Q: Which games should happen every year?

ignazio

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2007
3,837
2,878
0
Everyone gets in seeding becomes worthless. Look at Indiana.

I'm reading your post as:
"If everyone gets in, then seeding becomes worthless. Look at Indiana (where everyone is in)."

As we know, Indiana isn't seeded - do you mean no one is trying during the season?
 

Cross Bones

All-Conference
Aug 19, 2001
52,882
3,954
113
I'm reading your post as:
"If everyone gets in, then seeding becomes worthless. Look at Indiana (where everyone is in)."

As we know, Indiana isn't seeded - do you mean no one is trying during the season?
I'm saying it's the result of allowing everyone in. Who knows if they're trying, it doesn't matter if they win.
 
Oct 12, 2017
1,137
680
0
Get rid of cupcake nonconference games. College football has that problem too.

In theory, I agree with the concept. But what is a cupcake? We all know that if LWE schedules a 1A school, that doesn't even make the qualification of being a cupcake - its not even a scrimmage. Lets say LWE schedules Ottawa - 8A power scheduling a bad 5A/6A school = cupcake. But if Wilmington schedules Ottawa (like they did last year), which has almost 1000 more students, is it a cupcake? Wilmo might be favored, but it shouldn't be a cupcake...Unfortunately, under the current system for playoff seeding there is no distinction between Wilmo beating a 1-8 6A Ottawa or a 1-8 1A Iroquois
West...
 

Cat Box

Senior
Sep 23, 2012
1,118
718
0
The new Metro Suburban additions assure a few quality geographic/Protestant-Catholic match-ups, including:

Wheaton Academy v. St. Francis
Aurora Christian v. Aurora Central Catholic

I also like Immaculate Conception v. Bishop McNamara
 

badfrog68

Freshman
Oct 12, 2014
164
61
0
LWW vs PC

about a mile apart (closer than LWC) with a lot of kids that went to grade school together. Would draw great crowds. PC would have the advantage but I think it would be competitive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PanthersWildcats86