout loss to Auburn
  5. 05 Maroon and White Football Rapid Recap: Auburn 41-9 Mississippi State